• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Bitching about the 2004 Season

Jump to latest Follow Reply
Sort by date Sort by votes
Who cares what Judas says ... I'd never pick my alma mater over the tsun like he has in the past. Even if I was the best analyst in the world I'd gracefully say OSU has some challenges to overcome this or that team. Thats why so many people in the Buckeye Nation can't stand him!!! So who gives a rats A$# what he thinks.
 
Upvote 0
StoRMinBrutus said:
Who cares what Judas says ... I'd never pick my alma mater over the tsun like he has in the past. Even if I was the best analyst in the world I'd gracefully say OSU has some challenges to overcome this or that team. Thats why so many people in the Buckeye Nation can't stand him!!! So who gives a rats A$# what he thinks.
Click to expand...

Herbie is where he is today because he can remain impartial in the national spotlight. So you're pissed off that he picked UM last year? Was he wrong? He picked OSU last week, iirc against the odds. Did you lambast him then?

Herbie is right, we ARE the biggest disappointment of the season, so far. If we don't win today 6-5 is damn near best case scenario. We *HAVE* to win today to salvage this season into something decent. If we perform today like we have all year, then we're in for EXACTLY what herbie says.
 
Upvote 0
Da-Bucks,
I don't get "Pissed" about things like that Da-Bucks, don't assume you know what I am thinking please. I don't appreciate Judas (Herbie) because he is glimb and tries too hard to be "impartial",as you say, when it comes to his alma mater. Clark Kellogg (maybe not every instance so don't quote me to the letter) still comes off showing pride for his alma mater even though he knows they may not win. He usually just points out the "challenges" OSU will have to overcome to beat the opposing teams. That's a GREAT ANALYST and thats his choice, Herbie goes a different, less appealing route. I have the right not to like him and evidently alot of other OSU fans and alumni feel the same way here in Columbus who listen to him every day. If you like him, fine, thats your choice. Yes we lost to tsun last year but thats not why I don't appreciate him. I don't because of the way he is "analyzing" his alma mater with less respect he would have for a high school team with no talent. It can be done with more class and character and still shown respect for OSU. Herbie does not do that and he comes off with an arrogance. You can be impartial and still be a good "analyst" with class. Herbie fails to do that. Your entitled to your opinion, so am I but I am not alone in that thought.
So in short DA-Buck I lump him in with the goofs like corso, trev, and mays. I don't give a rats A$# what "analyst" predict or say about my beloved Buckeyes. I do however care if they do it with as much arrogance and glib of a trev alberts, mays or herbie, without any class while doing it !!! If you want to wallow in dissapointing predictions made by the "expert analyzt" then fine. I'd chose not to hear it and concentrate on supporting the team and of what needs to be done to improve this team and cheer em on when they need it most even though the reality is they may not have a great season.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
StoRMinBrutus said:
Da-Bucks,
I don't get "Pissed" about things like that Da-Bucks, don't assume you know what I am thinking please. I don't appreciate Judas (Herbie) because he is glimb and tries too hard to be "impartial",as you say, when it comes to his alma mater. Clark Kellogg (maybe not every instance so don't quote me to the letter) still comes off showing pride for his alma mater even though he knows they may not win. He usually just points out the "challenges" OSU will have to overcome to beat the opposing teams. That's a GREAT ANALYST and thats his choice, Herbie goes a different, less appealing route. I have the right not to like him and evidently alot of other OSU fans and alumni feel the same way here in Columbus who listen to him every day. If you like him, fine, thats your choice. Yes we lost to tsun last year but thats not why I don't appreciate him. I don't because of the way he is "analyzing" his alma mater with less respect he would have for a high school team with no talent. It can be done with more class and character and still shown respect for OSU. Herbie does not do that and he comes off with an arrogance.
So in short DA-Buck I lump him in with the goofs like corso, trev, and mays. I don't give a rats A$# what "analyst" predict or say about my beloved Buckeyes. I do however care if they do it with as much arrogance and glib of a trev alberts, mays or herbie, without any class while doing it !!! If you want to wallow in dissapointing predictions made by the "expert analyzt" then fine. I'd chose not to hear it and concentrate on supporting the team and of what needs to be done to improve this team and cheer em on when they need it most even though the reality is they may not have a great season.
Click to expand...

It's hard to pack that much ignorance into one post, but you managed to pull it off.

"Look out Eddie! Judas will strangle you!"
 

Attachments

  • dossintercept_herbstreit.jpeg
    dossintercept_herbstreit.jpeg
    13.4 KB · Views: 415
Upvote 0
However,the way it seems with his present harsh criticism towards tOSU, in comparison to other schools, leads me to believe this more of an attempt to ignite the team rather than degrade them.

Just an opinion, but I believe there is an agenda in Herbie's scathing commentary
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Sorry- I dont mean to encourage tibs, but

It's hard to pack that much ignorance into one post, but you managed to pull it off.
Click to expand...
:lol:



Stormin.....You're totally entitled to your opinion, but I think Herbie is very fair. Things dont always come up roses and Herbie calls it like he sees it.


go-bucks!!!
 
Upvote 0
Tibor coming from someone who never has a good or knowledgeable post to date on BP, I'll take it for what it's merits are worth .. nadda. You have yet to impress me with your remarks. Geeezzz at least try to be funny. Always trying to stir up controversy and show how "smart" and "witty" you are. Only the weak minded fall for those one liners.

jenkinswoody,
Thats just it. I don't mind you having that opinion just as I have mine. Alot of people, including myself, feel otherwise. That he goes a tad over the line of "impartial" and doesn't show the class he should. No reason to get mad about it or personal online like some with "computer Muscles" seem to do hahahaha too funny.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
StoRMinBrutus said:
Tibor coming from someone who never has a good or knowledgeable post to date on BP, I'll take it for what it's merits are worth .. nadda. You have yet to impress me with your remarks. Geeezzz at least try to be funny. Always trying to stir up controversy and show how "smart" and "witty" you are. Only the weak minded fall for those one liners.
Click to expand...

:boohoo:
 
Upvote 0
Who cares what Judas says ... I'd never pick my alma mater over the tsun like he has in the past. Even if I was the best analyst in the world I'd gracefully say OSU has some challenges to overcome this or that team. Thats why so many people in the Buckeye Nation can't stand him!!! So who gives a rats A$# what he thinks.
Click to expand...
Da-Bucks,
I don't get "Pissed" about things like that Da-Bucks, don't assume you know what I am thinking please. I don't appreciate Judas (Herbie) because he is glimb and tries too hard to be "impartial",as you say, when it comes to his alma mater. Clark Kellogg (maybe not every instance so don't quote me to the letter) still comes off showing pride for his alma mater even though he knows they may not win. He usually just points out the "challenges" OSU will have to overcome to beat the opposing teams. That's a GREAT ANALYST and thats his choice, Herbie goes a different, less appealing route. I have the right not to like him and evidently alot of other OSU fans and alumni feel the same way here in Columbus who listen to him every day. If you like him, fine, thats your choice. Yes we lost to tsun last year but thats not why I don't appreciate him. I don't because of the way he is "analyzing" his alma mater with less respect he would have for a high school team with no talent. It can be done with more class and character and still shown respect for OSU. Herbie does not do that and he comes off with an arrogance.
So in short DA-Buck I lump him in with the goofs like corso, trev, and mays. I don't give a rats A$# what "analyst" predict or say about my beloved Buckeyes. I do however care if they do it with as much arrogance and glib of a trev alberts, mays or herbie, without any class while doing it !!! If you want to wallow in dissapointing predictions made by the "expert analyzt" then fine. I'd chose not to hear it and concentrate on supporting the team and of what needs to be done to improve this team and cheer em on when they need it most even though the reality is they may not have a great season.
Click to expand...
so youre upset that herbie isnt a homer? and im sure you were really happy listening to gresie call the michigan games...im sure you didnt bitch then either.

im with tibor on this one.
 
Upvote 0
osugrad21 said:
However,the way it seems with his present harsh criticism towards tOSU, in comparison to other schools, leads me to believe this more of an attempt to ignite the team rather than degrade them.

Just an opinion, but I believe there is an agenda in Herbie's scathing commentary
Click to expand...
I was beginning to wonder if I was the only one thinking this way.
 
Upvote 0
BK27
Comon , your getting into this a little too hard. Greise comon ... No, I personally didn't like Greise. My only point is Herbstreet goes over the line. Just because others think he is a great impartial sportscaster. I don't .... is that so far out in left field ?? No ... there is no reason to make every effort to point out how terrible OSU is. I personally don't like the way he presents it. So I should be like Tibor and personally attack other peoples intellegence. I don't mind the experts pointing out the challenges of this team and that team but I do mind analyst being arrogant and not showing class about it. Why is it that one side of the arguement has all the answers and the oter side is all a bunch of ignorant jerks?
 
Upvote 0
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top