Last time we took the best player on the board, we ended up with Braylon.
I'm all for taking AP (depending on the potential trade downs) or one of the premier DLs/CBs in the draft in the first IF we take OL in the 2nd for sure. Having Tucker back (if he can get back into game shape) really changes the complexion of the offensive line. That said, I truly think you can get 1st round quality at OL in the 2nd round.
Another thing I wouldn't be opposed to would be trading Braylon for a 7th round pick and taking CJ. Kidding, I'd demand at least a 6th rounder for his piss poor attitude.
If we can get a stud in the 2nd to play on the left side of the line (and start early on in his Browns' career), then grabbing Peterson in the first becomes very attractive.
Then again, there's the whole QB thing. I am not, never have been, nor will be sold on Frye. Even when the line holds up, he does not impress me. I think the fact that the coaches have said that the starting QB spot is no longer his, but instead an open role, says A LOT. That and who knows, it looks like we could now be a contender for Schaub or Carr (who I still don't think is done in the NFL).