Winning never is trouble free in big-time college football
COMMENTARY
Winning never is trouble free in big-time college football
Monday, May 03, 2004
BOB HUNTER
It all sounds so easy.
Hire a coach who will recruit "good" kids, so there are no surprises on the police blotter. Find a man who is as concerned about academics as he is about football, so ineligibilities are nonexistent. Bring in a leader who wants to do "the right thing," who will make the alums "proud" of the program again.
Ohio State coach Jim Tressel would seem to be all of those things. He has made a point of running a clean, respectable program, has tried to recruit quality individuals and has tried to make them accountable after they arrived on campus.
So why do we still wake up to uncomfortable surprises — two Buckeyes football players arrested and charged with robbing another OSU student — like the one that greeted newspaper readers yesterday morning?
Because it’s not as easy as it sounds.
Everybody wants good kids. Every school would like a team of budding geniuses, athletes equally adept at trigonometry and blocking schemes. Nobody wants troublemakers. I’ve never heard a coach say he wanted to win by recruiting players he knew he would have to keep bailing out of jail.
Some coaches clearly try harder than others to recruit players of solid character, and Tressel appears to be making the effort. But no matter how good a coach’s intentions, no matter how much he wants to recruit athletes who won’t embarrass the university, his options often are limited.
The reason for that is simple: It takes a special player to play football at places such as Ohio State, Miami, Oklahoma and Michigan, and there aren’t that many special players out there.
A coach can dedicate himself to pursuing only recruits of the highest character, but he faces a delicate balance. While he would love to have his roster filled with players he wouldn’t hesitate to bring to the family picnic, his job security still is based on how many games he wins.
If he gambles on too many A-plus character guys who are C-minus football players, three years from now he might be out of a job.
It should be clear by now that the OSU football program will never be completely problem free, regardless of who is coaching. There are plenty of ugly stories out there. No school is immune.
In the last few months, for example, Wisconsin, West Virginia, Penn State, Arkansas, Miami (Fla.), Colorado, Florida State, Virginia Tech and Mississippi State have been in the news because of the arrests of players or recruits.
The names of the schools don’t matter much. Start keeping tabs today and you’ll find that most schools wind up on the list sooner or later.
Not surprisingly, winning makes it more acceptable. Losing makes it intolerable. I have yet to meet an Ohio State fan willing to abide a string of 6-6 seasons in order to have the school represented by a bunch of fine, scholarly, well-behaved young men.
When John Cooper was fired, my mailbox was full of notes from fans who were troubled by the news reports coming out of their alma mater. Many found the suspensions, arrests and academic problems that plagued the football program to be painful and embarrassing. It goes without saying that those fans wouldn’t have been nearly as pained and embarrassed if Cooper’s teams had won more bowl games and beaten Michigan more often, but such is the nature of the beast. In the end, Cooper’s teams were losing and showing up on police reports, a definite no-no.
OSU fans were heartened when athletics director Andy Geiger made a point of seeking a coach who would clean up the mess, and in that sense, Tressel was the perfect choice. He went out of his way to get to know the players, tried to keep closer tabs on what they were doing and made an effort to recruit individuals who would make the program’s followers proud.
The fact that there still are embarrassing incidents, and the fact that some of his recruits have followed in the footsteps of their predecessors, indicates how hard it is to run the pristine program that nearly everyone demands. It also shows that the coach who recruited all those other "troublemakers" might not have been as bad as fans thought.
Bob Hunter is a sports columnist for The Dispatch .
[email protected]