I think saying tOSU is a top-5 team to start next year is a little crazy. There's gonna be a lot of holes to fill. You don't lose a RB the calibre of Beanie and Senior leaders like JL and MJ on defense and improve that much. I know we tend to reload vice rebuild, but we're losing three "All-Timers" right there.
I think Boom will make the transition a little eaier. Add in Hyde, Berry and hopefully a healthy Zoom and that's a good stable of backs. Posey may step in and be better than Robo, but you can't replace the experience/leadership he provided. I'm sure somebody like Sabino or Spitler will step in and do an admirable job of replacing Freeman and JL, but there's sure to be a dropoff there. You cannot expect to come close to replacing a shutdown corner like MJ. You saw the respect he garners last night when the 'horns flat-out avoided him. Hopefully Chimdi uses last night as motivation to step up his game and DWash, a healthy Amos and some of the youngsters can help at least minimize that loss. Hopefully Coleman and Russell both come back because they are both very good safeties.
The two areas I expect BIG improvement from are along the lines. There will be a major talent upgrade on the OL, and if they stay healthy, they should be better than this years group with ease. Along the DL, Gibson and Williams are gonna be beasts off the edge, and Denlinger, Heyward, Rose, Goebel et al will make for a very strong rotation.
I think we should certainly be positioned in the top 5 next year and here's why.
First Defensively
First off Both offensive and defensive lines as you said should be better. The pressure off the edges from Williams/Gibson should be one of the better we've had in a while. The DT's should be insanely deep as well which in turn will allow the young LB's to transition in nicely.
Second, Sabino is a tremendous talent (5 star) and has shown to be a bigger hitter on special teams. You add him with Homan (who really played well this year) as well a trio of Moeller, Sweat, Rolle/Bell will do a great job as well.
Another reason is the DB's while we lose the best corner in the nation should also be very talented. We'll have Donald Washington as well as Chikwa as corners with tons of experience, and we'll have one of the best saftey groups in the nation with Coleman/Russel. Also at nickle is Hines who IMO is going to be the most talented DB we have next year, and passing on our bucks could be a hard task
Over all we don't lose that much one defense. We'll get Wilson back (again) on the D-line and with a very strong Dline/secondary we should be extremely hard to move the ball against. Only question is obviously can our Lb's step in and make an impact, but with the way our LB's in the past have filled in we shouldn't have troubles.
On Offense
First, The offensive line. While we lose three starters we, IMO, will be much much better. You'll have three 5 star talents on the line in Shuggarts, Brewster, and Adams who are just Nasty! Then you will have Boren as a lock at one gaurd who I hear is very impressive, and Cordle/Browning at another gaurd spot.
Second, the QB play. Terrelle Pryor with spring ball and fall practice under his belt is going to make him that much better. With a more talented offensive line he'll also have a better shot with his already freak talent. Improved Knowledge of the game, and more work on his passing abilities is going to take him to that next level.
Running backs-Sure we'll most likely lose Beanie but we do reload rather nicely. As stated on here I'm not so sure Beanie/Pryor in the same backfield as ever that great of a set. Pryor thrives in shotgun and Beanie thrived in the Iformation so perhaps it will make the offense even more diverse having a back like Herron who seemed to do well no matter what the formation? I personally also feel like Hyde from florida will have a HUGE impact (think beanie 06), and you add Berry who is electric as well so things aren't as bleak as you think.
Recievers- We lose Robo, but we are going to be STACKED at the WR position. IF hartline returns great, but if not then we'll have tons of talent either way. Posey, Sanzo, Thomas, Stoney, Washington, and Small is a great set of WR's. With the incoming Freshman class maybe including Marlon Brown we should be very talented.
Overall Pryor should have more time to throw, and a better grasp of the game which in itself can make our offense better overall than this years squad. The new talent stepping in IMO is just sadly to say more explosive than this years version (Thomas, Stoney, Berry).
I certainly think we should be right up there with the best. Texas, USC, Florida, and Bama are going to be AMAZING. However, PSU not so much IMO with the loss of those three recievers. IN order I think it would go something like this
1. Florida
2. Texas
3. USC
4. OSU
5 Bama
It'll come down to USC/OSU in that second week again to determine who's season is going to be great IMO I dunno if we can do it but we should atleast have the horses now to compete greatly with USC. Quick worry, That USC offensive line does worry me, but hopefully a better Defensive line helps erase that.