Posted: Yesterday*8:16*AM
TJBlog: A Recruiting Tale*
A Recruiting Tale
Now listen to ma story about a man named Jeb ...*
Jeb's a junior football player, goes to a school within driving distance of Ann Arbor, a school that is friendly with U-M.
Jeb comes in on a spring/summer visit, gets offered -- it's his first offer, he's excited, he says yes -- he commits!
U-M runs through the conditions, that he can't take visits, etc. ... however ... it's like the part of the 'TV ad for medicines' where they run through all the risks while showing playing wonderful music and showing smiling, wonderfully-happy people on the drug -- Jeb hears the conditions, sort've, but he's excited! *Jeb hears, "we want you at Michigan! wah-wah-wah ... Here's a scholarship! wah-wah-wah" ... and Jeb's sitting there thinking, "I'm a Wolverine!"
For most kids - this all works out fine down the road, etc.
But for a couple/few kids ... Jeb starts performing really well, better than expected, and his stock shoots up, schools start coming at him, big schools, inviting them on visits ... maybe it's glamor schools, maybe it's schools Jeb followed as a kid, maybe it's schools his parents actually prefer. Whatever it is -- Jeb wants to take at least one visit, just to be sure.
And then ... this is when the finality of the no-visit condition descends on him for the first time. Reality hits. Jeb gets reminded that heagreed to a no-visit condition ... so, initially, Jeb backs off. But, meanwhile, these other schools -- and maybe his parents -- keep up the pressure.
And, eventually, Jeb takes a visit. Jeb tells U-M first, etc.
Maybe at the visit Jeb realizes he wants to stick with Michigan.
However, from U-M's point of view, the commitment is broken -- if U-M excuses the visit, then their policy vanishes into thin air.
So ... then, from U-M's point of view, this can go two ways from here.
1. They tell Jeb - we're parting ways with you, good-bye.
2. They tell Jeb - we're 'recruiting your scholarship' but we're not dropping you, we're gonna recruit you - come visit in a couple-few weeks. (And from U-M's point of view, if the visit goes well they probably even plan to re-commit the kid at the visit). The school is hoping the kid accepts the punishment, accepts this plan, etc. (but they cannot 'tip their hand' to the kid about their plan - or again it's not actually punishment)
But from Jeb's point of view: it's like that TV-drug ad, only in reverse. Even if it is 'case 2' above, what Jeb hears is, wah-wah-wah ... 'the commit is off!' wah-wah-wah ... that he's being punished. Jeb is sitting there thinking, "I want to jump back into the fold here, I didn't like my visit, I'm Blue, but they're decommitting me!" And his parents may reinforce this point of view. So, Jeb goes, "Okay, I've got other schools begging, not punishing, me. They told me I'm no longer a commit - okay, I'm gonna take visits."
**Here's my bottom-line conclusion #1**
You cannot blame the school for having this policy -- a 'powerful program' can implement this policy (a 'weak program' cannot), and if this program gonna have lots of early-commits it is an effective way of 'keeping them on the farm'. And, from the coaches' point of view, they feel like they're already 'coaching the kids up' as soon as they commit, etc. But, there may inevitably be a couple kids as spelled out above.
And, you can't blame Jeb either (I know some zealous fans will take an extreme point of view on it and trash the kid, even tho they'd scream bloody murder if the situation happened to them). If you think about it, actually think about it ... it happens - you 'buy the drug without fully understanding the side-effects' - we all do it. And you feel like you should be able to reconsider without being punished, that's just how you feel about it, that's Jeb's point of view.
**And, my my bottom-BOTTOM-line conclusion #2**
The policy becomes tricky if a kid violates it, especially if the school really still wants Jeb. How can you 'penalize' a kid (who hasn't really made a contract, just a 'pinky-swear' more or less) without running him off? Maybe you can, maybe you can't... it's tricky. We'll find out with Conley, er, Jeb -- we'll see if he visits Michigan, and then see what happens from there