• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

CFP Playoff Committee justs makes s#!t up

With the 12 team CFP format next year will the ybe able to keep star players from opting out?

Will players opt out of expanded College Football Playoff? NFL hopes, injury prevention create tough decisions

The 12-team playoff could lead to some players suiting up for as many as 17 games in a season

cfp-logo-helmet-2018-g.png


One major bowl game executive has thought deeply about the prospect of losing his biggest drawing card as the College Football Playoff prepares for expansion in 2024. With the multibillion-dollar industry growing, the executive pondered what has emerged as the biggest question to this point with the format expanding to 12 teams: What if they threw the biggest national championship party ever but the best player(s) didn't show up?

"You gotta wonder, how many agents and parents are going to get in these kids' heads and say, 'Hey, we've got generational money here. Why are we going to go ahead and play for this thing?'" the executive told CBS Sports under the condition of anonymity.

Bowl game opt-outs are a modern trend. In 2016, running backs Leonard Fournette (LSU) and Christian McCaffrey (Stanford) caused a stir by skipping their respective postseason games. The practice has since become an expected -- if not accepted -- part of the bowl season.

The choice has always been understandable on some level.

At their core, bowl games are exhibitions in which players are not directly compensated for their participation. For those transferring or preserving their bodies for the NFL Draft process, sitting out makes perfect sense. The 12-team playoff will change the math, however, by bringing the possibility of four extra games. College football players may now suit up for 17 games, equal to an NFL regular season.

The choice now shifts from deciding whether to play just one exhibition game to risking generational NFL money to play as many as four additional games in pursuit of a national championship. (So far, through 10 years of the CFP, not a single player has intentionally opted out to preserve his body for the draft.)

"From the moment McCaffrey and others before him said they weren't going to play in bowl games, [I think] everybody should opt out if you're going to be a first- or second-rounder," said Richard Giller, head of insurance recovery at the Los Angeles-based Greenspoon Marder law firm.

CBS Sports has spent the last year speaking with approximately 20 persons closely associated with college football about the prospect of players opting out of the 12-team CFP. The discussions centered around a basic question: Is risking a broken body part (or worse) playing those extra games worth risking the generational NFL Draft money that awaits?
.
.
continued
.
.
Jason Belzer, CEO of Student Athlete NIL, called "absolute bullshit" on a report stating $20 million to $25 million in NIL money was being raised to keep Ohio State All-American wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. out of the draft. Belzer said participation in postseason games could potentially be written into an NIL agreement.
.
.
continued
 
Upvote 0
Opt-outs are going to get worse and worse. We've already seen situations where players are opting out of the regular season, and I think that just gets worse and worse.

Clauses in NIL contracts won't work because then some schools will choose not to have them as a recruiting advantage. The only way is to make the players employees and negotiate a CBA that penalizes and fines opt outs and would cover all players and schools. Even then I'd guess some players would just take the immediate financial hit rather than jeopardize the really big money that's coming a couple of months away.
 
Upvote 0
Opt-outs are going to get worse and worse. We've already seen situations where players are opting out of the regular season, and I think that just gets worse and worse.

Clauses in NIL contracts won't work because then some schools will choose not to have them as a recruiting advantage. The only way is to make the players employees and negotiate a CBA that penalizes and fines opt outs and would cover all players and schools. Even then I'd guess some players would just take the immediate financial hit rather than jeopardize the really big money that's coming a couple of months away.
I agree with your post, but I wonder about the faculty response when students are making 6 to 7 times more than all but the well connected research professors.

That ship probably already sailed the minute aTm signed Jackie Sherrill to that over the top salary. Proud to know that Woody insisted that he not be paid more than a full professor.
 
Upvote 0
Opt-outs are going to get worse and worse. We've already seen situations where players are opting out of the regular season, and I think that just gets worse and worse.

Clauses in NIL contracts won't work because then some schools will choose not to have them as a recruiting advantage. The only way is to make the players employees and negotiate a CBA that penalizes and fines opt outs and would cover all players and schools. Even then I'd guess some players would just take the immediate financial hit rather than jeopardize the really big money that's coming a couple of months away.
Or the bowl games and the TV networks could pay the players that help draw the audiences.

I haven’t seen the TV ratings, but I’m expecting the numbers for the Orange and Cotton Bowls, and the upcoming Fiesta Bowl (Oregon/Liberty) to be rather poor.

The 11 games in the CFP should do all right from now on, but the other 30 or so bowl games will probably get worse.
 
Upvote 0
Or the bowl games and the TV networks could pay the players that help draw the audiences.

I haven’t seen the TV ratings, but I’m expecting the numbers for the Orange and Cotton Bowls, and the upcoming Fiesta Bowl (Oregon/Liberty) to be rather poor.

The 11 games in the CFP should do all right from now on, but the other 30 or so bowl games will probably get worse.
If you were a potential first round pick playing for the twelfth ranked team in the CFP who came from a family with no money, what would you do? I suppose we’ll begin to find out starting next year.
 
Upvote 0
If you were a potential first round pick playing for the twelfth ranked team in the CFP who came from a family with no money, what would you do? I suppose we’ll begin to find out starting next year.
The entities giving the players money need to include insurance policies for bowl game injuries as past of their payment for the guys playing in bowl games.
 
Upvote 0
Or the bowl games and the TV networks could pay the players that help draw the audiences.

I haven’t seen the TV ratings, but I’m expecting the numbers for the Orange and Cotton Bowls, and the upcoming Fiesta Bowl (Oregon/Liberty) to be rather poor.

The 11 games in the CFP should do all right from now on, but the other 30 or so bowl games will probably get worse.
Cotton Bowl did a great number. About 10 million I believe.

 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

FBI notified about threats toward CFP members after FSU exclusion​

Executive director Bill Hancock said the College Football Playoff has contacted the FBI in response to threats he said were directed at himself, CFP staff members and selection committee members following this season's controversial exclusion of undefeated ACC champion Florida State.

Hancock declined to say specifically what the CFP has done to protect committee members and staff but said it has "taken steps" since Selection Day on Dec. 3.

"We've stayed ahead of it," Hancock said following the CFP's annual meeting prior to Monday night's CFP National Championship presented by AT&T between No. 1 Michigan and No. 2 Washington. "We've been in contact with the FBI just to say, 'We got this. We got a threat on my house. We want you to know about it and tell us what should we do about it?' Most of us did."

After excluding the first undefeated Power 5 champion in the CFP era, Hancock said some committee and staff members received threats at their homes and offices, and all of them received "the disgusting, profanity-laced emails and phone calls."

"Every NCAA sports committee receives criticism from the teams who were left out," Hancock said. "I've been doing this 35 years. I've seen it and I understand those fans, but this one was absolutely over the top and inappropriate. In my 35 years, I've never seen anything like this."
.
.
.
continued
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

FBI notified about threats toward CFP members after FSU exclusion​

Executive director Bill Hancock said the College Football Playoff has contacted the FBI in response to threats he said were directed at himself, CFP staff members and selection committee members following this season's controversial exclusion of undefeated ACC champion Florida State.

Hancock declined to say specifically what the CFP has done to protect committee members and staff but said it has "taken steps" since Selection Day on Dec. 3.

"We've stayed ahead of it," Hancock said following the CFP's annual meeting prior to Monday night's CFP National Championship presented by AT&T between No. 1 Michigan and No. 2 Washington. "We've been in contact with the FBI just to say, 'We got this. We got a threat on my house. We want you to know about it and tell us what should we do about it?' Most of us did."

After excluding the first undefeated Power 5 champion in the CFP era, Hancock said some committee and staff members received threats at their homes and offices, and all of them received "the disgusting, profanity-laced emails and phone calls."

"Every NCAA sports committee receives criticism from the teams who were left out," Hancock said. "I've been doing this 35 years. I've seen it and I understand those fans, but this one was absolutely over the top and inappropriate. In my 35 years, I've never seen anything like this."
.
.
.
continued
Tallahassee gonna Tallahassee.
 
Upvote 0

FBI notified about threats toward CFP members after FSU exclusion​

Executive director Bill Hancock said the College Football Playoff has contacted the FBI in response to threats he said were directed at himself, CFP staff members and selection committee members following this season's controversial exclusion of undefeated ACC champion Florida State.

Hancock declined to say specifically what the CFP has done to protect committee members and staff but said it has "taken steps" since Selection Day on Dec. 3.

"We've stayed ahead of it," Hancock said following the CFP's annual meeting prior to Monday night's CFP National Championship presented by AT&T between No. 1 Michigan and No. 2 Washington. "We've been in contact with the FBI just to say, 'We got this. We got a threat on my house. We want you to know about it and tell us what should we do about it?' Most of us did."

After excluding the first undefeated Power 5 champion in the CFP era, Hancock said some committee and staff members received threats at their homes and offices, and all of them received "the disgusting, profanity-laced emails and phone calls."

"Every NCAA sports committee receives criticism from the teams who were left out," Hancock said. "I've been doing this 35 years. I've seen it and I understand those fans, but this one was absolutely over the top and inappropriate. In my 35 years, I've never seen anything like this."
.
.
.
continued
Yeah, but let's bring these mouth-breathers into the B1G. No thanks.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top