B1G (Official Thread)
- By Zurp
- College Football
- 433 Replies
I think the college to pros comparison is closer to the small market to big market comparison within MLB - not so much the MLB to minor leagues. True, the small market teams in the MLB play against big market teams, but the college football teams don't play NFL teams. But the MLB teams are tied directly, through some agreement, somewhere, to the minor league teams. The Washington Nationals can't go into Columbus and call up the Clippers' first baseman. Unless a trade is made, the Clippers' first baseman can only go to the Guardians while he's under contract.I know this take will not be popular, but I’m gonna show my dumb ass anyway.
The argument of not taking nfl players to “protect the integrity of the game” is futile. The game has long been compromised.
College football is a minor league nfl now.
In the mlb, players get sent down to the minors all the time for various reasons. Same with the band d-league. The nfl has used CFB as a farm system for years, so if a player cst quite make the cut in the nfl, why not let them come back to college?
If you want to say that it would be a total
Shit show, well I’d agree. But it already is regardless, so who gives a fuck really. Plus fuck the nfl for various reasons and if this is a way to stick it to them, I’m all for it.
If the Browns don't like their quarterback (I chose that team and position on purpose) they can't send him down to Purdue and call up Purdue's quarterback.
If a player can't quite make the cut in the NFL, we now have whatever that Spring league is. It used to be the XFL, and maybe it was the AAFL or UFL or something. There's also Arena football. There's other options.
Yeah, "the game" has been compromised - I agree. But that doesn't mean we should drop the cherry bomb into the toilet. In another thread someone pointed out to me that this would open the door to shady roster management techniques. The NCAA probably cannot stop all teams from taking players who didn't cut it in the NFL, but the schools, themselves, can choose to not take them, and the conferences can try to control their teams. I think this move by the Big Ten and SEC to stop this is a good attempt to say to the rest of the country, "We want to try to maintain the old way of things - that we want to protect college players and show that we want to protect the integrity of the game."
Upvote
0

.....To save on a lot of bad publicity due to arrests/convictions resulting in an embarrassment for the NFL owners. I'm suggesting that the NFL should just have all future NFL owners meetings at the Mustang Ranch in Nevada where prostitution is actually legal.....