Dispatch
BEANIE?S BANE
Fumbling the football has been problem for talented Ohio State freshman Wells
Thursday, November 09, 2006
Ken Gordon
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
Ohio State?s Chris Wells lost his fourth fumble of this season midway through the second quarter against Illinois and cornerback Vontae Davis.
What to do with Chris "Beanie" Wells?
The Ohio State freshman tailback has loads of talent. He is a load, actually, at 6 feet 1 and 225 pounds of speed and muscle.
He can help the Buckeyes win games.
But Wells also has a problem. He fumbles. It?s fair to label him a fumbler at this point, because he has lost four this season and three in the past four games.
He can cause the Buckeyes to lose games.
So again: What to do with Beanie Wells?
"That?s the million-dollar question," said former Ohio State coach John Cooper, who once dealt with a similar problem when freshman Eddie George lost two costly fumbles in 1992.
Current coach Jim Tressel makes more than a million dollars, about $2.4 million this year, and he?ll earn it by how he handles Wells.
"How concerned am I? Tremendously concerned," Tressel said, "whether it?s Chris or anyone doing any job that isn?t getting done the way we need it. I?d like to think that he?ll one day get that under control, and I?m hoping it?s this day.
"He can add a lot to this team. Unfortunately, just like a quarterback who can add a lot to the team, if they throw it to the other guys ? What?s the risk vs. reward component? "
The Buckeyes are ranked No. l in the nation at 10-0. They play Saturday at Northwestern before facing Michigan on Nov. 18 for an apparent spot in the national-title game.
After his first three fumbles, Tressel put Wells back into games. Last Saturday at Illinois, he tried a different tack, sitting him for the last 2 1 /2 quarters.
It sounds as if he plans to give Wells another chance this week.
"If he practices well, he?ll be in good stead to go in and carry the ball like any other time," Tressel said. "About the only thing coaches can do is have someone sit down and think about it, but to me, there?s a certain length of time that makes sense. He had a chance to think about it through the second half of the (Illinois) game."
Current and former players say fumbling is a common problem with freshmen backs. Junior Antonio Pittman lost two fumbles in 72 carries his freshman season in 2004, and has lost just one in 438 attempts since then.
Tyrell Sutton, an Akron native and Northwestern sophomore, said he lost six or eight fumbles last season compared with two this season.
"I was trying to do too much and fight for extra yardage," Sutton said. "It?s great to fight for yards, but at the same time, you have to know when and where to go down."
Maurice Hall was a backup to freshman sensation Maurice Clarett in 2002. He watched Clarett fumble three times against Northwestern that year but still get put back in the game.
Hall believes sitting a fumbling back at the first sign of trouble can damage a player?s psyche. But he also thinks a repeat offender needs to be benched.
"I?ve seen both sides," Hall said. "If (Wells) continues to fumble, he has to have some kind of disciplinary action, that?s the only way he?ll learn.
"But if you sit someone down after one fumble, it does get into your head that if you make mistakes, you won?t play. Running backs are successful because of their instincts and decisions they make quickly. If you have to think about (not fumbling), it can eliminate your effectiveness."
So that?s both sides of the issue, but not really a definitive answer.
Being pragmatic sorts, coaches faced with this conundrum tend to boil the issue down.
"What other kind of players have I got?" Cooper asked. "If I have another capable running back I believe in, I?d probably play that guy."
Tressel has Pittman and Maurice Wells. Tressel said Maurice Wells was fine last week after suffering a shoulder stinger the week before, but he did not get a single carry at Illinois.
Clearly, Beanie will play Saturday. But if he fumbles for a fifth time, will he see the field against Michigan?
"Oh, gosh, I don?t know," Tressel said. "Give me the rest of the scenario. Am I the next tailback in the game? Then he?s playing."