• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

QB1 Julian Sayin (National Champion)

Saved.

And I was being negative towards Julian as an FYI.

Is there a clear issue he's had in camp?

And I hope no one took my joke about his size as a real negative. He's only a bit lighter but also taller than Troy was. And Troy took a lot of hits. If the OL is struggling so much that he's getting hit a lot, there are bigger issues.
Upvote 0

2025 scUM Shenanigans, Arguments - NCAA: no wins taken away, no postseason ban

I agree with what he says, but any punishment on the team does not punish the current players, because they are free to transfer out. Maybe not free to transfer at any minute. But they're free in certain windows. And I think a major punishment like that would have opened one of those windows. But if a stud player wants to go to a post-season, win a championship, etc., he can go somewhere else and do that there.
Also, are there not still players from the 2022 and 2023 teams on their roster?
Upvote 0

QB1 Julian Sayin (National Champion)

I want Julian to be great, but don’t underestimate the things that can happen in season.

Day has also said they’ll have packages prepared for Kienholz. And Lincoln is built a little different mentally….i don’t think he’s quite ready to pack his bags.

I’d let this play out a bit more, IMO.
You certainly know more about what goes in with the program than I do, but I've always thought that Sayin was a virtual lock to win the job simply because I've seen no indication that he's a statue to the point where it's a problem, he's widely reported to be more polished with a quicker processor and release than Kienholz, and I don't think that Day will ever prioritize athleticism over those things when choosing a QB unless he has an OL that can't pass protect at all, which seems unlikely, and he has to change everything out of desperation.

I'm not bagging on Kienholz at all, and I think he'll get some decent playing time this year, but barring a significant injury to Sayin (which is certainly always possible) or Sayin just not being as good as we think he will be, he'd be backing up Sayin for two seasons, and that seems unlikely to me, especially if St. Clair shows progress towards being what people say he can be during that time and he's not likely to be the man for his fifth year. At some point, he'll have to look out for himself whether he really wants to or not, and I think that's more likely to be after this season than waiting and seeing if he can beat out St. Clair.
Upvote 0

Game Thread #1 Texas at #2/#3 tOSU, Sat. Aug. 30th, 12pm ET, FOX

What has me confused is arch being tabbed as the best QB in college football. He might be good but wtf is that? I get it’s likely due to his name but I just don’t get that.

He’s got 4 new starters up front, lost his three best WRs and his best RB yet he’s so kind of QB gift from heaven after having played back up snaps as a gadget QB for 2 years?

I don’t get his hype and man I’m tired of hearing about Texas being a given proven thing. Why is no one accounting for all the starters they lost? They may have lost more than we have.
Upvote 0

2025 scUM Shenanigans, Arguments - NCAA: no wins taken away, no postseason ban

I agree with what he says, but any punishment on the team does not punish the current players, because they are free to transfer out. Maybe not free to transfer at any minute. But they're free in certain windows. And I think a major punishment like that would have opened one of those windows. But if a stud player wants to go to a post-season, win a championship, etc., he can go somewhere else and do that there.
Upvote 0

Filter

Back
Top