Look, I've heard stories about impermissible benefits received by football players at Duke in the late 1990s through 2000's.
These incompetents couldn't beat anyone. As a salesman friend of mine once said, "they couldn't sell snatch in a logging camp." But they got car deals, low rental rates on apartments, etc.
There's little doubt that, regardless of whether Small was one of the privileged, gridiron heroes at Ohio State have received "impermissible benefits" since Chic Harley roamed Ohio Stadium - and likely before that. No different from USC. No different from Alabama. No different from Michigan, Penn State, New Mexico, Cal State Santa Barbara, Mount Union, and Bemidgi State.
Having said all that, Titus was clearly intending to deflect attention from the basketball team, since they're his boys. He knows the football team is likely well and truly fucked, and would like Matta's crew to avoid the same scrutiny and punishment. Hard to blame him for that.