• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Which baseball record will never be broken?

Which baseball record in unbreakable

  • Orel Hershiser's scoreless innings streak

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Bond's impending Homerun record

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    51
Cy's 511 wins is the most untouchable record on this list. A pitcher in a 5-man rotation only gets 32.4 starts. A pitcher in a 4-man rotation, if anyone used a 4-man rotation anymore, would still only get 40.5 starts.

Hypothetical: If a pitcher pitched 25 years, was 100% injury free, never missed a start their entire career, and won at least half their games in a 4-man rotation (20.25 wins a season), they'd still be five wins short of the record.

For reference, Roger Clemens has 348 wins in 23 seasons. Clemens still has to win 163 more games (nearly half of his current career total) to reach 511. He is 45 years old, and won only seven games last season.
 
Upvote 0


Angels History: Frank Tanana Throws 14th Consecutive Complete Game

During that streak, the 22 year old Tanana also had complete games of ten and eleven innings. Three of those outings came with just three days of rest, as he went out and proceeded to face down the competition. And yet, even after throwing all those pitches game after game, Tanana was ready to take the ball whenever his name was called.

Understandably, Tanana’s arm began to hurt. After this outing, he struggled the rest of the way, posting a 3-4 record with a 3.74 ERA over the final two months of the season. He would have only one more season as a top strikeout artist, before his arm issues forced him into becoming a finesse pitcher. Although he still had a fine career, one has to wonder what would have been if he was not overworked to that extent.

Entire article: https://calltothepen.com/2017/07/03...tanana-throws-14th-consecutive-complete-game/

Another record that will never be broken is Cy Young's 749 "complete games".

http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/CG_career.shtml

These days the best pitchers are only averaging about 2 complete games a season.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/CG_active.shtml
 
Upvote 0
It could've been multiple choice....

There are several on the list that won't be broken (and several that won't that weren't on the list either)....

But that said, Cy Young, Ripken and Nolan Ryan's No-hitter and K records will never been broken.

511 wins is crazy (and his 316 career losses won't be touched either)...

2632 games is over 16 years straight. Ripken also holds the consecutive innings streak although it's unofficial at 8243 consecutive innings. That won't be touched either.

7 No-hitters? Ha right. The MLB went something like 3 years here just recently between no-nos (Randy Johnson's perfect game to Anibal Sanchez's No-no last summer). If someone as dominating as the Big Unit didn't have a no-no until he was 39 years old, there isn't anyone that will approach it, much less eclipse it. Same with the strike out record.

The all-time triples record is 36, which won't ever been touched either. The ballparks of today are way too different from when that record was set (1912). IN fact 4 of the top 5 weren't even in the 20th century.

Bonds impending homer record will be broken by A-Rod (assuming he stays healthy) and if not ARod, then Andruw Jones.

So let's see how I did 12 years later...

- Obviously, no one has gotten close to Cy Young. Randy Johnson ended up with 303 wins. Sabathia is probably going to end up within 1 or 2 wins of 255. Maddux - arguably the best modern-era pitcher, ended with 355. The only guy within 100 of Cy Young is Walter Johnson, and he's been dead for going on 80 years. Never going to be approached again much less broken.

- The Ripken streak is ridiculous on many levels, but ultimately, this isn't going to be approached either. In the past 3 years, only 3 players on average in any season have played all 162 games. The era has changed, how players are used have changed and that's that. 3rd all time behind Ripken and Gehrig is a guy named Everett Scott...at 1307 consecutive.

- 7 no-hitters? I don't think MLB has had 7 no-nos in the past 10 years. Anyway, no one is going to pitch long enough to get 7 or be used long enough in games to get there. The last no-hitter was Mike Fiers against the Reds this year.

- Hunter Dozier hit 2 triples in a game in April and has none since. Ball parks aren't configured in a triple-friendly way and now most of the teams are looking more for homers anyway.

- Bonds has the homer record with an asterisk. A-Roid was exposed as a fraud and his roid usage ended up shortening his career due to his hips failing. Ironically, Andruw Jones' last year as a full time player was 2007 when I made this post. He struggled with injuries (and then weight) for the remaining 5 seasons of his career, which sapped his productivity and power, not to mention his ability to play nearly every day. At the end of 2007, he had 368 homers by the age of 30. His previous 5 seasons up to that point had produced 36, 29, 51, 41 and 26 homers for an average of 36-37 per year. If he would have played 10 more years (to the age of 40) it's conceivable he could have challenged for the record if he had lasted in the league. He didn't. Now it's guys like Mike Trout (270 homers and counting through age 27) and maybe Bryce Harper (207 and still in his age 26 year) who have theoretical shots, but I don't think Harper is a good enough hitter to get there and I think Trout will slow down simply because the every day center fielder role will wear on him as he gets older.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Cy Young, Ripken and Nolan Ryan's No-hitter and K records will never been broken.

511 wins is crazy (and his 316 career losses won't be touched either)...

2632 games is over 16 years straight. Ripken also holds the consecutive innings streak although it's unofficial at 8243 consecutive innings. That won't be touched either.

7 No-hitters? Ha right.

The all-time triples record is 36, which won't ever been touched either.
Johhny Vander Meer of the Reds in '38....back to back no hitters.

No one can pitch the 3 consecutive no hitters it would take to break that one. I put it with Cy Young's win record as the only two completely impossibles.
What about Pete Rose's hit record?
Henderson's career steals record is another tough one...he's like 30% above 2nd place. You'd have to average 70 steals for 20 years to take him. Hard to fathom at this point.
What about Ty Cobb's career batting average of .366?
You guys aren't putting enough effort into this.

The one baseball record that will never, ever be broken is Pop Snyder's record of 763 passed balls. Snyder played 930 games over 18 years (1873 to 1891), which means that he averaged 42.4 passed balls per season, and one passed ball every 1.2 games.

By way of comparison, the active leaders in passed balls are Yadier Molina (84 in 16 seasons, 5.25 per season) and Russell Martin (84 in 14 seasons, 6 per season).

Congrats to Pop Snyder for your enduring achievement - you will always be a legend!
 
Upvote 0
You guys aren't putting enough effort into this.

The one baseball record that will never, ever be broken is Pop Snyder's record of 763 passed balls. Snyder played 930 games over 18 years (1873 to 1891), which means that he averaged 42.4 passed balls per season, and one passed ball every 1.2 games.

By way of comparison, the active leaders in passed balls are Yadier Molina (84 in 16 seasons, 5.25 per season) and Russell Martin (84 in 14 seasons, 6 per season).

Congrats to Pop Snyder for your enduring achievement - you will always be a legend!

The Reds have them a new catcher. Let's not be too hasty on this record.
 
Upvote 0
You guys aren't putting enough effort into this.

The one baseball record that will never, ever be broken is Pop Snyder's record of 763 passed balls. Snyder played 930 games over 18 years (1873 to 1891), which means that he averaged 42.4 passed balls per season, and one passed ball every 1.2 games.

By way of comparison, the active leaders in passed balls are Yadier Molina (84 in 16 seasons, 5.25 per season) and Russell Martin (84 in 14 seasons, 6 per season).

Congrats to Pop Snyder for your enduring achievement - you will always be a legend!

The problem is only @BB73 was around to see him play...
 
Upvote 0
MLB roundtable: What's the most unbreakable record in baseball history?

Matt Snyder: I think there are a pretty large number of unbreakable records.

  • Cal Ripken played in 2,632 consecutive games. That's more than 16 seasons without missing a game. That's never going to happen again.
  • Cy Young's 511 career wins is ridiculously safe.
  • The active leader in triples is Dexter Fowler with 82. The career record is 309 (Sam Crawford). It's hard to see anyone getting to that. The single-season record of 36 (Chief Wilson, 1912) is probably not getting close to being touched ever again.
  • I don't think we're very likely to ever see Barry Bonds' season mark of 73 homers fall and his 762 career home runs are probably safe as well.
  • The single-season batting average record is .440 (Hugh Duffy, 1894). Ty Cobb's career mark of .366 seems untouchable as well.
  • A pitcher would have to average more than 285 strikeouts per season for 20 years to get to Nolan Ryan's 5,714.
But I think it's the most unbreakable is complete games, as R.J. mentioned. The 75 in a single season simply aren't possible. Cy Young's 749 in his career are completely out of the realm of possibility, too. Similarly, we could throw in innings pitched. Will White's 680 in 1879 and Cy Young's career mark is 7,356.

Entire article: https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/...-most-unbreakable-record-in-baseball-history/
 
Upvote 0
Johhny Vander Meer of the Reds in '38....back to back no hitters.

No one can pitch the 3 consecutive no hitters it would take to break that one. I put it with Cy Young's win record as the only two completely impossibles.

I stand with this one as the second safest record behind Cy Young's win record.

3 consecutive No Hitters is impossible

Some cock slap would bunt for a hit or some bigger cock slap of a manager would pull you because of a pitch count.

It will never happen again.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top