Since we are getting so many knowledgeable Tigers on here I would like to get their reaction to my initial impressions of advantages and disadvantages -
Talent - advantage LSU.
We don't have a Dorsey (nobody does) and he is a difference maker. Our OL is very, very good. But I don't know if it is strong enough for your DL - which, of course, is more than just Dorsey. Beyond the DL I would make some arguments at a lot of other positions on D, but none that would compensate for what Dorsey can do if he is healthy.
I love Boeckman, but he does not have the experience - and we have no proven commodities behind him - none. If he gets knocked for a loop we will be as anxious as the LSU fans to see who takes the field. You guys are obviously more set at that position. But you are not working against a weak D - and if you are judging based on last year's NC game that is a mistake. You have a ton of weapons. Your combination of speed and power out of the backfield is scary. You will score. But perhaps not as easily as you think.
I don't see a single offensive player on LSU that matches Beanie Wells. (And yes, I know who Hester is.) If we can scheme to open holes for him we can move the ball. Move it enough? I don't know. Which takes us to ....
Coaching - advantage OSU.
Miles does not impress me either with his game prep or his game time decisions. Peilini was good. But it looks like "was" is the operative word relative to LSU.
The football world has gotten more mileage out of last year's NC game than any game I can recall. It has been painful. Meyer beat us. His team was more ready, his game plan was better and we did not adjust. I can't mount a serious argument that Florida was not the better team. But they were not 27 points the better team.
Miles is not Meyer.
What happened last year happens. Not often, but it happens. (There is no better example than Florida-FSU in 1996-97 for what those kinds of scores mean.) Tressel and staff are better than what anyone saw last year.
If there is a way to counter for Dorsey Tressel will find it. If OSU is going to win this game I have to be right about Tressel and he has to be at his best.
Home Field - advantage LSU.
Obviously. And Buckeye fans should not underestimate it.
Senior Leadership - advantage LSU.
I count something like 11 seniors starting for LSU. OSU has TWO senior players who came in as Frosh on scholarship on the entire roster (our other seniors are one JUCO and some former walk ons).
That is big and I wouldn't underestimate that either.
Intangibles - advantage OSU.
Last year we were reading our press clippings more than working out. Why bother - it was going to be a cake walk. Florida read those same clippings and reacted differently.
I don't care who has the #1 ranking. This year LSU gets to read about how good they are. Hell, they don't even need to read. Just watch the game film from last year. Northern football is no match for southern speed.
It's a cake walk man. Just enjoy the ride and take home the trophy. That is all you have to do. Miles will tell you different. You will can try to tell yourselves different. But deep down you know you just have to show up.
As for OSU, there is absolutely nothing this team will not leave on the field this year.
Oh, and by the way - your coach IS going to Michigan.