jwinslow;738010; said:
Feedback please, Wii owners/users...
Were you frustrated with the 3d control at first? I've tried it a few times in stores... and I found the 3d control a bit cumbersome. The tennis stroke was particularly awkward and inaccurate.
Was this something you guys struggled with at first, but overcame with practice?
It might also have been a calibration issue with the test units in the stores.
Lots of things could be at play here, such as the location of the IR sensor bar, the battery life remaining in the Wii Remote, and EMI. Electronics departments or stores aren't set up well to demo the Wii because the IR can go screwy with the flourescent lighting.
I have no problem with mine in my home. The IR pointer is good up to about 15 feet from the TV and the Bluetooth connection is good a little beyond that with the basic Wii channel menus and Wii Sports. Where I do have a problem is with Rayman: Raving Rabbids, which can drop the Wii Remote pretty easily at about half the range of Zelda or Wii Sports.
From my reading, the Wii Remote sends orientation signals (X, Y, and Z axis + yaw, pitch, and roll) which are computed by the game, not the console itself. This allows developers to make things as 'loose' or 'tight' as they might want. Ubisoft's current titles, such as Rayman, have very 'tight' controls, but the range is for shit because the data rate/error correction to read that level of precision requires the controller to be a little closer to the console.
It will probably take a generation of titles before the full potential of the remote is unlocked.
Incidentally, Wii Sports is designed for the whole family, from the kids to the grandparents. The controls are very loose (I think by design) and you'll probably find the controls read more accurately if you slow down and make more deliberate motions as opposed to being a spazz and flailing like you're playing a real sport. :p Tennis has a surprising amount of control, whether you're doing lobs, smashes, or applying spin to the ball, provided you just slow your stroke down a little. It took me about three or four matches to figure it out.
I would presume EA's control precision will be far more accurate than Nintendo's; that's what EA does.