Player(s) to Watch: Ohio State’s seven returning starters chasing rare repeat
Gene Ross via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here
Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images
The Buckeyes’ small handful of veterans look to lead the way for a second-straight national title.
The phrase has always been that
Ohio State doesn’t rebuild, it only reloads. That theory is going to be put to the ultimate test in 2025, as the Buckeyes return only seven players that started at least half of their games during their national championship season.
Entering the 2024 campaign, Ryan Day saw a ton of his players put off the
NFL Draft for one more year in Columbus, and the result was a roster laden with premier veteran talent. Guys like Jack Sawyer, TreVeyon Henderson, Emeka Egbuka and a handful of others came back with unfinished business, and in a season the players themselves deemed ‘Natty or Bust’, managed to achieve the ultimate goal.
Ultimately, that meant the ensuing offseason would see a mass exodus of supremely important names. Following its national title, Ohio State had 14 players taken in the 2025 NFL Draft — the most of any program and tying a school record set back in 2004. It is the fifth time since 1994 that at least 10 Buckeyes were drafted, and it included four first round picks led by Egbuka at No. 19 and seven players total in the first two rounds.
With so much of last year’s team now gone, it leaves a small handful of guys in the Woody Hayes Athletic Center to lead the charge for a rare national championship repeat. Only seven teams in college football history can lay claim to uncontested back-to-back national titles, with seven others claiming co-championships in at least one of the two seasons.
If the Buckeyes are going to go down in history as one of the elite programs ever to achieve the elusive feat, it will be on the backs of the seven returning players that helped Ohio State reach the top of the mountain in 2024.
That conversation, of course, begins with
Jeremiah Smith. A five-star freshman that entered the season with the loftiest of expectations, Smith shattered even the wildest dreams of what Buckeye Nation thought the elite wide receiver could be.
Smith finished the year with 76 catches for a team-high 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns, including more one-handed grabs and big catch-and-run chunk plays in one season than many guys will have in their entire careers. The Miami Gardens native capped off his scintillating campaign with a 56-yard reception on 3rd-and-11 to effectively ice the national championship game against Notre Dame, finishing the contest with five catches for 88 yards and touchdown.
With a new quarterback in place — likely redshirt freshman Julian Sayin — as well as a new-but-familiar offensive coordinator in Brian Hartline, the ceiling of what Ohio State’s offense can be in 2025 will rely on what an encore performance looks like for the nation’s best wide receiver.
Joining him in making a first-time starting QB’s life easier will be fellow wideout,
Carnell Tate. As the No. 3 guy in the room last year behind Smith and Egbuka, Tate had a breakout sophomore season with 52 catches for 733 yards and four TDs. A former five-star prospect in his own right, the Chicago native made some huge plays for the Buckeyes throughout the year, and should have zero issue seeing his workload increase even further.
Elsewhere on offense, the only other two players that return with any sort of starting experience are offensive linemen
Carson Hinzman and
Tegra Tshabola.
Hinzman made massive strides this past season after a rough 2023 campaign in which he was likely forced into action a year early. Beginning the 2024 season on the bench, Hinzman was thrust into the starting lineup at guard following the injury to Josh Simmons that moved Donovan Jackson to tackle. After the subsequent injury to Seth McLaughlin, Hinzman moved back to his natural position at center and flourished as the starter over the team’s final six games.
On the flip side, Tshabola earned the starting right guard job right out of the gate last season, but ended up in a bit of a time share at the position with Austin Siereveld. Showcasing his versatility and a ton of improvement as the year wore on, Tshabola finished with the third-most snaps of any Ohio State offensive lineman — behind only Jackson and Josh Fryar — and played at least 40 snaps in 11 games and at least 30 snaps in all 16.
While returning only four starters on offense seems troubling, the Buckeyes have a ton of young talent around them to shoulder the load, and will be able to lean on this quartet of experienced guys if times get tough. It is also one more starter than Ohio State returns on defense, which loses eight of 11 starters from 2024, including the entire defensive line.
On the bright side, one of the trio of starters that does return on that side of the ball happens to be the best safety and one of the best overall defensive players in college football in
Caleb Downs.
Transferring in from Alabama following SEC Freshman of the Year and Shaun Alexander National Freshman of the Year honors in year one with the Crimson Tide, Downs followed up his stellar debut campaign with a dominant sophomore season at Ohio State. The do-it-all safety racked up 82 tackles, eight tackles for loss, two interceptions, six pass breakups and half a sack playing in the middle of the Buckeyes’ defense.
Even more than the counting stats, which were impressive in their own right, was what Downs allowed defensive coordinator Jim Knowles to do with the rest of the defense. Downs played a hybrid middle linebacker/safety role with the Buckeyes, and made his presence felt on nearly every play whether it be a run or pass. The unanimous First Team All-American will now be expected to help lead a new Ohio State defense under Matt Patricia as, effectively, a coach on the field.
Joining him in the backfield will be a pair of familiar faces in
Sonny Styles and
Davison Igbinosun.
Styles became a completely different guy by the end of the season in his first full year at linebacker, having moved down from his initial role at safety. Following some early struggles, Styles emerged as one of Ohio State’s best defensive players, finishing second on the team behind Cody Simon with 100 tackles to go along with 11 TFLs and six sacks. A special athlete with another offseason under James Laurinaitis, the Buckeyes will be expecting big things from Styles as a senior.
Igbinosun was a tale of two players in his second year with Ohio State after transferring in from Ole Miss. When he was at his best, he was leading the Buckeyes with nine pass breakups to add to 45 tackles and a pair of interceptions. When he wasn’t, his physical style of play led to far too many pass interference penalties. Iggy is a dominant coverage cornerback and came up clutch in some really big moments, he just needs to figure out a way to clean up on those seemingly weekly calls in this his senior season.
With an entirely new group up front, Downs, Igbinsoun and Styles will be relied upon to carry the torch in the back seven. There are a bunch of players around them that have logged a good deal of valuable reps, with guys like defensive end Kenyatta Jackson Jr., linebacker Arvell Reese and cornerback Jermaine Mathews Jr. all playing more than 300 snaps in 2024, but losing eight starters could still be tough to overcome early on.
At the end of the day, this Ohio State team is still choc full of high four and five-star players that are more than capable of getting the job done. It will be a very different Buckeyes team than the one that relied on a large group of returning seniors to win the national title last season, but one that features a number of new breakout stars and can look to its seven returnees for guidance along the way.
Continue reading...