Zurp;647871; said:
I believe that using the scenario stated above (Lynn Brant), the Rose Bowl loses their Big Ten automatic bid, because Ohio State was the Big Ten's automatic bid. The Rose Bowl then gets to choose an at-large team. Being the Rose Bowl, they will most likely choose a Big Ten team. They like the tradition of Big Ten vs. Pac-10. And, they would also most likely choose Michigan over Wisconsin because of the head-to-head matchup.
But I don't believe that Michigan is guaranteed a BCS bowl game unless they are in the top 4.
This is essentially correct. However, if Michigan were BCS #4, and BCS #3 was also from the same conference as a team that's BCS #1 or #2, only the #3 team would get an automatic bid.
I'm going to need another recording for that one over the next month.
Here's an overview of the BCS selection process for this season:
There are 10 BCS spots this year. Since there's no way a team from outside the 6 'BCS conferences' will be #1 or #2 this year, two bids are for Glendale on January 8th, and 4 more bids are taken by the other 4 BCS conference champions. (This could be 5 more bids, it tOSU/TSUN end up #1 and #2 in the BCS).
That leaves 3 or 4 bids. The next teams considered are those from the other 5 conferences. Only Boise State has a realistic chance to be in the BCS top-12 (or in the top-16 and ahead of one of the 6 BCS conference champions; this is very possible with the ACC champ, or if Texas is upset in their CCG). Note - even if more than 1 non-BCS conference school meets these criteria, only 1 will be given an automatic bid.
That leaves 2 to 4 bids. Next is the Notre Dame provision. If ND is in the top 8, they get an automatic spot. Note that they don't receive a full bowl payout any longer; if ND is in a BCS bowl, they receive the same BCS money as a second team from a BCS conference (close to $5 million, rather than $15-$17 million). That's new this year, and often not reported accurately.
That leaves 1 to 4 bids. If the #3 team is from a BCS conference but not that conference's champion, they get an automatic bid as long as the conference doesn't already have two teams qualified. If the #3 team doesn't grab an automatic bid under this provision, the #4 team is then considered under the same guidelines.
That leaves 0 to 4 bids. These are considered 'At large' bids, and can be any team with at least 9 wins in the BCS top 14, as long as they are not under NCAA sanctions which would prevent a bowl appearance. For marketing reasons, if Notre Dame is in the top 14, but not the top-8, they will almost always be selected for an at large bid over anyone else.
Here is the link to the full BCS selection process:
bcsfootball.org