Grumpy Old Buckeye: Ohio State vs. Akron
Michael Citro via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here
Adam Cairns/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK
A 46-point win does not mean things are as they should be.
Ohio State kicked off the 2024 season with a 46-point win over the Akron Zips, pulling away for a 52-6 victory. That’s a final score that may not be too far off from predictions, but it’s the way we got there in the end that held some surprises.
As a reminder for our longtime readers and a heads up to newcomers, the purpose of this column is to accentuate the negative, even when things are going great. Most of it is meant to be taken tongue in cheek, but it does contain kernels of truth.
With that said, here are the things that burned my toast when the Buckeyes played the Zips.
Freshman’s Follies
Jeremiah Smith is a recruit we’ve been hearing a lot about for a long time, and he showed why throughout the day on Saturday. However, his first college offensive series was one to forget. His first target of the season — and Will Howard’s first throw as a Buckeye — fell incomplete when Smith failed to look the ball in.
It squirted through his hands and hit him in the helmet. The play was set up well and may have turned into an explosive run after catch, but we’ll never know. The freshman then was late getting set on the ensuing short-yardage play. The penalty turned a third-and-1 into a third-and-6 because of the penalty.
Howard threw incomplete to Emeka Egbuka, who was hit early, but no flag flew for the pass interference infraction. Around the first weekend of the season, referees around the country have been letting defenders do a lot more grabbing and hitting early, so it wasn’t a big surprise, but it was still annoying.
More Laundry
Davison Igbinosun got Akron’s first offensive drive off to a great start when he foolishly launched himself at a sliding quarterback, picking up an obvious flag. The targeting penalty that was called always seemed likely to be overturned, and it was, but it was still a dumb thing for a veteran to do.
The penalty helped Akron with field position, and the Zips were able to move the ball into scoring position. Despite a sack by JT Tuimoloau and a bad snap, the Zips took a 3-0 lead with a field goal.
So Nice They Made Ohio State Do It Twice
It’ll be hard to ever convince me that Emeka Egbuka’s acrobatic catch wasn’t a touchdown near the end of the first quarter. The ruling on the field was that he came down out of bounds and the replays (even the live look, to me) clearly refuted that.
So, the officials decided the ball moved, which it did when the receiver was getting up. Prior to that, it appeared to be pinned to his body through contact with the opponent and then the ground. The coolness factor alone should have made it a touchdown. But no, it was upheld as incomplete after review.
That’s OK, because it allowed Smith to make his first collegiate touchdown catch instead. The freshman did well to locate the ball, pull it in, and get both feet in bounds in a tight corner of the end zone. The thing about ball is that ball don’t lie.
Offensive Line Struggles
Ohio State’s offensive line struggled with the interior run game all day, and at times missed pass blocking assignments and other blocks on the edge. While Donovan Jackson was out for this game, the problems seemed much larger than one player being out.
A microcosm of the overall performance came on a key third down early in the second quarter. Carson Hinzman was out in front of TreVeyon Henderson and was moving his head back and forth as if he was looking for someone to block. There was no lack of options. He had multiple defenders from which to choose, but he decided not to block any of them. Henderson was dropped after a short gain, and the Buckeyes failed on a fourth-and-5 situation, turning it over on downs.
Hinzman wasn’t the only problem. Josh Fryar had a difficult first quarter, and short-yardage situations were making Akron’s defensive line look like Georgia’s. The offensive line is a work in progress and will no doubt be a focus in practice this week.
Illegal Formation
A failure to line up correctly turned a third-and-3 — which would have been converted by Egbuka on a nice catch and run — into a third-and-8 situation. The Buckeyes still converted, with Howard firing a strike to Carnell Tate on the next play.
It’s early in the season, so I’ll look for improvement in this area. Eliminating preventable formation and pre-snap penalties before the schedule gets tougher is imperative. Those longer conversions aren’t as easy against better competition.
Illegal Numbering
Come on. I’m not sure I even knew this was a penalty. I nominally understood that two players with the same number couldn’t be on the field together, but I had literally never seen this call until Saturday. I think I’ve seen everything in college football now.
Protect the Players
Even as an Ohio State fan, it was uncomfortable, at first, and outrageous, as it continued, to see what Akron’s coaching staff did to quarterback Ben Finley. Anyone watching the game could see how much discomfort Finley was in after taking several big shots in the first half.
That continued with consecutive big hits from Jack Sawyer on the Zips’ first possession of the second half. Finley was in obvious pain, even as the CBS sideline reporter discussed how his ribs/chest area was deemed a non issue by Akron head coach Joe Moorhead. Akron then called a quarterback run, making matters worse. Finley finally couldn’t take anymore punishment and came out of the game.
The coaches are the adults here, not the players. They have a responsibility to protect the young athletes in their programs. Even if Finley was asking to stay in, Moorhead should have taken him off after the second Sawyer hit to at least let him catch his breath and get looked at by the training staff. To call a quarterback run (even if it was a run-pass option) on the next play was sadistic and borderline criminal, in my opinion.
I felt terrible for the kid, who was shown several times on the broadcast with an ice bag and still in obvious pain.
Those are the things that got my blood pressure up on Saturday. What stuck out to you?
Obviously, the above did not negate all of the positives from Ohio State’s opener. Smith looks like the next great OSU receiver. Henderson and Quinshon Judkins appear to be a formidable duo if they get any help from the offensive line creating running lanes. The defensive line looked physical, and Tuimoloau sniffed out multiple passes in the flat. The defense got three takeaways and scored on two of them. All of that was a welcome sight.
The Buckeyes are back at it at home next Saturday night when they host a Western Michigan side that gave Wisconsin a game this past week.
Continue reading...