Calling UTMNC, calling UTMNC, you've got a new motivational speaker for your support group.
To be fair about this whole discussion here is how it seems to balance out.
The losses on Texas' D were significant, but they have a large core of players returning.
The players not returning to Ohio State's D were large in number and in presence last year. However, the returning players often have significant experience in D-1A play, either with the Buckeyes, or in the case of Kerr for a full season at Indiana.
No loss though can really compare to what was a hearbreak of an early exit for Longhorn fans in the party of Vince Young. Like Brown himself said, you can no longer count on 3rd and 30 (or I suspect 3rd and 10) conversions being exciting and frequent occurences. Tack on the loss of Ramonce Taylor and suddenly you have a lot of last years scoring taken off the field of play.
Unlike the players who have to step up into the shoes of the Ohio State D '05 starters the key player(s) who fill the gaping void left by Vince Young have not had a start. I know we keep harping on this, but it is true. Had Troy Smith left early we would have been looking very hard at the capabilities of Schoenhoft and Boeckman in Spring Game settings. Because we were looking forward we did that anyway. Like some Texas fans concerning McCoy or Snead, our general feeling is that these guys are "doing better than we hoped for." Realistically though that does not mean they would step in and run the offense with the same smooth and instinctive quality that Smith brings to the table. He evades trouble from the back side and makes the extra yard with his own legs if the play breaks down in front of him. Which was exactly part of the extra special pizazz Young would bring to the UT offense with frequency.
Expecting someone to even be a pale shadow of that well honed player is unreasonable. To quote Brown, literally this time:
And the unwritten part of that is how much game experience will be needed. Its game two, September 9th, remember? I honestly find it hard, well nigh impossible to believe that a firm, fixed and constant fixture decision will have been made at QB by then - when your warm up is against North Texas.