BuckeyeMac;2007567; said:
Yes. I think it's going to be worse than what we are hoping for
While it's always interesting to contemplate being buggered by an agitated Ewok, I think your concerns may be overstated. The NCAA is in a tough spot. Throwing down on Ohio State when all of the violations are self-reported will do nothing but undermine the NCAA investigative process.
Think about this for a moment -- who has more resources to devote to a problem? A loaded athletic department that makes hundreds of millions a year, or the NCAA with hundreds of schools to police? Imagine five major programs at once stonewalling the NCAA rather than cooperating. Their cozy little system comes apart. They NEED schools to use their athletic department resources to self-report and do the enforcement for Indy, because there's no way in hell Indy can do it on their own.
If they slap Ohio State with serious penalties, we will be the very last major school ever to cooperate. From here on out, people will shut up, lawyer up, and the compliance departments will become oriented to defending against NCAA charges rather than monitoring and reporting.
As it stands, and as I've said before, the PR nightmare is already too costly. These sorts of violations by their nature should have been covered by the cryptic "suspended for violating team rules", and perhaps a private fine, censure or multi-game suspension for Coach Tressel. Having a major institution dragged through the media muck for nearly a year over a grand total of "violations" that add up to less than what many of us make in a few months is in-fucking-sane. Seriously. Look at the total dollar amount involved here. Now look at the television deal for one BCS conference. The NCAA is tearing the sport apart over the change in the couch when they're living in a 50 acre beachfront estate in Malibu.
And if they DO hit Ohio State hard, what do they do to Miami? Auburn? Oregon? Are they seriously going to gut every cash cow in the sport? Oregon is dead to rights on flat out buying Lache Seastrunk. Miami's troubles are better documented than anything since SMU. Auburn, if proven, may have committed the single worst recruiting violation in dollar terms ever. They've already sidelined USC for the next decade, and the dust hasn't quite settled on the aftermath of Kiffykins' quick run through Knoxville.
Given everything that's going on in the sport, laying the hammer down on one school that actually self-reported their own coach and star players, AND kept digging until it disassociated a booster and found even more violations is nuts. The NCAA needs more schools to act like OSU, not fewer. It's my opinion that if they do anything severe to Ohio State that their entire enforcement mechanism crumbles. There's simply no reason at all to self-report at that point; you just structure everything towards plausible deniability and let Yahoo! Sports do the digging.