• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Should semipro/college players be paid, or allowed to sell their stuff? (NIL and Revenue Sharing)

Login to view embedded media

Is there a changing of the guard among the blue bloods?

There could be a massive change coming to the college football and basketball hierarchys.

Ohio State’s standing in the historical hierarchy of college football will never be questioned. The Buckeyes’ on-field success, combined with school traditions, has made Ohio State a giant in a sport that dates back to just after the Lincoln Administration.

But in the ever-changing landscape of college athletics, it’s worth wondering if there’s a changing of the guard amongst the blue bloods. Ohio State won a national championship in 2024, but it has struggled in some ways to adapt to the advent of the transfer portal and NIL. Other programs that have been blue bloods over the years, including Alabama, Oklahoma, USC, and Texas, have not been as dominant in recent seasons.
To be clear, Ohio State is still a great program. They’ve been one of the winningest programs in college football over the last five, 10, 15, and 20 years. They have three national championships this century.

But with some of the other programs no longer what they once were, it begs the question of whether new blood is being injected into both college football and college basketball. Look at the teams that played in the national championship this season. Miami and Indiana aren’t considered blue bloods of college football. Sure, Miami had really good teams in the ‘80s, ‘90s, and early 2000s. But they haven’t had the historical dominance a blue blood typically has.

Blue bloods have built their success on recruiting the best players, hiring the best head coaches, and having the most on-field success. But look at blue blood programs like Kentucky in college basketball. They’re struggling to recruit because they haven’t yet figured out how to navigate NIL most effectively. Other college basketball players, like Kansas, have struggled in recent seasons.

The transfer portal and NIL have brought parity to both college football and basketball. That’s great. But some blue-blood programs have struggled to catch on. They have been used to doing things a certain way for so long, and now they have to adapt quickly to a whole new era of college athletics.

Meanwhile, other schools, particularly at the Power Four level, that didn’t have much of a chance in previous seasons, now feel like they have an opportunity. The playing field has been leveled. It’s benefited schools like Indiana, Miami, Ole Miss, Texas Tech, Auburn, Houston, and many others. Players don’t necessarily have to go to the historic blue bloods to get the best NIL deal and/or more playing time. These schools have athletic departments that are embracing a new era of college athletics.
.
.
.
continued
Top 5 portal class begs to differ. Aint going anywhere son
Upvote 0

2025-2026 College Basketball General Discussion

I listened to the entire 1st half of that Kent State/Miami game on the radio old school style since I am too cheap to pay for ESPN+. That is when I turned on Ohio State to watch that great finish then turned back to the Kent State/Miami game for the final 8 mins there and OT.

Miami sure is ranked super low in kenpom though at 93 and 52 in the NET coming into the night and with 0 quad 1 wins means they probably can only lose 1 regular season game and then lose in the MAC tournament for 2 total losses max and still feel safe for an at large bid.

I wish they could have scheduled at least 1 decent power school to see how they could done. Totally mystery box right now.
Upvote 0

Should semipro/college players be paid, or allowed to sell their stuff? (NIL and Revenue Sharing)

NIL has ruined college football as we knew it. Lots of players dont come because they want to be a "Buckeye" but because we offer a NIL or a larger NIL. It's hard for me to regard them as such when they are not here for the "team"
Just look at how many players left this year. That's disgraceful.
The OSU is buying and selling players just like the pro's do.
So sad. It seems most fans cheer more for certain players than for my beloved Buckeye's.
GO BUCK!
No offense but this narrative is so tired. Do you not think that OSU, Bama, Oregon, etc didnt pay kids before? I saw this same retort when people saw this same statement. Its seems like fans who sound like yourself were more content when players just got paid by the dumpster of the Piggly wiggly or IGA. Theres a reason why Saban, Smart, Meyer, Carroll, etc were able to consolidate so much talent annually. And it wasn't because they wanted to matriculate from the prestigious universities.

The Program, Blue Chips, told fictional stories while we all watched the Pony Excess 30 for 30(or like myself, read the book too).
The NCAA chose to make billions from free labor until they couldn't any longer due to their greed. OSU will always be OSU to me. And I'll still love rooting for them, because I know they can and will pivot with the times. Its funny how if OSU had won it all this year, your love for CFB wouldn't have waned...
Upvote 0

NCAA - slowly ruining football (rules changes - merged)

but the NCAA passed on doing that. They had decades to adapt and failed.

This is what happens.

I'm enjoying watching it burn, myself.
100, I've lost hope. That ship sailed.

There are reasons why no other country, to my knowledge at least, has any market for college sports. Universities in lots of developed countries don't even have sports teams. <mind blown explosion sound effect>

It was a good run.
Upvote 0

SEC (It just means more.. even its losses are wins)

This goes back nearly 50 years at this point. Whenever ESPN became a thing, the ONE thing that they absolutely knew was that they needed College Football. The Big 10 and Pac-10 were already tied into the Rose Bowl and national broadcasts. Oklahoma and Nebraska from the Big 8 were also nationwide. So where did that leave the fledgling network? The SEC. So E!SPiN hitched its wagon to that beleaguered conference, and they promoted it and promoted it and promoted it. And they always WILL promote it. Because that's their bellcow. But NIL and the portal have destroyed E!SPIN's football hegemony. The B1G and PAC programs have ALWAYS had more money than the SEC. BUT they (mostly) followed the rules. The current CFP runs through ESECPN until the end of the 2031-2032 season. In the current expansion negotiations, the B1G doesn't even need to take the hard line. They just need to wrestle control of the CFP from ESECPN. Which they can and will do.

The entire State of Alabama only has two billionaires, and both of them are Auburn supporters. NO ONE in the SEC can outspend Ohio State, or the Cheaters up North, or Oregon, or Washington, or USC, or even freaking INDIANA. They can't even outspend Northwestern or Purdue. Even Rutgers and Maryland can basically spend with any SEC school except UT and aTm.

OKAY. I'm rambling. My bad.
The sec is about to become Texas, aTm, then everybody else. Maybe Vanderbilt. Florida and Georgia could scrounge up some donors but still unlikely to match big ten alumni money.

Of anyone is inspired by what Indiana did its Vandy.
Upvote 0

2025-2026 College Basketball General Discussion

Talk about mentally tough man, the Miami Redhawks are nails in that department. Kent has the upset in their plates ready to eat and Miami snatched it from them and went off in OT. Similar to the Buckeyes OT effort, they left no doubt about who was going to win.

Keep an eye on this coach. Travis Steele.

Actually wondering if I'm related to him as I type this.

Edit: not over yet. Kent 5 points last 10 seconds to cut it to 1 in OT. Lol
Upvote 0

Indiana Hoosiers (2025 National Champions)

A regular Dodge Neon? Or an SRT-4 Neon? The SRT-4 was factory rated at 215hp... except Sport Compact Car magazine put one on a dyno, and it put down 223 to the wheels, which means that it actually had ~300hp at the crank. Those cars were insanely underrated from the factory. I knew a guy who had a modded one. He would race *anyone* from a roll. Not so much from a dig, because hooking up was definitely an issue, along with insane torque steer. I watched him break his dick off in cars that cost 2x-3x as much numerous times. The funny thing was, his "real" car was a freaking Viper. He just liked to clown people in his "It's just a Neon" for the lulz.

IDK what my point was just now. It's my Friday, and I've had a couple Hazy Janes.

Carry on.
From my days as a stock boy at a grocery store in Centerville: One customer put a Porsche four banger in the ass end of a VW minibus. Another dropped a Chevy 350 into an MG- TD body. The guy with the mini was smart enough to also put Porsche level brakes on his monster. Oh, and fuck Michigan.
Upvote 0

Indiana Hoosiers (2025 National Champions)

We lost to the #1 team by three points and the #2 team by ten points--which were our only two losses of the season--and we return our Heisman Trophy finalist at QB and the best WR in the country this coming season, and yet we get ranked at #6 in the pre-season poll?
Mark May was transferred to ESPN's poll selection team.
Upvote 0

SEC (It just means more.. even its losses are wins)

The SEC will be right back to being propped up in the summer with comically over inflated preseason rankings for the usual suspects.
This goes back nearly 50 years at this point. Whenever ESPN became a thing, the ONE thing that they absolutely knew was that they needed College Football. The Big 10 and Pac-10 were already tied into the Rose Bowl and national broadcasts. Oklahoma and Nebraska from the Big 8 were also nationwide. So where did that leave the fledgling network? The SEC. So E!SPiN hitched its wagon to that beleaguered conference, and they promoted it and promoted it and promoted it. And they always WILL promote it. Because that's their bellcow. But NIL and the portal have destroyed E!SPIN's football hegemony. The B1G and PAC programs have ALWAYS had more money than the SEC. BUT they (mostly) followed the rules. The current CFP runs through ESECPN until the end of the 2031-2032 season. In the current expansion negotiations, the B1G doesn't even need to take the hard line. They just need to wrestle control of the CFP from ESECPN. Which they can and will do.

The entire State of Alabama only has two billionaires, and both of them are Auburn supporters. NO ONE in the SEC can outspend Ohio State, or the Cheaters up North, or Oregon, or Washington, or USC, or even freaking INDIANA. They can't even outspend Northwestern or Purdue. Even Rutgers and Maryland can basically spend with any SEC school except UT and aTm.

OKAY. I'm rambling. My bad.
Upvote 0

Cleveland Browns (Factory of Sadness)

No seasoned coach worth anything wants to work with Haslam, nor Barry for that matter. Their reputation has screwed the team and they know it.

That said, word on the street is that McDaniel told Haslam that there simply weren’t enough sausage shops at the West Side Market and with the recent trend of self checkout lines at grocery stores, bag boys were too hard to find in order for him to seriously consider Cleveland as his destination.
Upvote 0

Filter

Back
Top