Very much a trend in middle/high. We have had several “held back” in order to gain that experience in age. Yet to see conclusive evidence it’s beneficial. One would think if you do it it’s because your son socially/mentally would benefit. That is not the case I’m seeing….
I would strongly disagree. I’ll provide a small list of successful 19 year old graduates who were 19 their freshman year of college for us at Ohio state.
Cardale Jones – National Championship QB
Ted Ginn Jr. – 1st-round NFL Draft pick
Vernon Gholston – Dominant DE; Top-10 NFL Draft pick
Michael Thomas – All-time Buckeye WR great; NFL All-Pro
Chris “Beanie” Wells – Immediate impact RB; 1st-round NFL Draft pick
Braxton Miller – 2× Big Ten POTY
Dwayne Haskins Jr. – Heisman finalist, OSU records
Jack Sawyer – cornerstone edge defender and national champion; draft pick
Garrett Wilson –NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year
J.T. Tuimoloau – impact DL from day one
Could provide probably dozens more with ample research. From the results of our successful history at OSU, taking as you phrased them “ hold backs” has worked out well.