For the purposes of these rankings, the 1800's are considered to be a single decade.
In these rankings, I have not included prestige from Hall of Famers because: (a) some players' (Jack Tatum, Jim Stillwagon) and many coaches' (Woody Hayes, Earle Bruce, John Cooper) careers spanned more than one decade, and (b) Hall of Fame inclusion is a lagging indicator of prestige (for example, Orlando Pace left Ohio State after the 1996 season, and he is still not in the College Football Hall of Fame).
The 1800's
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Michigan...........70.0.........5.4....
Nebraska...........33.0.........2.5....
Texas..............25.0.........2.0....
Penn State.........19.0.........2.0....
Notre Dame.........15.0.........1.0....
Georgia............14.0.........2.0....
Louisiana State....13.0.........1.8....
Southern Cal........9.0.........0.6....
Oklahoma............6.0.........0.4....
Tennessee...........5.0.........0.6....
Ohio State..........3.5.........0.3....
Florida.............0.0.........0.0....
Florida State.......0.0.........0.0....
Miami...............0.0.........0.0....
Alabama............-2.0........-0.1....
1900 - 1909
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Michigan..........184.5........14.2....
Nebraska...........73.0.........5.5....
Notre Dame.........55.0.........3.8....
Ohio State.........48.0.........3.6....
Louisiana State....48.0.........6.6....
Texas..............39.0.........3.2....
Penn State.........28.0.........3.0....
Oklahoma...........25.0.........1.7....
Alabama............22.0.........1.6....
Southern Cal.......17.0.........1.2....
Florida............13.0.........1.9....
Tennessee...........0.0.........0.0....
Florida State.......0.0.........0.0....
Miami...............0.0.........0.0....
Georgia...........-13.0........-1.9....
1910 - 1919
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Nebraska...........98.5.........7.5....
Notre Dame.........73.5.........5.1....
Texas..............72.0.........5.8....
Oklahoma...........65.0.........4.5....
Penn State.........62.5.........6.6....
Ohio State.........58.5.........4.4....
Michigan...........54.0.........4.2....
Tennessee..........29.5.........3.4....
Alabama............26.0.........1.0....
Georgia............25.0.........3.6....
Louisiana State....17.0.........2.3....
Southern Cal.......16.5.........1.1....
Florida............12.0.........1.7....
Florida State.......0.0.........0.0....
Miami...............0.0.........0.0....
1920 - 1929
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Notre Dame........158.0........10.9....
Alabama...........142.5........10.4....
Southern Cal......110.5.........7.6....
Michigan...........84.0.........6.5....
Nebraska...........64.0.........4.8....
Texas..............63.5.........5.2....
Tennessee..........62.5.........7.2....
Penn State.........40.0.........4.2....
Florida............39.0.........5.7....
Georgia............37.5.........5.3....
Ohio State.........26.0.........2.0....
Louisiana State....14.0.........1.9....
Oklahoma...........13.0.........0.9....
Florida State.......0.0.........0.0....
Miami..............-2.0........-0.3....
1930 - 1939
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Southern Cal......162.5........11.2....
Alabama...........128.5.........9.3....
Tennessee..........97.0........11.2....
Michigan...........93.0.........7.2....
Notre Dame.........84.0.........5.8....
Nebraska...........73.0.........5.5....
Louisiana State....65.5.........9.0....
Ohio State.........52.0.........3.9....
Oklahoma...........24.0.........1.7....
Georgia............24.0.........3.4....
Miami..............16.0.........2.1....
Texas...............8.0.........0.6....
Florida State.......0.0.........0.0....
Penn State.........-7.0........-0.7....
Florida...........-10.0........-1.5....
1940 - 1949
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Notre Dame........355.5........24.5....
Michigan..........177.0........13.6....
Ohio State........125.0.........9.4....
Georgia...........112.0........15.9....
Texas..............97.0.........7.9....
Oklahoma...........97.0.........6.6....
Alabama............74.0.........5.4....
Tennessee..........71.0.........8.2....
Southern Cal.......63.5.........4.4....
Penn State.........48.5.........5.1....
Louisiana State....33.0.........4.6....
Miami..............20.0.........2.6....
Florida State......19.0.........3.0....
Nebraska..........-16.0........-1.2....
Florida...........-17.0........-2.5....
1950 - 1959
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Oklahoma..........368.0........25.4....
Ohio State........164.0........12.3....
Tennessee.........123.0........14.2....
Louisiana State....97.0........13.4....
Notre Dame.........73.5.........5.1....
Texas..............59.0.........4.8....
Penn State.........43.0.........4.6....
Southern Cal.......41.0.........2.8....
Michigan...........28.0.........2.2....
Miami..............28.0.........3.6....
Florida State......21.0.........3.3....
Alabama............15.0.........1.1....
Florida............15.0.........2.2....
Georgia............13.0.........1.8....
Nebraska..........-17.0........-1.4....
1960 - 1969
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Alabama...........290.0........21.1....
Texas.............280.0........22.7....
Southern Cal......272.5........18.8....
Ohio State........150.5........11.3....
Notre Dame........132.5.........9.1....
Penn State........104.0........11.0....
Nebraska...........94.0.........7.1....
Louisiana State....86.0........11.9....
Florida............68.0.........9.9....
Tennessee..........67.0.........7.7....
Oklahoma...........60.0.........4.1....
Georgia............51.0.........7.3....
Michigan...........41.0.........3.2....
Florida State......25.0.........4.0....
Miami..............21.0.........2.7....
1970 - 1979
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Alabama...........302.0........22.0....
Southern Cal......300.5........20.7....
Oklahoma..........287.5........19.8....
Nebraska..........274.5........20.8....
Notre Dame........238.0........16.4....
Ohio State........205.5........15.4....
Texas.............178.0........14.5....
Penn State........150.0........15.9....
Michigan..........140.5........10.8....
Louisiana State....65.0.........9.0....
Tennessee..........57.0.........8.1....
Georgia............57.0.........6.6....
Florida State......25.0.........4.0....
Florida............11.0.........1.6....
Miami.............-24.0........-3.1....
1980 - 1989
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Miami.............319.0........43.2....
Penn State........229.5........24.3....
Georgia...........201.0........28.6....
Oklahoma..........195.5........13.5....
Nebraska..........191.0........14.4....
Notre Dame........136.0.........9.4....
Michigan..........124.0.........9.5....
Southern Cal......115.5.........7.9....
Florida State.....105.0........16.7....
Alabama............99.5.........7.2....
Ohio State.........93.0.........7.0....
Tennessee..........78.0.........9.0....
Texas..............68.0.........5.5....
Florida............58.0.........8.4....
Louisiana State....51.0.........7.0....
1990 - 1999
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Nebraska..........362.0........27.4....
Florida State.....353.5........56.1....
Florida...........231.0........33.5....
Michigan..........213.5........16.4....
Tennessee.........207.0........23.9....
Miami.............183.0........23.8....
Alabama...........159.5........11.6....
Ohio State........150.5........11.3....
Penn State........137.0........14.5....
Notre Dame.........93.0.........6.4....
Texas..............87.0.........7.1....
Georgia............55.5.........7.9....
Southern Cal.......52.5.........3.6....
Oklahoma...........18.0.........1.2....
Louisiana State.....8.0.........1.1....
2000 - 2009
Team.............Prestige....%.of.Total
Southern Cal......292.0........20.1....
Oklahoma..........291.0........20.1....
Florida...........269.0........39.0....
Ohio State........255.5........19.2....
Texas.............254.5........20.7....
Louisiana State...227.5........31.4....
Miami.............208.0........27.0....
Georgia...........126.0........17.9....
Alabama...........117.5.........8.5....
Florida State......93.0........14.8....
Nebraska...........92.0.........7.0....
Michigan...........89.0.........6.9....
Penn State.........88.5.........9.4....
Tennessee..........68.0.........7.9....
Notre Dame.........38.5.........2.7....