• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Jameis Winston (QB Browns)

Now, the separate issue that you raise is whether she is lying. But that is an issue for a jury to decide.

The question I have regarding the accuser's veracity (and I don't know the answer) is this: How common is it for women who are fabricating an accusation of rape to also present themselves at a hospital to experience the scintillating fun of a rape kit examination?

Trial by media is one of my least favorite things about our culture, and they have certainly been known to get it abysmally wrong (Richard Jewell). That said, the sequence of events lends credence to this young woman's claim for me. I hope the truth will prevail.
 
Upvote 0
The question I have regarding the accuser's veracity (and I don't know the answer) is this: How common is it for women who are fabricating an accusation of rape to also present themselves at a hospital to experience the scintillating fun of a rape kit examination?

Trial by media is one of my least favorite things about our culture, and they have certainly been known to get it abysmally wrong (Richard Jewell). That said, the sequence of events lends credence to this young woman's claim for me. I hope the truth will prevail.

Okay, I am going to go with this in generalities only because I participated in a huge "why we have weird rape laws" thing in law school. For what it's worth, I was against many of the "rape shield" laws at the time, and may be now. . . I'm not sure.

Anyway. . .

A large majority of rape reports are real.

A larger majority of rape reports are not reported.

A larger majority of reported rape reports are not prosecuted ("he said she said").

An enormous majority (pretty much all) of rape reports where the woman submits to a rape kit are real.

An enormous majority (pretty much all) of rapes reported within 8 hours are real.

All I remember is FBI and other stats were involved in this. The focus was on why rape victims get special privileges as victims in court. Also, there was quite a bit of information about the fact that a huge number of false rapes are also reported each year. But see above to see if it is likely in this case. But hey, who knows. This whole case is very strange and I sincerely don't believe we should rush to any judgments on it. Something is amiss. Once you throw in all the crazy factors of this case, all "norms" go out the window, perhaps.
 
Upvote 0
An enormous majority (pretty much all) of rapes reported within 8 hours are real.

Edited out before I posted my remark was the additional consideration that she went in for the exam in a sufficiently timely manner for them to obtain a viable DNA sample. So, if this was just a case of "buyer's remorse" post consensual sex, it manifested in an awfully big hurry.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Re: The prosecutor investigating sexual assault allegations against Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston wants the process to be "thorough" and won't let football dictate when he will wrap up his inquiry.
State Attorney Willie Meggs on Monday reiterated he won't let FSU's football schedule or Winston's Heisman Trophy possibilities determine when his investigation will be completed.
http://espn.go.com/college-football...igation-thorough-says-prosecutor-willie-meggs

Just sayin': He didn't comment that potential threats to himself and/or his family, and that it would be political suicide* would dictate/influence his decision whether to indict Winston or not

*his chances for re election to an 8th term would undoubtedly be "zilch".

Apparently his last election was fairly close: http://mcimaps.com/floridas-second-circuit-state-attorney-race-how-willie-meggs-held-on/

http://www.sao2fl.org/Willie's_Profile.htm
 
Upvote 0
Re: The prosecutor investigating sexual assault allegations against Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston wants the process to be "thorough" and won't let football dictate when he will wrap up his inquiry.
State Attorney Willie Meggs on Monday reiterated he won't let FSU's football schedule or Winston's Heisman Trophy possibilities determine when his investigation will be completed.
http://espn.go.com/college-football...igation-thorough-says-prosecutor-willie-meggs

Just sayin': He didn't comment that potential threats to himself and/or his family, and that it would be political suicide* would dictate/influence his decision whether to indict Winston or not

*his chances for re election to an 8th term would undoubtedly be "zilch".

Apparently his last election was fairly close: http://mcimaps.com/floridas-second-circuit-state-attorney-race-how-willie-meggs-held-on/

http://www.sao2fl.org/Willie's_Profile.htm

Before this story broke, Meggs had already announced he would not seek another term.
 
Upvote 0

5cbd956dcb9352eb46854a5cb707d1a4188492437-598x800.jpg


747bee27fa72ee9c700490ddf6cc6d16609339088-598x800.jpg
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top