ulukinatme;889449; said:
Nintendo made good decisions with the Wii, but the originality in the games is lacking, some of this is with their ol' bread and butter titles though. I heard a lot of good things about Zelda, I'm playing it, but it feels like the same 'ol story. The story might as well be Zelda: A Link to the Past. The parrallels to previous game storylines/sidequests are endless. I'm beginning to think Nintendo can do little with the Zelda title besides rehashing old stories/themes.
Zelda: TP I can see that argument, but the franchise as a whole -- I'd disagree. WindWaker on the GameCube and Phantom Hourglass on the DS have been critically and commercially successful, and their cel-shaded design goes completely against the previous Zelda styles.
For the Wii as a platform, I'd say that third parties are more to blame than Ninty. Virtually everybody but Ubisoft hedged on their Wii projects, or assigned their "B teams" to do crude Wiimakes of PS2 games. Ubisoft was the only company fully on board right out of the gate, and though a lot of their schlock was crap (hey, they're still Ubi), they did score million sellers with Red Steel and Rayman Raving Rabbids. Capcom did a Wiimake right with Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition, which looks like it'll break 1M world wide too.
The "big" titles written from the ground up for the Wii will begin dropping next month, as third parties have been playing catch-up for most of the past year. It really isn't anymore complex than that. The lack of games targeting the hard core weren't there because devs wrote Nintendo off.
Oops.
As for the "originality" + Nintendo argument. That's complete bullshit. In the past two years Ninty has released A TON of new IP for all their platforms. The Wii branded games, Animal Crossing, the Touch Generation games like Brain Age & Big Brain Academy, Nintendogs, etc ... It's the Western developers that couldn't design their way out of a wet paper bag. What happened when Mario Party became a smash? We got a shitload of bad minigame collections! What happened when Nintendogs sold 10M copies? We got a shitload of bad Petz sims. What happened when Brain Age sold 1M? We got a shitload of puzzle/brain training games.
It's hysterical to me that Nintendo-bashers complain about how unoriginal Nintendo has become, then go back to playing the 15th EA football game on their platform of choice, or maybe their preferred first person shooter.
What "big" games are the other platforms banking on? Halo
3. Gran Turismo
5. God of War
3. Final Fantasy
13. Hot Shots Golf
5. Ratchet & Clank
whatever. Grand Theft Auto: Pimps & Hos edition!!!111!!
There
is a dearth of originality in the video game industry, but that's not Nintendo's problem.