What Cincy proved against Miami Ohio for more than three quarters is that it is very beatable. Sagarin has their schedule strength at #109. South Florida and Pittsburgh are likely to show us another side of Cincy.
Why is Ohio State ranked lower? The rankings are a statement about the weakness of the Big Ten and a desire to not see Ohio State in the NC game. Sagarin has the Big Ten at #6, Marsee at #5.
Sagarin has Ohio State #8, Cincy #11. In his Predictor, Ohio State is #4, Cincy #13. Ohio State would be a five point favorite on a neutral field. USC is back to #1 in both ratings. In his ELO rating, used in the BCS, Ohio State is #15 and Cincy #5.
Just keep winning...