Apologies in advance for the rant:
The one thing I have always been critical of in the Urban Meyer era is that we have never put together a complete team. I realize that in college football it is rare for any team to be complete - but this is Ohio State, we are one of the top 2 programs in CFB, and (like Alabama does year after year) I think we should be able to pull that off. Especially considering the resources and talent that is at our disposal.
Our offense was great but our defense played like crap in the first two years under Urban. Since Ash arrived, our defense has been solid but our offense has too often been suspect. And Special Teams has been [Mark May] entirely throughout. Hell, even in the 2014 playoff run, we were not a complete team - anyone remember the frequent turnovers and special teams miscues? They could have killed us if things hadn't somehow fallen our way.
I have to ask, why has this not been solved by now? It's year 5. I still hold my breath whenever we field a punt (Jalin, Dontre, whomever); I still hold my breath whenever we kick off. Our playcalling and offense disappears for literally games at a stretch, only reappearing every now and then. Considering the talent we had on the team last year (and how well that talent is playing in the NFL), and the QB we have this year, I find it unfathomable that we have not gotten more out of our players.
I trust in Urban - he will go down as one of the best coaches in the history of CFB - but he can make mistakes. We need to address some fundamental underlying problems that have been here since he took over, if we aspire to the level of excellence that Saban has right now, Carroll had at USC, and Osborne had at Nebraska.