Rob Oller commentary: Criticism finds every coach, even Tressel
Saturday, November 8, 2008 3:10 AM
By
Rob Oller
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
Sooner or later, Teflon wears thin. Just ask Jim Tressel. It wasn't long ago -- right after Ted Ginn Jr. returned the opening kickoff for a touchdown in the 2006 national championship game, to be exact -- that Tress was untouchable.
Today, after consecutive national championship game smackdowns, an embarrassing loss to Southern California and a disappointing loss to Penn State this season, the Coach Who Could Do No Wrong is experiencing criticism that seems to be sticking.
As it always does. Eventually.
A trip down memory lane:
Three seasons removed from winning the 1968 national championship, Woody Hayes found For Sale signs in his lawn. Seems that the fans -- make that the fringe fans, who almost always are the main culprits in over-the-top tirades -- didn't take a shine to Ohio State's 6-4 record in 1971. Never mind that the Buckeyes went Greg Oden that year with serious injuries to at least six starters, Hayes was over the hill. His methods were outdated. He needed to go.
The Buckeyes returned to the national title hunt with Hayes at the helm in 1974 and '75, but lost back-to-back Rose Bowls after those seasons -- apparently the current big-game meltdown curse is nothing new -- which only intensified the talk that Woody's ways no longer worked.
Tressel, six seasons removed from the 2002 national title, is taking heat for a lackluster offense that has failed to score a touchdown in three of its nine games this season. Like Hayes, he is being accused of holding too tightly to his playbook. Woody would entrust his offensive assistants with designing progressive plays that were used in practice but seldom saw the light of day come Saturday.
More recently, Lloyd Carr led Michigan to its first national title in 50 years in 1997 -- and was gone 11 seasons later. And the latest riches-to-rags story belongs to Phil Fulmer, who this week was pushed out at Tennessee 10 years after coaching the Vols to the 1998 national championship.
Comparing Tressel with those two coaches would be silly, because he is so far removed from facing a similar fate. Carr and Fulmer failed to win enough games, period. Tressel's win total -- he goes for No. 81 today at Northwestern, which would tie him with Earle Bruce for third-most in school history -- and winning percentage (.816) are worthy of respect, not to mention a long-term contract.
Cont...