I'll take a crack.
October 11, 2003
Night kickoff. National TV audience. 80,000 at Camp Randell
Ohio State, defending National Champs, ranked #3, 5-0, 1-0 in conference and on a 19 game winning streak.
Wisconsin, ranked #23, 6-1, 2-0 in conference. The loss? A 23-5 home loss to UNLV. Wisconsin was playing without star tailback Anthony Davis (ankle). Soon they would be playing without starting QB Jim Sorgi thanks to OSU LB Robert Reynolds. The next play they kick a field goal. Wisky up 10-3 with 5:09 in the 3rd quarter.
OSU ties the game with a 75 yard, 7 play drive with 6:09 left in the game.
Here's the play. I'm sure you've figured it out by now. And no, it wasn't Robert Reynolds horrific choke move earlier in the game.
On second down, WR Lee Evans runs an out-and-up route. And future first round draft pick, OSU CB Chris Gamble bites on the "out". No help as Dustin Fox was blitzing on the play. Evans is WIDE open for a TD pass from Matt Schabert. Remember him? Yeah, not many do. 5:20 remain.
Bucks never get back in the game. The next drive stalls and we punt with 3:27 to go. Matt Schabert converts 2 more first downs. Ballgame.
Wisconsin goes on to: lose 5 of their next 6 games.
Was TP's fumble a game changer? Yeah. Was it the biggest momentum killer in OSU history? Nah. There are huge plays like this in every game, every season, for every school. Heck, there are probably quite a few that only the coaches know about and we the fans never even realize. Maybe the story I relayed doesn't seem to resonate with Buck fans. I know that personally, I was so disgusted after seeing the Reynolds choke on replay that I didn't care one bit if OSU lost that game. Maybe that takes the "sting" off Gambles gaff. Maybe it eases the pain of seeing an unknown 2nd string QB (who transferred to Eastern Illinois the next year) beat us for the winning score, then seal the deal with 2 first down runs. Heck, we were defending champs, in the top 5. That loss should have been much worse than PSU. We still had everything in font of us. Not so this season.
I guess all things mellow with age. I would hazard a guess that TP's fumble won't be such a horrific play when viewed through the lens of time.