• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Should semipro/college players be paid, or allowed to sell their stuff? (NIL and Revenue Sharing)

This shit is just wrong.


Fucked up part I:
The key components of the bill would grant the NCAA and conferences a limited antitrust exemption to re-implement the one-time transfer exception, standardize a five-year eligibility policy, ban professional athletes from returning to college, establish an agent registry and maximum fee (5%) and, as noted above, create a more strict athlete revenue-share cap.

Fucked up part II
Opposed to collective bargaining and employment, college sports leaders are working to establish a harder cap like the NFL

So the NCAA and Conferences bought their politicians and now get to make up the rules without players having any voice what so ever. They are going to limit the kids ability to move and earn because they bought anti trust exemption.

To be clear...we are right back to square 1. The NCAA is the governing body because well, that has worked so well for so long , right?
Later in the day, a Senate staff member sent a memo to conference commissioners outlining the ways that the bill closes the loophole, writing that the NCAA and College Sports Commission has "clear authority to establish and enforce rules ensuring that associated entity compensation is counted against the cap."


In case you think that maybe politicians will avoid adding some odd provisions to the bill in return for votes....No. Politicians are gonna be politicians.
While the cap circumvention provision remains the top issue, there are others, such as a new, mysterious third section of the bill added just this week. Title III, called the "Ignite HBCUs Sports and Media Act," is a competitive federal grant program to assist historically Black colleges and universities, though details of the act are unclear.
Upvote 0

2026-27 Ohio State Men's Basketball

Login to view embedded media

This week’s question: Where will Ohio State men’s basketball finish in the Big Ten this season?​


Connor: 7th​

I think Ohio State has the opportunity to move up from last season’s 8th-place finish in the conference, but there’s still enough questions about this team that I’m not super confident that they will do that.

Who starts at center, and how effective will they be at that spot? Can Justin Pippen improve his career field goal percentage of 36% as a heavy minutes type of guy?

Will Anthony Thompson jump right in and dominate like he’s expected to, or will it take some time for the freshman to adjust to the speed and physicality of college basketball? How much of a step will Amare Bynum take as a sophomore — are we looking at a potential All-Big Ten type of guy, or an 11-point, five-rebound per game guy (so a marginal uptick from last season)?

If all of those things pan out in Ohio State’s favor, you’re looking at a Buckeyes team that could absolutely finish in the top four of the Big Ten and compete for both a triple-bye in the Big Ten Tournament and a higher seed in the NCAA Tournament than they got last year.

Also, there are several teams that I think are more trustworthy/have fewer questions surrounding them than Ohio State.

Right off the top, Illinois, Michigan State, and Nebraska all feel like safer bets than Ohio State. Michigan and USC both have very talented rosters, although I think (for different reasons) I trust them less than the top three.

On paper, Purdue’s roster is nowhere close to as good as it has been over the past decade or so, but Matt Painter always seems to take a group of guys and make the sum greater than its parts.

Illinois, Michigan State, Nebraska, Michigan, USC, Purdue….. and then Ohio State.

Justin: 6th​

I pretty much just turned this question into a “Will Ohio State finish in the top six of the Big Ten?” and my answer is yes.

As of right now, Illinois, Michigan State, and Michigan are the top three teams in the conference. UCLA, USC, Maryland, Indiana, Purdue, and Ohio State are all in the second tier to me, and the Buckeyes can fall anywhere from fourth to ninth, depending on what the other teams do.

USC and Indiana have great teams on paper, but they will have to gel and find team chemistry they didn’t find last year. Purdue has the question mark of replacing Braden Smith, Fletcher Loyer, and Trey Kaufman-Renn. The Boilermakers have not played without that trio in four years and, even though they are talented, will have to learn to play without Smith, Loyer, and Kaufman-Renn.

Obviously, the Buckeyes have questions too, as Mobley and Bynum have to take the next steps, the bench has to be wildly better, and the

Buckeyes are relying heavily on a freshman to be one of their best players.

But I love the transfers and the addition of the freshmen, and I think this is a top six team in the conference.
IMO MSU and Nebraska are on par with OSU. Illinois and UM are the top, USC, UCLA and IU are the next tier, and then OSU, MSU and Nebraska.
Upvote 0

Notre Dame (football only discussion)

I was assigned to Moeller for 20 years. Non-Catholic public school guy, I would get nauseous every football season when the ND talk would hit its peak. The school was seen as a combination of Harvard, Oxford, and the Holy Ghost. Irish football was the holy grail and the shroud of Turin all rolled into one
.
What are you “assigned” there to do?
Upvote 0

C Christoph Tilly (Official Thread)

Ohio State should bring back this player with the new eligibility rules

images%2FReutersImages%2Fmmsport%2F151%2F01kyytcb11m589hbnn0h.jpg


Now that every player gets five years of eligibility, the Buckeyes should bring back their center from a year ago.

The NCAA has lost again in court (shocking, I know), and now players from the 2022 class in all sports will have a fifth year of eligibility. That means that a lot of seniors who tried to be drafted in their respective sports could flood back to the NCAA to try to find a spot.

One of those players could be former Buckeye center Christoph Tilly. Tilly was the starting center for the Ohio State basketball program last season, averaging 11 points, 4.7 rebounds, and 2.3 assists. While he wasn't the best center they've ever had, the Buckeyes need to see if they can bring him back.

Why the Ohio State basketball program should bring Christoph Tilly back​

The Buckeyes simply don't have a good player to replace Tilly on the roster. As it stands now, Ivan Njegovan is slated to be the starting center. While he has shown some promise as an offensive rebounder, his offensive skill set leaves a lot to be desired. He's at least a decent shot-blocker, though.

Still, the Buckeyes would benefit from having Tilly back as the starter. At seven feet tall, he can still deter players at the rim. He shot abysmally from outside the 3-point arc a year ago, but at least he can make those shots occasionally. Spacing the floor will be key with the roster next year.

The core of the team will be John Mobley Jr. and two five-star freshmen. Maximizing the offense is clearly going to be the way that this team has to play in order to win games. They are going to be small in the backcourt, so why not try to have the best offense they can possibly put on the court?

Tilly went undrafted in late June, so he would be available to come back. It would certainly boost up a roster that actually has expectations after Jake Diebler took the Buckeyes to the NCAA Tournament for the first time in four years. Adding a center who can shoot would help.

Ohio State can't bring their best player from a year ago back​

Unfortunately for them, Ohio State cannot bring the best player on the team back. Bruce Thornton was surprisingly the first pick of the second round by the Houston Rockets. He played well in Summer League, all but assuring his chance at a roster spot with the Rockets.

Had they been able to bring back Thornton, this would have been a team that could win the Big Ten. As it stands now, they should still shoot for the top six. If they bring back Tilly, the top four could be in play. Deibler needs to do as much research as he can to see if bringing Tilly back would be feasible.

I'm sure Tilly will explore a return to college basketball. It would help if he could come back to Columbus and play for a familiar face and in a familiar environment. That would be the best-case scenario for everyone involved in his possible return.
Thanks but no thanks. They have Jelavic to fill that role.
Upvote 0

Neal Shipley (PGA Golf Pro)

I decided to do a deep dive into Neal's stats to see why he hasn't had better results (I expected a lot of variability from week to week, which really hasn't been the issue, but thought he'd have stronger good weeks than he has had so far). Drive for show, putt for dough seems to be the TLDR conclusion, with his non-putting short game around the green, especially from the sand, also costing him bigly.

Leaving aside rankings for the moment, he's gaining .729 strokes per round on the field driving (3rd on the entire tour), but losing .103 on approach shots, .560 around the green, and .632 putting. Digging deeper on the two problem areas, he's ranked 135th in total scrambling but he's 52nd in scrambling from the rough and 154th in sand save percentage. When it comes to putting, the mid range seems to be what's killing him as he's ranked 72nd on putts inside 10 feet (probably a number that's better than the reality due to gimmes left over after missing mid-range putts), but 158th from both 10-15 feet and 15-20 feet and 123rd from 20-25 feet. He's actually ranked 17th in putting for putts over 25 feet. He's also 153rd in lag putting (proximity to the hole after the first putt).

There are a few quirky things. Oddly, he's only ranked 112th in shots gained on approach shots but is quite a bit better than that in a lot of the components that make up that stat. For example, he's ranked 22nd in proximity to the hole in approach shots. He's also ranked 56th in par 3 scoring average despite being ranked 136th in total scoring average. A final quirk is that his first round scoring average (71.53) is almost a full stroke worse than his scoring average for his next worst round (70.53 for round three) with rounds 2 and 4 coming in at 70.12 and 70.00 respectively. That might be a function of being a rookie and not being familiar with the course or might have to do with nerves and pressure. Who knows?
Upvote 0

QB1 Julian Sayin (All B1G, B1G Frosh of Year, All American, National Frosh of Year, National Champion)

That is definitely a fair question. I just have to laugh when someone says they can't put Sayin ahead of a guy who turned the ball over 42 times in 31starts at TCU (Hoover)
The good thing is any comparison between these two will be as fair as it gets and neither will have any excuses.
Upvote 0

2027 FL DB Amir Sears (Miami, FL. Verbal)

Just a thought...Miami could save a bunch of money, simply get rid of their recruiting department, but plant a bug in the Woody, and go after those kids the Buckeyes want. With the money they save, they can outbid tOSU, for these players. Or somesuch.
So the Oregon and Tennessee plan?
Upvote 0

2026 scUM Shenanigans, Arguments, Arrogant Twatwaffles, Emasculated Cucks, Feckless Marmots, Dirty Cheaters "Mid"chigan

Why wouldn't he tell them that? He told them all a hammer wasn't coming even though it 5 bajillion percent should have, and he turned out to be right
Upvote 0

TenneCheat VolunTears (official thread)

Login to view embedded media

NCAA suspends Tennessee linebacker Arion Carter

Arion Carter has been suspended by the NCAA for the first two games of Tennessee football's upcoming season.​

Veteran linebacker Arion Carter has been suspended by the NCAA for the first two games of Tennessee's upcoming season, Adam Sparks of the Knoxville News Sentinel reported on Wednesday.

A UT spokesperson confirmed Carter's suspension to GoVols247.

The NCAA elected to suspend Carter because of a $427 flight that was paid for him while he was going through the NFL pre-draft process. Carter was suspended even though he repaid the money according to Sparks' reporting.

Carter will miss Tennessee's season opener against Furman as a result. He'll also miss UT's road trip to Georgia Tech the second week of the season.

Josh Heupel was not happy with the NCAA's decision to suspend one of his leaders.

The linebacker declared for the NFL Draft in mid-December after an All-SEC junior season he achieved despite playing more than two months of the season with double turf toe, an injury severe enough for surgery. It sidelined Carter for the entire pre-draft process. He eventually withdrew from the draft with the intentions of entering the transfer portal before he and Tennessee worked out a return for his senior season.
.
.
.
continued
Upvote 0

Filter

Back
Top