It's probably unfair to lump all of these guys together, but it makes for a more interesting poll:
Michael Doss: All American (2000, 2001, 2002); national championship (2002)
Malcolm Jenkins: All American (2007, 2008); Thorpe Award (2008)
Shawn Springs: All American (1996); Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year (2006)
Jack Tatum: All American (1969, 1970); National Defensive Player of the Year (1970); national championship (1968, 1970)
Antoine Winfield: All American (1997, 1998); Thorpe Award (1998)
Michael Doss: All American (2000, 2001, 2002); national championship (2002)
Malcolm Jenkins: All American (2007, 2008); Thorpe Award (2008)
Shawn Springs: All American (1996); Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year (2006)
Jack Tatum: All American (1969, 1970); National Defensive Player of the Year (1970); national championship (1968, 1970)
Antoine Winfield: All American (1997, 1998); Thorpe Award (1998)