Ohio State’s defense is actually good; Or, Are all college football fans as neurotic as we are?
Matt Tamanini via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here
Made with Google AI
A rambling argument for allowing joy into your college football fandom.
I’ve never been a fan of a college football team other than the
Ohio State Buckeyes, so I have no frame of reference for the inner workings of how other fanbases react to the highs and lows of a given CFB game or season. However, as the son of two OSU alums, someone who grew up in Central Ohio, and a proud graduate of The Ohio State University, I feel like I’ve got a pretty good handle on how Buckeye Nation responds when things go well and when they don’t, and
sometimes often more times than not there is always a portion of the fanbase who is violently angry about something.
Now, I want to make it clear, that I am not scolding or criticizing anyone for their natural reactions to what they see on or off the field. I am a strong believer that as long as you aren’t being a jerk about it, no one should tell you how you should or shouldn’t feel as a fan. Additionally, I recognize that over the years, we here at LGHL have had a tendency to be a bit more critical than many (ok, any) other outlets that cover the Buckeyes. So, this is not a condemnation of anyone in any way; it is simply an exploration of how we react to our team compared to other fanbases and in one particular case through the early part of this season, whether or not it is justified.
It has long been accepted as fact in college football circles that the majority of Ohio State supporters live in one of two equally extreme camps on opposite ends of the fandom spectrum; they either believe that the Buckeyes are the sun and the moon of the college football world and anything that goes even slightly wrong is a result of a multi-pronged global conspiracy that somehow always begins and ends with ESPN’s blind hatred of the program; or, they think that no matter what success OSU has, there are far more egregious flaws and incompetences in the program that the sheep in the fandom — including beat reporters — are too blind to recognize.
If you think that I am being hyperbolic, perhaps I am to a certain degree, but if you spend even a few minutes on social media during a game sampling the conversations amongst Buckeye fans, you will quickly find that my assessment is not that far off. But my question is, is that different for other fandoms? Is the Jekyll and Hyde nature of our fanbase somehow unique in the college football world?
Were Texas fans going apoplectic last weekend when the Longhorns, with a backup quarterback (albeit a five-star Manning), only beat a 1-and-4 conference opponent 35 to 13? Are Georgia fans calling for Kirby Smart to be fired following a horrible first-half performance
and a late-game loss against Alabama?
While not apples-to-apples comparisons to what has been bothering Ohio State fans so far this season, I do wonder if the general level of agita that we feel on a weekly basis is similar to what fans of UGA, Bama, Texas, Oregon, Miami, and other blue-blood programs go through from game to game.
For example, one of the current concerns for the more critical Buckeye faithful is whether or not Ohio State’s defense is truly at a national championship level. The statistics would certainly suggest that it is, as Jim Knowles’ unit is No. 1 in the country in points allowed per game (6.8) and non-blitz pressure rate (45.1%); second in yards allowed per game (196.5), plays allowed of 10+ yards (28), and stop rate (88.9%); third in rushing yards per game allowed (61.75) and red zone conversion percentage (60%); and they haven’t given up a single play of 30 or more yards this season.
However, for some fans, that is as much a byproduct of the opponents that the Buckeyes have faced as it is a reflection of the unit’s true dominance. This section of the fanbase will point to the defensive line still not getting home consistently, issues with undisciplined linebackers, the lack of press coverage from cornerbacks, and coaching decisions like the defensive line rotation and playing three LBs even when the situation doesn’t appear to call for it.
I am not going to dismiss any of these concerns, because I think that they are all valid to varying degrees, but I get the sense that if Penn State or USC or Tennessee or Oklahoma fans had stats like those, regardless of who they were racked up against, the vast majority of those fans would be beating their chests about how dominant their defense has been.
Again, I don’t think that the questions about the Buckeye defense are necessarily off-base, and I certainly have questions of my own. My biggest one has to do with whether or not the right players are being put in the best positions to succeed. None of us fans are afforded the opportunity to see what happens at practices or sit in on staff meetings, so we don’t have anywhere near a full picture of what goes into coaches’ decisions, but we do have four games’ worth of film and data to analyze.
As an example, Sonny Styles's physical athleticism is undeniable, but early in his transition to linebacker, he still seems to be playing without the discipline needed for the position. He is relying on his natural abilities — which are admittedly immense — and when he looks best, it is often when he is able to attack a ball carrier and make a one-on-one play outside the framework of the scheme. However, the younger of OSU’s two Styles brothers seems to struggle when it comes to being patient and locking down his portion of the field as mandated by the play call.
However, Arvell Reese — who, like Sonny, is transitioning to LB this season — has appeared to be more well-rounded when it comes to what the Buckeyes have asked him to do. The sophomore has the best Pro Football Focus grade of any linebacker on the team with more than 20 snaps. Thus far, however, Reese has played just over half as much as Styles (who has PFF’s 22nd-best grade on OSU’s defense to Reese’s seventh).
Even though Reese appears to be more than capable of handling all aspects of the job, Knowles and position coach James Laurinaitis aren’t yet comfortable putting him out there in two-LB sets. Instead, he has been playing the Mike linebacker position with Styles on one side and Cody Simon on the other — at least when everyone is healthy. And since the Buckeyes’ base defense is a 4-2-5, that means that Reese is only getting first-team reps in an alternate package.
While I still think that there is considerable value in utilizing Styles’ athleticism and allowing him to get high-leverage game reps in order to add to his experience, it seems obvious to me that Reese deserves more of a shot in OSU’s base defense. I’ve also recently wondered if some of
the backup defensive linemen needed to be seeing more time.
But, that is a further tangent that distracts from my main point, which is that while there are admitted issues with the defense, the unit is still incredibly good, especially if
Tyleik Williams returns as planned against Iowa. With the added stability of Ohio State’s best defensive lineman back to anchor the front six (or seven), I don’t think that there is significant reason to be concerned about the long-term viability of the defense. Yes, the competition has been subpar, but this is the type of performance you want to see against subpar competition; overall dominance while getting guys reps in different situations and experimenting a bit to see who can handle what and when.
For those who want to see more sacks from Jack Sawyer and J.T. Tuimoloau, I’m there with you, but we are in a new era of college football where quarterbacks are getting the ball out much more quickly than they ever have before. Nonetheless, OSU is tied for 11th in the country with 3.25 sacks per game, so it’s not like they aren’t getting home at all. Throw Tyleik back into the lineup, and you have to feel better about where they stand on the pressure front.
While all of the general caveats about the level of competition are valid, when looking at the advanced analytics that factor in strength of opponent, the Buckeyes are No. 2 nationally in adjusted expected points added (EPA) per play, arguably the most important metric in analytical models. The OSU defense is also currently second according to SP+’s model, just slightly behind the Hawkeyes. So while the season stats and analytics thus far do not guarantee success against the best teams remaining on Ohio State’s schedule, I would much rather the early accolades than not.
There is room to grow for this defense, for sure; both in terms of player and coach performance. And I understand that despite similarly impressive numbers last season, the defense failed to turn in a spectacular game against their rival in the regular season finale robbing the team of a potential national championship. We have been burned before by seemingly paper-tiger defenses, so a certain level of doubt about the unit’s ability to perform in th marquee matchups on their schedule is warranted.
However, this defense — in my estimation — is markedly better than last year’s. The vast majority of starters are returning from the statistically great 2023 unit, and I don’t think that any of them have gotten worse. Then, of course, the OSU defense has added arguably the best safety in the country in Caleb Downs, and Ty Hamilton has been a solid replacement for the now departed (and suspended) Mike Hall Jr.
Is the Buckeye D perfect? No, of course not. Can it get better? I sure hope so, but I have to wonder if some Ohio State fans’ inherent inferiority complex and crippling need for perfection (and I am including myself in these ranks at times) are actually robbing us of the joy and pride that any other fanbase would feel given the performance witnessed on the field through four games.
I watch college football not as a parasocial way to define my existence as a human, but as a form of entertainment and connection to my home and my roots. In my mind, those efforts should always be centered on celebration whenever possible. From an objective perspective, there will never not be something that the team can improve, but I worry that our hyperfocus on those particular thorns ruins the view of the uniquely beautiful roses that we walk amongst as Buckeye fans.
Perhaps Dawsg fans, and Vols fans, and Canes fans, and Sooner fans, and Horns fans, and Tide fans go through the same pits of despair that we do following a five-touchdown victory, I don’t know. But, as I age, I increasingly think that it’s more than a little bit sad that anyone — especially Buckeye fans — would watch something that they love and get only pain and frustration out of it.
Obviously, there’s nothing wrong with being critical of something that you love when it warrants it, but when that is your default, and no evidence to the contrary can persuade you otherwise, I feel like you might be missing out on the best part of fandom: seizing every opportunity — no matter how minor — to overinflate your own, personal ego and rub it in the faces of everyone who has ever doubted you or your team before.
Continue reading...