• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Indiana Hoosiers (no more shinebox)

Well said and I agree the pressure at OSU is for sure different. As always I’d imagine there’s a balance to be had with portal or HS.

I will say I would’ve no doubt wanted Hemby over our two back ups lol.
But would you have said that going into the season, without the pleasure of hindsight?

And there is a balance, but fans have to realize that sometimes the guys in the Portal won't have the big names with stars next to them. And that's where the issue lies between fans and actual team. Going into the season everyone talked about Ethan Onianwa being the next great OT at OSU, and Phillip Daniels was an afterthought who wouldn't contribute for another year... Logan George(63) and Beau Atkinson(15) is who OSU got at DE in the Portal, IU got Stephen Daley (84) and Kellan Wyatt(91), I don't think anyone would've wanted that swap before the season. In hindsight it looks bad, but we don't have that luxury in real time. I doubt any OSU fan would've wanted Day to pursue a Cal QB transfer, over former 5star and Bama transfer Sayin. Some guys pan out, and others don't. But the transfers you only have a year for them to pop, whereas HSers have multiple years, and their bodies can still develop and they can still be taught some good practice and work habits
Upvote 0

Indiana Hoosiers (no more shinebox)

Dude, that's every single one of them. Just watch the games. You don't need some asshole with a camera and a microphone in front of him to inform yourself.
I'm not watching every single game on TV. And also I look for breakdown and analysis, that just watching doesn't provide. And also, there was a time when watching the highlights and getting a brief synopsis of the game was given without the opinion, I miss those days. But at times I want someone smarter than me to break down film. Now everyone leans too much into their own opinion to drive clocks and ratings. I think PTI and Around the Horn are mainly to blame
Upvote 0

Indiana Hoosiers (no more shinebox)

Funny thing is, I think if IU brought in the TE that OSU did, people would be losing their minds and wondering why OSU didn't pursue the TE from OU. Its all perception at this point. Cig prefers the Portal to HS recruiting, but he's not pursuing top, high star guys(outside of Marsh). The TCU QB is not a player that OSU would be interested in, none of the IU WRs would OSU be interested in, Zen Michalski was cast off from OSU and was a running joke of recruiting OL failures, and now he could win an NC as their starting OL. Roman Hemby is their starting RB, but no one would even want him over CJ Donaldson or James Peoples let alone Bo.
Cig is also playing with house money with the IU job. He literally has nothing to lose. If he loses out on a recruit it doesn't matter, he's only at IU, if a transfer doesn't pan out, oh well fans will look forward to basketball season. If Ryan Day doesn't get every single 5star, and win every game by 40pts, the fan base turns on him. Cig has next to no pressure from his fan base or their donors. He can get blown out by Oregon and it won't matter that much, they're just happy to be there. OSU fans are up in arms over losing twice this season, imagine if Day said he was going to stop really recruiting HS talent in place of transfers. Every OSU site would explode
Well said and I agree the pressure at OSU is for sure different. As always I’d imagine there’s a balance to be had with portal or HS.

I will say I would’ve no doubt wanted Hemby over our two back ups lol.
Upvote 0

Indiana Hoosiers (no more shinebox)

Colin has gotten worse and worse over the last few years. I used to like him for some of the brash takes that he would occasionally get right. Now he’s wrong on pretty much every show, and it’s almost like he’s attempting to be wrong for clicks. And it seems like he doesn’t even watch sports anymore, some random intern or camera guy gives him a box score and he just wings it
Dude, that's every single one of them. Just watch the games. You don't need some asshole with a camera and a microphone in front of him to inform yourself.
Upvote 0

2025 Bowl Upset Contest (won by Wadcutter)

Congrats to @Wadcutter, the winner of this year’s Bowl Upset Contest.

Here are the final standings:

24.5 - Wadcutter
22.5 - Oregonbuck
22.0 - HineyBuck
21.0 - muffler dragon
21.0 - Drubuck
20.0 - gracelhink
18.0 - JCOSU86
16.5 - brodybuck21
14.5 - Wingate1217
13.5 - Bborg140
13.5 - Brutus1
13.0 - BB73
13.0 - AuTX Buckeye
13.0 - TampaBuckeyes
11.0 - buckeyemania11
11.0 - MD Buckeye
11.0 - CMic
10.5 - osugrad21
10.0 - WoodyWorshiper
09.0 - iambrutus
07.0 - Best Buckeye
06.5 - Fungo Squiggly
06.5 - buckeyboy
06.5 - heisman
03.5 - Bestbuck36
03.5 - 808 Buck
00.0 - Mike80
00.0 - @BuckeyeNation27, knew he’d finish below @osugrad21 anyway, so he didn’t submit picks.

top 10 woooooooooooooooooooo
Upvote 0

CB Aaron Scott Jr. (National Champion, transfer to ???)

We are going to get a lot of this with the elimination of the spring portal.

With the spring portal Scott & West likely at least stick it out through then, battle, see where they stand at that point and then make a decision in the spring window. But now these kinds of guys are forced to make the decision now.
Upvote 0

CB Aaron Scott Jr. (National Champion, transfer to ???)

That's fine but don't act like NIL and the portal are killing the sport. I wish more people would be like you and admit you're pissed because your favorite team isn't benefiting anymore from the old system.

As do I. I think all the change is actually great for college football. Just fearful of how great/not great it might be for OSU.
Upvote 0

2026 scUM Shenanigans, Arguments, Arrogant Twatwaffles, Emasculated Cucks, Feckless Marmots, Dirty Cheaters "Mid"chigan

In reply to Smith Snowden from Utah (CB)… by AuJusBlue

Michigan4Life
January 5th, 2026 at 11:39 AM ^
He's a junior at Utah so he'll need to graduate in order to transfer to Michigan.
I hope KW understands how transfer credits work at Michigan.

Still at it with this obvious BS coping mechanism. They've brought in plenty of guys who weren't grad transfers.
Upvote 0

Filter

Latest winning wagers

Back
Top