Hafner's bell stops ringing
Tribe's DH uses hard work and humor during recovery from concussion
Sunday, February 05, 2006 Paul Hoynes
Plain Dealer Reporter
Travis Hafner has run and run and run this winter. He's waited for the dizziness and headaches to return. Waited for the dullness to overtake his body.
So far, there's been nothing.
Hafner takes that to mean he's over the concussion he suffered last season on July 16 when Chicago's Mark Buehrle hit him in the face with a fastball. The injury put him on the disabled list for 17 games and lingered for the rest of the season.
While Hafner's equilibrium has returned, his sense of humor never left.
"The dizziness is gone," he said recently.
The punchline followed with the timing of a good stand-up comic.
"Of course, I still have a tendency to forget people's birthdays and anniversaries," Hafner said.
When Hafner came off the DL on Aug. 4, he made no mention of the post-concussive symptoms that clung to him. No one else talked much about them either.
Hafner doubled in his first at-bat against the Yankees after being activated. He singled home a run in his last at-bat of that game. All seemed right with the man called Pronk.
The statistics said so as well. After getting hit by Buehrle's pitch in the first inning on July 16, Hafner was hitting .310 (89-for-287) with 23 doubles, 18 homers and 63 RBI. When he came off the DL, he hit .296 (59-for-199) with 19 doubles, 15 homers and 45 RBI in 54 games.
But Hafner says he went through stretches where he played through dizziness and headaches. If he elevated his heart rate too much by running or other physical activity, the symptoms could return.
Along with the symptoms came a dullness of spirit.
"In some games you'd lost your competitiveness," Hafner said. "It's tough to explain. You didn't feel like going out there. You just didn't feel like getting up for the game.
"I've talked to other baseball players who have had concussions. They said the same thing. You just didn't have that drive."
Hafner said there were times when he went to the plate and found it hard to concentrate. Humor helped him get through it.
The left-handed hitting DH thought about hitting right-handed.
"I figured if I got hit on the right side of my head, I'd be back to normal," Hafner said.
Hafner, 28, ended the season hitting .305 (148-for-486) with 42 doubles, 33 homers and 108 RBI. He ranked second in the American League in OPS (on- base percentage plus slugging percentage) to AL MVP Alex Rodriguez, 1.031-1.003. He finished second in RBI among DHs to Boston's David Ortiz, 141-106.
Like his teammates, Hafner still has a hard time dealing with the final week of last season. The Indians had a chance to win the AL Central or the wild card, but lost six of their last seven games.
"I don't know if you ever get over it," Hafner said. "You use it to motivate you during the off-season. I think we can learn a lesson from it to help us this year."
The Indians, starting with a Sunday afternoon loss to Kansas City on Sept. 25, lost two out of three to Tampa Bay and were swept by Chicago in the final three games of the season.
"It's pretty simple what happened," Hafner said. "We didn't score enough runs. We left a lot of runners on base."
Five of the Indians' six losses were by one run. The other was by two. They averaged just over two runs per game in those defeats.
"There's no way to describe it but frustrating," Hafner said. "We should have a really good team for a long time here. You just hate to have that kind of opportunity and not take advantage of it."
To reach this Plain Dealer reporter:
[email protected], 216-999-5754