Romeo's choice? It was no choice at all
by Terry Pluto Wednesday September 24, 2008, 6:58 PM
The Browns did exactly what I feared -- announced Derek Anderson would start Sunday in Cincinnati, but they also saidBrady Quinn had better stay "ready."
If you're Anderson, the message is clear: Don't mess up or you sit.
If you're Quinn, you are told to prepare like a starter, only you will split the snaps inpractices with Anderson.
If you're the other players, you have to wonder who the coaches want to be the quarterback.
This is absolutely, positively the wrong approach because of its indecision.
John Kuntz/The Plain Dealer
ROMEO'S HOOK
Romeo Crennel has changed quarterbacks in every season he has been Browns coach. Here's a look at the circumstances.
2005
In Game 10, starter Trent Dilfer was pulled during a 22-0 victory over Miami. Charlie Frye played one series in the second quarter and two series in the fourth quarter. After the game, Dilfer was visibly upset with the coach's decision.
In Game 11, a 24-12 loss at Minnesota, Frye received one series in the fourth quarter. Actually, it was one play -- an interception.
Frye started the final five games, playing every snap, and won two.
2006
In Game 12, Frye suffered an injury to his wrist. Derek Anderson relieved him and orchestrated a comeback overtime win over the Chiefs, 31-28.
Anderson started the next three games, losing each.
Frye returned to start Game 16, a 14-6 loss in Houston.
2007
In Game 1 against Pittsburgh, Frye was yanked in the second quarter after suffering five sacks and one interception. Anderson finished the game.
Two days later, Frye was traded to Seattle. Anderson started the remaining 15 games, winning 10, and earning an alternate spot in the Pro Bowl.
In Game 16, Anderson left in the second quarter with a finger injury. Brady Quinn came in for one series and led Browns to a field goal. Anderson started the second half and finished the game.
-- Tony Grossi
Crennel is a conservative, loyal man. The coach feels an attachment to Anderson, who saved the 2007 season after the disheartening 34-7 loss to Pittsburgh in the opener as Anderson was 10-5 as a starter. Crennel could have said, "I believe in D.A. He's my guy and I'm sticking with him."
Like it or not, that is a firm approach.
Cont...