I haven‘t read the whole game thread yet, but I‘ve been through the last 3 minutes of the game.
Day should have called his 2 timeouts on defense before the 2-minute stoppage. They would have kicked their FG as the clock went under 2 minutes then, rather than at 1:47. Then tOSU would have had 10 to 12 more seconds and still the 1 timeout. This isn’t Tuesday-morning QB’ing, I was saying ‘call timeout’ it in the stands as the guy was being tackled with 2:12 left.
Regarding the play-calling on the final drive, I thought it was OK. They got to the 28-yard line with 34 seconds left and a timeout. On the next play, Howard threw deep, but the play call wasn’t the problem, it was the read. Gee Scott was open crossing on the 20-yard line and it probably would have gotten a first down, which would have been within range with time to get a little closer and put the ball in the middle before calling the timeout. That decision, followed by the OPI on the next play, were obviously both crucial.
It doesn’t make sense that after a play that was incomplete, stopping the clock, a play that ended up out of bounds (which would stop the clock again) but ends up being penalized and having that down run again, has the clock start before the next snap, but apparently those are the rules. Too bad the ref didn’t say ‘clock will start on my signal’ as he was marking off the penalty, as we often hear. But Day and Howard shouldn’t have allowed 6 seconds to run before the next snap.
And since the 12-men penalty came after the Oregon timeout, it was clearly intentional and the clock should have been put back to 10 seconds as they marked off that penalty, which is up to the judgment of the referee.