• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!
While I despise the phrase, I never made fun of scUM for them using "*ichigan Man". I know we have more than a handful here who have done so, and that's their business.

And the reason I never made fun of that mentality, is because that is the same thing being expressed in these posts over the last couple days.

Is it possible to fully embrace a culture, the seemingly spiritual meaning behind it, if you weren't raised and immersed in it? Make no mistake, football in the midwest is as ingrained as our religion. It's almost a culture onto itself.

This is something I've wrestled with every since Urban began his recruiting focus nationally, as much as he did locally.

Can kids outside of the midwest ever be washed in the water? Yes, it's cult like in the zealotry. But there are some things you just accept and love it as is regardless of how it seems from the outside.

The Game is the epitome of tOSU football culture that spans, because of the players, coaches and fans, the world over. You will eventually see it, even if you aren't one of us.
But can you ever convert yourself? I believe it's possible, because we've all seen kids come in from out of state and throw themselves at such a baptism. Hell, when I hear Greg McCellroy, an Alabama player and graduate(spell check) use the phrase "That team up north", during a CBS broadcast, I know how special tOSU and the State of Ohio are in general. It's our Mecca for football, and I'll call anyone an idiot who disagrees.

Circling back around to my greater point - I believe individuals can be immersed and become of this Ohio Football culture. But if I believe that, it would also mean I believe there are those who cannot or will not. I'm sure for their own various reasons. But this also brings in the questions that have loomed large in my mind - when the rich become richer, as things have especially shown with NIL, more and more kids are making decisions based in a foundation of business before it's based on passion.

Football isn't exclusive to this either. I see it all over, this mentality shift that I cannot stand. And at the root of it is money, plain and simple.

This isn't to completely demonize NIL, I have well established thoughts on this board that range from "long overdue" to "when is it TOO much?".

C.J. has been a fine QB, and there have been times it has been a real treat watching him play. But his play individually, and the cumulative effect on those around him, has been almost the antithesis to what we've see built here nearly the last 25 years. So there is something to be said for desire and leadership, as much as those terms can be highly overused and cliche'. So I question is immersion and understanding or accepting of the significance of the last Saturday in November when I hear "this game doesn't define us".

Fair or unfair, C.J., yes it does. To quote Chris Speilman, "you are judged at Ohio State by what you do against *ichigan". That is the standard and weight you must bear if you choose to put on that uniform, and nothing less is acceptable.

We have Tress to thank for reviving this culture and saving it from Cooper. But as of right now, scUM has become the early days of what we saw in those formative 2000s years. Matching talent and creativity is one thing, but matching preparation, intensity and most of all - passion from the result of emotional investment, is another animal entirely.

I have some questions about that last one...
 
Upvote 0
I'm big on analogies as you all know...

We were Batman vs Bane when Batman got his ass kicked. Saw his target, got infuriated, started swinging for the knock out. Then got counter punched and it was over.

We have got to get it in our head that our games vs these guys will be 4 quarters. That it's going to suck physically and that we've got to keep swinging which means pacing yourself.
What about Ace and Gary?
 
Upvote 0
While I despise the phrase, I never made fun of scUM for them using "*ichigan Man". I know we have more than a handful here who have done so, and that's their business.

And the reason I never made fun of that mentality, is because that is the same thing being expressed in these posts over the last couple days.

Is it possible to fully embrace a culture, the seemingly spiritual meaning behind it, if you weren't raised and immersed in it? Make no mistake, football in the midwest is as ingrained as our religion. It's almost a culture onto itself.

This is something I've wrestled with every since Urban began his recruiting focus nationally, as much as he did locally.

Can kids outside of the midwest ever be washed in the water? Yes, it's cult like in the zealotry. But there are some things you just accept and love it as is regardless of how it seems from the outside.

The Game is the epitome of tOSU football culture that spans, because of the players, coaches and fans, the world over. You will eventually see it, even if you aren't one of us.
But can you ever convert yourself? I believe it's possible, because we've all seen kids come in from out of state and throw themselves at such a baptism. Hell, when I hear Greg McCellroy, an Alabama player and graduate(spell check) use the phrase "That team up north", during a CBS broadcast, I know how special tOSU and the State of Ohio are in general. It's our Mecca for football, and I'll call anyone an idiot who disagrees.

Circling back around to my greater point - I believe individuals can be immersed and become of this Ohio Football culture. But if I believe that, it would also mean I believe there are those who cannot or will not. I'm sure for their own various reasons. But this also brings in the questions that have loomed large in my mind - when the rich become richer, as things have especially shown with NIL, more and more kids are making decisions based in a foundation of business before it's based on passion.

Football isn't exclusive to this either. I see it all over, this mentality shift that I cannot stand. And at the root of it is money, plain and simple.

This isn't to completely demonize NIL, I have well established thoughts on this board that range from "long overdue" to "when is it TOO much?".

C.J. has been a fine QB, and there have been times it has been a real treat watching him play. But his play individually, and the cumulative effect on those around him, has been almost the antithesis to what we've see built here nearly the last 25 years. So there is something to be said for desire and leadership, as much as those terms can be highly overused and cliche'. So I question is immersion and understanding or accepting of the significance of the last Saturday in November when I hear "this game doesn't define us".

Fair or unfair, C.J., yes it does. To quote Chris Speilman, "you are judged at Ohio State by what you do against *ichigan". That is the standard and weight you must bear if you choose to put on that uniform, and nothing less is acceptable.

We have Tress to thank for reviving this culture and saving it from Cooper. But as of right now, scUM has become the early days of what we saw in those formative 2000s years. Matching talent and creativity is one thing, but matching preparation, intensity and most of all - passion from the result of emotional investment, is another animal entirely.

I have some questions about that last one...
Extremely fair and well-stated!
 
Upvote 0
Ambiguously gay duo?
Ah damn alright an SNL reference lol...

Seriously though that really was our fight with Michigan. There was a point Batman started swinging back as a last gasp but in control Bane allowed Batman to swing himself out then ended it. All the while establishing a few times here and there that he wasn't going anywhere.

Next time we have to come in under control, understand whats happening and wear them down.
 
Upvote 0
Anybody else think our guys weren't conditioned for a 4qr game. With all the blowouts we had early in the season some on here mentioned it might be a problem when you face good teams. They sure looked gassed in that 4th quarter if you ask me.

This would also be a coaching issue.
 
Upvote 0
i still say player have no pride when they watch ttun player planting flags do nothing about reverse it if ohio st players did that at there stadium they'd be defending there turf bc they have pride

I only saw one Buckeye player on the twitter video close to the flag planting. I'm not sure if the other 99% of players were on the sidelines. But if there were still Buckeye players still out on the field at the time of the flag planting, then that is hugely disappointing.
 
Upvote 0
I will say I couldn't be happier with our AD and President pairing, so I trust we are in good hands.

That said, I am concerned where there is smoke there is fire....if they don't believe Day is the guy, waiting a year or two can have disastrous results on a program. Losing 3 or 4 times in a row to them would be monumentally negative.

I know we think we are different or unique, but many schools have waited too long to make a change and thought they would recover instantly too....like Texas with Mack, Miami with Coker, Tennessee with Fulmer, etc. Oklahoma might find themselves in the same boat now with Venables.
 
Upvote 0
I will say I couldn't be happier with our AD and President pairing, so I trust we are in good hands.

That said, I am concerned where there is smoke there is fire....if they don't believe Day is the guy, waiting a year or two can have disastrous results on a program. Losing 3 or 4 times in a row to them would be monumentally negative.

I know we think we are different or unique, but many schools have waited too long to make a change and thought they would recover instantly too....like Texas with Mack, Miami with Coker, Tennessee with Fulmer, etc. Oklahoma might find themselves in the same boat now with Venables.
We've hit home runs basically 4 straight times hiring head coaches... we will hit another whenever that time comes.

Fickle would NOT turn this job down. So we go into our next coaching search knowing that at a minimum.
 
Upvote 0
There has been some talk of the transfer portal in another thread and places we may need new blood. Day has always cautioned that any players brought in would have to be a cultural fit for the program. This has also come up in threads about recruits and their fit. We hear of the brotherhood amongst the players. I’m wondering what’s Day’s definition of the culture is? I’m wondering where the brotherhood fits into the Game?

I didn’t see anyone on the team or the staff getting anyone fired up or in anyones face about anything. The closest maybe was Days reaction to the Gee Scott head butt.
 
Upvote 0
C.J. has been a fine QB, and there have been times it has been a real treat watching him play. But his play individually, and the cumulative effect on those around him, has been almost the antithesis to what we've see built here nearly the last 25 years. So there is something to be said for desire and leadership, as much as those terms can be highly overused and cliche'. So I question is immersion and understanding or accepting of the significance of the last Saturday in November when I hear "this game doesn't define us".

Fair or unfair, C.J., yes it does. To quote Chris Speilman, "you are judged at Ohio State by what you do against *ichigan". That is the standard and weight you must bear if you choose to put on that uniform, and nothing less is acceptable.

CJ is the first OSU QB to lose back-to-back versus TTUN in over 20 years. It's not entirely his fault - that's not my point - but for him to say what he did after the second loss tells me the importance of The Game is lost on him. How is that possible? Who is not making that clear to him? More importantly, how many other players agree with him?

The guys who played for Tressel would have never said that, nor would Urban's guys. They understood the importance. Not just the game itself, but how winning or losing that game impacts every other goal you had for the season.
 
Upvote 0
"one loss doesn't define us" is a problem in and of itself.

It's back to back losses in the exact same way to your biggest rival. It's refusing to run when you have giant lanes to run in for a first down. It's making a bad throw because you retreat in the pocket instead of being willing to take a hit to deliver a good ball. It's your coach struggling to consistently move the ball against average defenses for several weeks and then coming out and doing the the exact same thing against the best defense you're going to play all year.

The idea that the defining is based on one loss is the exact lack of self-awareness that causes situations like this.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top