This or That: Which Alabama transfer to Ohio State will be more impactful?
Brett Ludwiczak via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here
Photo by Ryan Kang/Getty Images
Sorry Seth McLaughlin, this is between Caleb Downs and Julian Sayin.
Back on the first day of 2015,
Ohio State was able to shock the world when they were not only able to beat Nick Saban and Alabama but did so with a quarterback who was third-string on the depth chart a few months prior to the start of the season. Nine years later the Buckeyes were not only celebrating the retirement of Saban, they were also the recipient of three transfers from Tuscaloosa who wanted a change of scenery after Saban decided to end his legendary coaching career.
Today we are going to focus on two of those transfers. Sorry Seth McLaughlin, it’s not that you’re not important; Buckeye Nation is just hoping not to hear your name called much during the season since if you are talking a lot about an offensive lineman, it likely means he isn’t living up to expectations.
Instead, we are going to focus on the impacts we could see from defensive back Caleb Downs and quarterback Julian Sayin.
Caleb Downs
Let’s start with the Alabama transfer who is going to make an instant impact. Downs burst onto the scene as a freshman last season, immediately inserting himself into the conversation as one of the best safeties in the country. Downs finished the season with 107 tackles and two interceptions. Not only was Downs named the Shaun Alexander National Freshman of the Year, he was also a first-team All-American.
Even though Ohio State is bursting with talent in the secondary, as soon as Downs announced he was transferring to Ohio State, he was considered the best player on the Buckeye defense. Along with being a defensive standout, Downs is likely to return some kicks for Ohio State this year.
Head coach Ryan Day even made some noise earlier this week when it was revealed Downs has been doing some work at running back. While I’m not putting a bunch of stock in Downs seeing any carries this year, if he does make some plays on offense this year, then it would be hard to keep him out of the Heisman conversation.
Kiyoshi Mio-USA TODAY Sports
What makes the transfer of Downs to Ohio State even more important is he possibly could be here for the next two seasons since he is a true sophomore. Even though there is a chance Downs could return to Alabama without penalty after this season, it’s hard to imagine the star safety wanting to head back to Tuscaloosa since Ohio State is loaded beyond this year, while nobody knows how the first year of Kalen DeBoer at Alabama is going to go.
Even though Downs didn’t commit to Ohio State out of high school, he still has a chance to go down as one of the greatest safeties in Buckeye history if he is able to build on the outstanding freshman season he had with the Crimson Tide. It’s evident just how electric Downs can be on the field since the coaching staff is working on different ways to get him on the field to impact the game.
Julian Sayin
Unlike Downs, Sayin has yet to take a snap in college football. In fact, Sayin was playing high school football in 2023 and was only at Alabama for a handful of weeks after enrolling earlier at the school. Once Saban announced his retirement, Sayin decided to hit the transfer portal and head to Columbus.
This isn’t the first time in recent memory that one of the top quarterback recruits in the country decided to become a Buckeye. Quinn Ewers also came to Ohio State and was back in Texas a few months later. With the loaded quarterback room, Ryan Day has assembled, it’s not a given that Sayin is with the Buckeyes in 2025.
There are differences between Sayin’s situation and what we saw from Ewers. The Texas quarterback threw off Ohio State’s plans when he reclassified to take advantage of NIL. Sayin completed his high school career so there wasn’t quite the rush to get on campus as we saw from Ewers. Also, Ewers didn’t feel like waiting behind C.J. Stroud, while Sayin knows he is going to be competing for snaps with some talented quarterbacks.
Photo by Jason Mowry/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
How college football teams manage quarterbacks has changed over the past couple of decades. Before, quarterbacks often sat for a couple of years before taking over as the starter. Now high-profile recruits are seeing time in the first year on campus, or at the latest their second season. It almost feels like what Texas did with Arch Manning is a bit of an anomaly, since he didn’t even see much mop-up duty.
Sayin likely won’t see a ton of playing time this year. It feels like Will Howard and Devin Brown will battle it out to be the starter. Not to say Sayin won’t put up a fight to earn some snaps this year, it just feels like in what is going to be the longest college football season we have ever seen, Day wants Howard to start since he does bring a ton of experience to Columbus. If there is an injury or Howard is ineffective, maybe you see Day and Chip Kelly give Sayin a shot to inject some life into the offense if he has shown the coaches enough in practice.
When it comes to 2025, that’s likely when you’ll see Sayin’s breakout campaign. With his passing ability and the loaded wide receiver room, Sayin should be one of the top quarterbacks in the country. The combination of Sayin and Jeremiah Smith could be lethal. What will be fun to watch is to see if Sayin can match the numbers C.J. Stroud put up in his two seasons at starting quarterback, since if he lives up to expectations, Sayin will be entering the 2027
NFL Draft.
I’m not saying (no pun intended) Air Noland and the others in this year's and next year’s quarterback room are going to roll over and just give Sayin the quarterback job, it just feels like the line of succession for Ohio State at quarterback has him at the head of the line for 2025 and 2026. Iron sharpens iron and all these tremendous quarterbacks are going to make each other better.
Continue reading...