Football
Michigan Monday
By Tony Gerdeman
Remember last week when Michigan was only up a touchdown for most of the Penn State game, but the game never really seemed in doubt? That was the situation again on Saturday, except there was a little more doubt in the air.
Much of that, of course, is attributable to Iowa quarterback Drew Tate, even though he's only better than Anthony Morelli in theory anymore.
The Wolverine defense continues to be dominant, and their 20-6 win over Iowa is indicative of that. However, as I mentioned last week, the offense is struggling.
Michigan only put up 291 yards of total offense on Iowa. It was the worst offensive performance against Iowa since Syracuse put up 280 yards on the Hawkeyes in week two. Here are the yardage totals that Iowa's Division I-A opponents have put up against them this season: Syracuse 280; Iowa State 323; Illinois 315; Ohio State 400; Purdue 456; Indiana 413. I understand that losing Manningham is big, but c'mon...
Still, offense isn't always necessary, and fans of the 2002 Buckeyes should keep that in mind.
So, with the victory over Iowa, the Wolverines have now officially completed the "iffy" portion of their schedule.
They now begin their prep for Troy Smith and the Buckeyes with games against Northwestern, Ball State and at Indiana. None of these games will provide a test for Michigan. However, when you include the Iowa game, they will have played four straight games against a mobile quarterback.
And while Troy Smith isn't any of those quarterbacks, it will give Michigan looks similar to the ones they'll be seeing against the Buckeyes.
Though it may not matter if Manningham is still out.
When Michigan Had The Ball
Even though they had it for most of the game, they didn't do much with it.
Iowa had the ball for 9:44 of the first quarter, then Michigan had it for over nine minutes in each of the final three quarters. Michigan finished with a 34:23 to 25:37 time of possession advantage. Which shouldn't be a surprise, since they lead the nation in that statistic.
With Mario Manningham still out, and no reliable timetable provided by Lloyd Carr, the Wolverines still don't have an available secondary downfield receiver. Adrian Arrington has taken Manningham's spot with some success, but he hasn't had the same impact. The same can be said for Greg Mathews and Steve Breaston, who have tried to pick up Arrington's slack as the "third" receiver.
Breaston is being sent downfield more, but Mathews is pretty much a short route guy. Nobody else has come forward and it doesn't look like anybody else is going to be asked to.
If these three receivers don't step it up even more, it's going to get harder and harder for Michael Hart to find room to run. Fortunately, the caliber of defenses they play won't provide any challenges.
Actually, I don't know if that truly is fortunate. I think you would want a better barometer of where your offense stands before you come to Columbus.
With just those three receivers to choose from, Chad Henne went back to the old Michigan staple--the tight end. This time it was Carson Butler. Though Butler only caught three passes, he showed athleticism and an ability to stretch the field. In fact, he averaged fourteen yards per catch on Saturday, which was by far the best on the team for the day.
Looking at the numbers for the receivers: Adrian Arrington had eight catches for 79 yards; Steve Breaston had seven catches for 49 yards; and Greg Mathews had three catches for sixteen yards. As you can see, that's not exactly stretching the field.
Interestingly, the Wolverines went five wide a few times, even though they only played four receivers on the afternoon.
On the day, Henne was a very respectable 23-33 for 203 yards with an interception. The interception was a pretty bad one, as he threw it downfield over the middle into double coverage and led his receiver too far.
He was sacked three times and the Michigan offensive line had more than a few struggles against the smaller, quicker Iowa defensive line.
Right tackle Rueben Riley allowed a sack that caused a Chad Henne fumble. Right guard Alex Mitchell was called for a couple of penalties. And left tackle Jake Long gave up a coverage sack. It wasn't the best day of pass protection, as Henne was pressured throughout the day.
The pass blocking wasn't the only area of concern for the Wolverines. Michigan ran the ball 39 times for 88 yards, for an average of 2.3 yards per carry. For comparison's sake, the Buckeyes ran the ball 50 times against the Hawkeyes for 214 yards, averaging 4.3 yards per carry.
Michael Hart carried the ball 31 times for 126 yards and scored two touchdowns. Even though there wasn't a lot of room to run, he wasn't credited with any negative rushing yards. His long run of the day was ten yards.
Hart did struggle a bit in the first half, carrying the ball ten time for 27 yards. However, in the second half, he and the offensive line managed to control the game. Hart had 21 carries for 99 yards in the third and fourth quarters.
No other running backs carried the ball for the Wolverines, and it still clearly looks to be a trust issue.
When Michigan Was On Defense
Per usual, Michigan's run defense was the story. They held the Hawkeyes to 41 yards on 24 carries.
The running game was abused on Saturday afternoon. Damian Sims ran the ball seven times, gaining 22 yards. Albert Young carried it nine times for seventeen yards. The best run of the day came on a 21-yard scramble by Drew Tate.
The tackles were pretty spread out for the Wolverines. The starting linebackers had three tackles apiece. In fact, the leading tackler at linebacker was reserve Chris Graham with four. It should be noted, however, that all three of Crable's tackles went for sacks, and included a forced fumble.
Michigan was playing five and six man fronts for much of the game. In so doing, they moved Shawn Crable all around. He was at rush end at times, where he would be the fifth man on the line and just go after the quarterback. He would also stand up inside and twist and stunt with the defensive tackles. Both instances bred success for the Michigan defense.
Every week, we talk about Alan Branch around this time. But today, let's mention defensive tackle Terrance Taylor first. He had four tackles on the day and was active from the first snap. He's only 6'0", so he can't just maul people like the 6'6" Alan Branch does. Taylor runs and pursues and doesn't stay blocked for long.
Anyway, back to Branch...he just mauls people. He doesn't need to shed blockers, he just takes them with him. Woodley gets all of the sacks and notoriety, but Branch will be the one cashing the bigger paychecks in a couple of years.
Speaking of Woodley, he had another two sacks today, including a forced fumble. He was chasing Drew Tate all day long.
When the Hawkeyes gave Tate time, he was able to go downfield and attack the secondary. He also rolled out on occasion and found receivers downfield. However, nearly every time he rolled out, he paid for it as soon as he released the ball.
So, while the rollout is effective, you have to weigh it against the prospects of a concussion.
The secondary was merely okay this week. And I believe the "okay" is a very accurate indicator of where the secondary is right now, and where it will be on November 18.
If Hawkeye receivers are running free in the secondary, what does that mean for the Ohio State receivers?
Leon Hall is the best cornerback on the team, but he was bailed out by bad throws or dropped passes on a few occasions Saturday. Morgan Trent is still not playing as well as he was prior to his injury, though he?s very close.
Defensive coordinator Ron English has mixed Johnny Sears into the cornerback rotation. He has potential, as does the long ago benched Charles Stewart, but Sears is too inconsistent and is still a bit overmatched.
Fortunately for Michigan, the schedule will now allow for mismatches in certain positions. It will make for good learning situations for those who need it. Namely, Sears and Trent.
Brandon Harrison has also been playing quite a bit, but it almost seems like he's the designated blitzer right now. He's small, so he's not always an easy pick up for the running back or the lineman.
Brandent Englemon and Jamar Adams went most, if not all of the way, at the two safety positions. While both are big hitters, and solid tacklers, neither is especially great in pass coverage.
It seems like the same story every week, but that's because it is.
The front seven is hiding a suspect secondary right now.
Special Teams
Michigan had their first big special teams play of the season, as Steve Breaston returned a kickoff 64 yards. He still can't really get anything going on the punt return, though. He had two returns for four yards, with a long of five.
Zoltan Mesko again did all of the punting. He has such a huge leg that he is capable of out-kicking his coverage. I don't know how wise it would be to give Ted Ginn fifteen yards of distance between he and the first gunner. Fortunately for the Wolverines, Mesko is also starting to find his touch. Of his five punts on Saturday, three ended up inside the twenty-yard line.
The Wolverine return defense wasn't too bad, though they did give up a nineteen-yard punt return to Dominique Douglas.
Garrett Rivas made all of his placements, kicking a 20-yard and 37-yard field goal, as well as hitting both of his extra point attempts. He also handled all of the kickoffs, putting three of his five kickoffs into the end zone for touchbacks. This is a distinct improvement from his 0-4 last week. Much like the punting situation, I wonder if Michigan will try to reach the end zone when they play the Buckeyes.
What Does It All Mean
It means that Michigan needs Mario Manningham badly, but not soon.
The offense will do enough to win the next three weeks.
Chad Henne will continue to try to find open receivers. But those receivers will have to do a better job of getting open.
The defense won't have any problems laying waste to their ninth, tenth, and eleventh opponents.
It also means that we are now in that portion of the season where Michigan and Ohio State are showing each other purposeful looks.
Michigan went with five wides and five and six-man fronts.
The Buckeyes, meanwhile, are throwing passes with Ted Ginn.
Even though the games may not be that interesting leading up to November 18, the gamesmanship sure will be.
The Road To The Big One
Sept. 2 Michigan 27 - Vanderbilt 7
Sept. 9 Michigan 41 - Central Michigan 17
Sept. 16 Michigan 47 - Notre Dame 21
Sept. 23 Michigan 27 - Wisconsin 13
Sept. 30 Michigan 28 - Minnesota 14
Oct. 7 Michigan 31 - Michigan State 13
Oct. 14 Michigan 17 - Penn State 10
Oct. 21 Michigan 20 - Iowa 6
Oct. 28 Northwestern at Michigan
Nov. 4 Ball State at Michigan
Nov. 11 Michigan at Indiana
Nov. 18 Michigan at Ohio State