If you could go back to the beginning of college football time, what 5 things would you retroactively change about the game? Would you have instituted a playoff from day one? – CR
A: I know you asked about changing the game, but you hinted at changing up the BCS, so let’s just go back to the mid-1990s when the whole weird, wild system kicked in and there was a chance to set things right from the start. First, I would’ve made the BCS formula with three components using the human polls, the computers, and the strength of schedule all equally. Next, I’d take the top four conference winners according to the final BCS formula, and play them off No. 1 vs. No. 4 and No. 2 vs. No. 3 with everyone else going to the regular bowls. I wouldn’t have any distinction between BCS leagues and non-BCS leagues, if you’re in the top four among the conference winners, you’re in. Third, I’d make sure the playoff would be played on New Year’s Day, and the national title a week later so it wouldn't get too drawn out. Fourth, I’d make the voters accountable from vote one. All votes would be published, and each pollster would be given a weekly test to make sure they know what they’re talking about. Finally, I’d make Notre Dame join a conference if they wanted to be a part of the whole show and eliminate the special BCS treatment. You want in the big dance, earn it by winning a league.