Here’s another way of looking at what happened against ND, using the drive chart.
FIRST HALF
tOSU: from their 25, 8 plays for 33 yards, minus 5 for a false start, punted from the ND 47
ND: from their 11, 14 plays for 71 yards, stopped on 4th and 1, Simon tackled Hartman on sideline and replay reversed the spot
tOSU: from their 18, 3 and out, 3 runs for 8 yards, punted from their own 26
ND: from their own 32, 7 plays for 39 yards, missed a 47-yard FG after 2 straight incomplete passes.
tOSU: from their own 29, 13 plays for 70 yards, stopped at the 1 on a Miyan run for no gain and an incomplete pass
ND: from their own 1, 5 plays for 32 yards, 1 first down, punted from their own 33 after an incomplete pass
tOSU: from their own 21, 12 plays for 66 yards, including PI on Harrison’s catch, 31-yard FG with 26 seconds left in half
ND: from their own 25, took a knee for -1 yard to end the half
SECOND HALF
ND: from their own 25, 8 plays for 36 yards, after 2 straight 1-yard Estime runs, Hartman stuffed on 4th and 1 at tOSU 39
tOSU: from their own 39, 1 play for 61 yards, Henderson‘s speed and Harrison’s block result in a TD, 10-0
ND: from their own 25, 13 plays for 75 yards, all runs except 1 15-yard pass, scored on first and goal from the 1
tOSU: from their own 35, 7 plays for 24 yards, including 15-yard personal foul on Fryar that wiped out a 1st down at ND 28
ND: from their own 4, 11 plays for 96 yards, including a 28-yard pass wide open over the middle, and a clutch throw by Hartman on third and ten inside 3 defenders. Scored on a 2-yard pass with trips left and a man motioning behind them that the Buckeyes didn’t handle
tOSU: from their own 25, 7 plays for 64 yards, including a deep PI against Henderson after a false start. Henderson was short on 3rd and 1, and Egbuka was stopped on a jet sweep.
ND: from their own 11, 5 plays for 16 yards, including JT’s TFL for a -5 on first down, and JT knocking down a screen pass that would have almost certainly sealed the game if it had been complete. Punt to the tOSU 35 with 1:26 left
tOSU: from their own 35, 15 plays for 65 yards in 1:25; including a 23-yard pass to Egbuka on 3rd and 10, a conversion on 4th and 7 to Fleming, a 19-yard completion to Harrison at the 13, intentional grounding creating a 3rd and 19 at the 22 with 15 seconds left (final timeout prevented a 19-second runoff), a 21-yard pass to Egbuka creating a first down at the 1 with 9 seconds left, a quick spike, a timeout by ND after which they only had 10 defenders for tOSU’s incompletion and the TD by Chip with ‘no time’ left. 17-14 after XP was kicked when 1 second was put back on clock.
ND: from their own 35, after squib kick went out of bounds, a multi-lateral play resulted in an 8 yard loss.
So ND only had 7 actual possessions that weren’t the last play of either half, and they got 351 yards on 65 plays. Taking away the -8 on the last play, and the -1 on the kneel down, and giving their offense credit for 10 yards on a holding by Igbinosun, they gained a net of 370 yards on 7 possessions. That’s almost 53 yards per possession, which is a rather alarming number.
On ND’s 7 drives, they had:
2 punts after only moving a short distance, including their final ‘real‘ possession
1 missed FG from 47 yards
2 stops of Hartman on 4th and 1, one of those via a replay reversal that actually went tOSU’s way
2 long TD drives, mostly on the ground, in the second half
On tOSU’s 8 drives, they had:
1 TD on an explosive run
1 TD on a clutch 85-second, 65-yard drive
1 31-yard FG
2 stops on downs, 3rd and 4th from the 1, and 3rd and 4th and 1 from the 11
1 three-and-out
1 punt from near midfield to the ND 11
1 punt from near midfield to the ND 4, after a penalty wiped out a first down to the ND 28
The fact that ND had 1 less possession with a chance to score was significant. Buckeye scores in the final 30 seconds of each half caused that. Both teams were stopped twice on 4th and 1, with tOSU being closer to a TD on both of those failed 4th downs.
ND fans will bemoan the missed FG, their two 4th downs being stuffed when Hartman was running, and only having 10 guys on the field for the final 7 seconds after their own timeout.
Buckeye fans will bemoan the 4 failed plays on third and fourth and 1, and the personal foul that could be called finishing a block that killed a drive. The play calls and execution on short yardage obviously have to improve significantly for the teams goals to be achieved.