buckiprof;1614640; said:
So with that said, do you believe that if He were the QB at OSU and had the same career at OSU as at UF that the media love affair with Him would be the same?
I don't know - probably. Let's see what kind of media love Terrelle Pryor gets next year, when the media will need a new darling.
I've never bought the theory that the media hates Ohio State. Sure, we see Buckeye hit pieces from time to time, but every school gets those. The AP poll, which is comprised of media voters, always seems to rank the Buckeyes about where they belong. In the recent past, the media have pimped Buckeye players like James Laurinaitis and Malcolm Jenkins, for example.
I think that the "media hate" is more a perception of an overly sensitive, insecure fan base than it is a reality. Any actual media hate is likely the result of three factors: (1) Ohio State is a large target that is always in the media spotlight, (2) Ohio State (and the Big Ten in general) has a ready-made media template (big, fat, slow farm boys), and (3) Jim Tressel is not cozy with the media and doesn't give a great interview. It doesn't help matters that Jim Tressel's offensive game plans often look like they were specifically designed for a team full of big, fat, slow farm boys, which just serves to reinforce the media template described in point number two. :)
Look, a team that habitually loses big games on the national stage deserves negative attention from the media, and that's exactly what Ohio State has gotten over the past three years. The Buckeyes take plenty of shit from their own fans, yet we expect the media to treat them with kid gloves? Ain't gonna happen. Right now, the media has no reason to admit that they have been wrong about Ohio State, because, quite frankly, they haven't been wrong. The Buckeyes have lost their last five big-time out-of-conference games - Florida in 2006, LSU in 2007, USC in 2008, Texas in 2008, and USC in 2009 - and, to be honest, they haven't exactly looked like lean, athletic, thoroughbreds in doing so. The Buckeyes need to string together some impressive victories - Oregon in the Rose Bowl, Miami next September, maybe even a BCS championship game - before the media template is going to change. Beating other teams that fit Ohio State's template (i.e. other Big Ten teams) just isn't going to impress the national media, who are looking for a different template ... just like guys who want MMA aren't going to be impressed with sumo wrestling.
Back to Tim Tebow for a minute ... If Troy Smith had gone on a mission instead of taking money from a booster ... and if Troy Smith had beaten Florida in 2006 instead of showing up out-of-shape and disinterested ... and if Troy Smith had led his team to one national championship, much less two ... then maybe Troy Smith would have been a media golden child, too ... and maybe Troy Smith would be praised and adulated by the media as one of the best college football players of all time and not regarded as just another Heisman bust who couldn't get it done when it counted the most.
So, I think that the media, in general, is tough but fair ... and that Ohio State gets some crap from the media because the Buckeyes haven't really been all that praiseworthy recently. And Florida has ... and Tim Tebow has ... so deal with it. When Ohio State changes for the better, then so will the media coverage.