What free game did you guys choose?
There are some shockingly great titles - BF3, ME3, NFSmw - the mass effect series ranks right behind Bad Company 2 as my favorite 360 game ever.
The rest seem really unappealing
Dead Space 3 - not a fan of the horror action genre in games or movies
Medal of Honor Warfighter - such poor reviews that they cancelled the entire series. Great choice to develop this instead of Bad Company 3
Simcity 4 - beyond the hilarity of including a title to remind folks what Maxis used to produce, I just can't imagine wanting to play this also, especially with the decade old graphics
Plants vs Zombies - great smartphone game, not about to get it again
Bejeweled 3 - seriously?
I think most would have preferred an expansion pack of some sort. Since a DLC credit wasn't going to happen, it would have been nice to get a building pack instead.