• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

tOSU at Notre Dame, Sat. 9/23, 7:30pm EST, NBC

Agree with most of this. Biggest complaint was the 2 stops on 3rd and 4th and short on the 2 occasions in the red zone. Run #3 into the middle of the line on third and then turn it over on 4th with an incomplete pass. Would have been better served by handing it to#19 twice down there I think. And running a jet sweep on 4th and less than 1 is James Franklin level dumb. Still don't understand Day's play calling in crunch time in a lot of instances. Last drive was a masterpiece of execution though.

With the push being legal, I don't know why you do anything else.
Instead of lead blocking with the "FB" (Chip), either give it to FB and TB pushes... or QB sneak and FB pushes.
He made this way too complicated.
 
Upvote 0
With the push being legal, I don't know why you do anything else.
Instead of lead blocking with the "FB" (Chip), either give it to FB and TB pushes... or QB sneak and FB pushes.
He made this way too complicated.

That type of stuff is where the team’s toughness gets questioned by the way
 
Upvote 0
The biggest thing I'm stoked about is that we mostly only rushed the front 4 and got enough pressure (with good coverage) to force bad throws against a really good QB
I can't recall Hartman making a bad throw or making a bad decision. Not spectacular but cool and calm. In fact, I was puzzled why we would use zone against a QB that has played 8 years
 
Upvote 0
A personal request to folks posting during game threads.

I understand the frustration with the lack of pass rush. I understand the frustration about not calling a QB sneak when it’s a yard or less. I understand the refs and the announcers often blatantly demonstrate ineptitude.

I‘m OK bitching about the refs, hell I do that often enough. I’m fine with bitching about the announcers, I do that, too.

But during the games, let’s try to limit how we express frustration at Buckeye players and coaches. It’s one thing to say player X has to: “take better angles”, or “turn his head around when the ball’s in the air”, or “should’ve followed that block”. And it’s fine to say “they need to crank up the pass rush” or “too much zone is being played and it’s not working”, or “don’t always run on second and long”, or “run a damn QB sneak!”. This board has a tradition of not bashing Buckeyes, and I believe it’s time we strive to be more careful about how we’re being critical during games.

And let’s just avoid talking about firing coaches during the games. After the game is over, fine, have that discussion. But while the game was still going, the talk about firing coaches during the heat of the battle last night was BS. I’m not going to quote any posts or point anybody out, it was several people including some long-time posters.

I’m not saying we need to be rah-rah, or rainbows and unicorns all the time, and I’m not saying we can’t state how we think things should be done differently on the field. But it seems that things have gotten out of hand, and we should think twice about how our criticisms are expressed during game threads.

Thanks for your consideration. I know it’s not easy to post calmly when you’re throwing your remote at the screen.
 
Upvote 0

They think the refs were bad......for us.
 
Upvote 0
Post-Game Comments

• With 4:12 left in the game, I was preparing to write the lazy postmortem. You know, something like: "Play calling .... lack of adjustments .... soft team .... short yardage red zone Clemson 2019 .... John Cooper .... season over wait until next year." While we can, and some of us undoubtedly will, discuss our team's and our coach's shortcomings over the upcoming days and weeks, today all of that negative talk (or constructive criticism) has to be put on hold because It happened. After failing to convert a 3rd-and-1 and a 4th-and-1 from Notre Dame's 11-yard line down 14-10, the Buckeye defense somehow forced a quick punt (assist to the ND coaching staff), and the Buckeye offense went 65 yards in the final 1:26 of the game (and they literally needed every last second) to score the game-winning touchdown and snatch victory from the jaws of defeat.

• The final drive took a staggering 15 plays to complete, meaning that Ohio State ran one play every 5.7 seconds. Kyle McCord will deservedly get much credit for leading his team down the field in clutch time, but if you look just at the raw numbers you won't be all that impressed: 5 completions in 14 attempts (one spike) with an intentional grounding penalty thrown into the mix. Where McCord earned his NIL money was on the plays where the Buckeyes needed him the most, converting first downs on 3rd-and-10, 3rd-and-19, and 4th-and-7 to keep the improbable drive alive.

• Some of our posters claimed that McCord entered The Pantheon after that game-winning drive, joining the likes of Dwayne Haskins, Justin Fields, and CJ Stroud as Buckeye legends. Another poster dubbed him Kyle McKrenzel. Right now, I'm inclined to the hold the latter position – lots of awkwardness and ugliness with moments of sublime beauty delivered right on time. Haskins, Fields, and Stroud were all Heisman finalists and first round draft choices and prototype quarterbacks, but Krenzel won a national championship.

• Much has already been said about Ohio State's final play, the Chip Trayanum 1-yard touchdown run to win the game. Most of that talk has been along the lines of Ryan Day being a lunatic for calling a run with just 3 seconds left on the clock. But it was the right call. Ohio State needed one yard and Ryan Day dialed up the play mostly likely to gain him that one yard. Sure, if that run failed then it was game over, but an incomplete pass might have used up those final 3 seconds anyway. And as mentioned above, Kyle McCord hadn't exactly been surgically shredding Notre Dame's defense during the previous 14 plays, he didn't really have the proverbial hot hand. Maybe Day felt that McCord wasn't quite ready for that moment of crowning glory so he took the ball out of his hands and the pressure off of his back. Maybe Day went into Kevin Stefanski smartest guy in the room mode and called a play against type. Or maybe Day (or McCord) checked into a running play after noticing that Notre Dame had only 10 men on the field and that the missing man was the right defensive end. In any event, it was the right play call because the play worked and the Buckeyes won the game.

• People have already asked whether last night's game was an instant classic. I have two answers: Yes, and maybe. Yes, because it was a matchup of top-10 teams from historic programs that had an epic finish. Maybe, because this game might not seem so special if Ohio State fails to finish the season strongly – if the Buckeyes end up 9-4 with a middling bowl game, then this becomes just another really nice win with a few memorable highlights.

• Now that the final comeback drive has entered Buckeye lore, what do we call it? The Drive is too simple and obvious, and that term has already been appropriated by Cleveland Browns fans. Something with "Miracle" in the name would make sense, especially because it happened in view of Touchdown Jesus, but that route is a bit to clichéd for my tastes. I'm sure that there are names floating around cyberspace as I type – let me know if your see or hear any good ones.

• The rushing numbers for both teams were fairly similar: Ohio State had 27 carries for 126 yards (4.7 average) and 2 touchdowns, while Notre Dame had 38 carries for 177 yards (4.7 average) and 1 touchdown. The difference was in how each team gained its yardage – Ohio State had a 61-yard touchdown run from TreVeyon Henderson (that's why he's special, folks) and not much else; Notre Dame was able to consistently pound the ball behind their outstanding offensive line.

• Like Kyle McCord, JT Tuimoloau came up big when it mattered the most. On Notre Dame's final drive, he had a 5-yard TFL and a batted pass on consecutive plays to force the Irish into 3rd-and-15 and an eventual punt.

• Ryan Day's Ric Flair postgame interview was equal parts inspiring and hilarious – maybe next time he'll be sporting dark shades and flashing a solid gold Rolex. People will undoubtedly bash Day for calling out Lou Holtz, but in this Coach Prime Era of college football playing the disrespect card and delivering it with vigor and style will get you noticed. Nice guys finish last, and quiet guys don't make SportsCenter. And besides, college football is entertainment, so who can complain when a head coach is entertaining?

* My father was born in December of 1936. He has never seen Notre Dame beat Ohio State in football. May he live another 100 years.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Most of that talk has been along the lines of Ryan Day being a lunatic for calling a run with just 7 seconds left on the clock. But it was the right call. Ohio State needed one yard and Ryan Day dialed up the play mostly likely to gain him that one yard. Sure, if that run failed then it was game over, but an incomplete pass might have used up those final 7 seconds anyway.
There was an incomplete pass called with 7 seconds left. The final run came at three seconds, when only 1 play was possible, run or pass.
 
Upvote 0
Post-Game Comments

• With 4:12 left in the game, I was preparing to write the lazy postmortem. You know, something like: "Play calling .... lack of adjustments .... soft team .... short yardage red zone Clemson 2019 .... John Cooper .... season over wait until next year." While we can, and some of us undoubtedly will, discuss our team's and our coach's shortcomings over the upcoming days and weeks, today all of that negative talk (or constructive criticism) has to be put on hold because It happened. After failing to convert a 3rd-and-1 and a 4th-and-1 from Notre Dame's 11-yard line down 14-10, the Buckeye defense somehow forced a quick punt (assist to the ND coaching staff), and the Buckeye offense went 65 yards in the final 1:26 of the game (and they literally needed every last second) to score the game-winning touchdown and snatch victory from the jaws of defeat.

• The final drive took a staggering 15 plays to complete, meaning that Ohio State ran one play every 5.7 seconds. Kyle McCord will deservedly get much credit for leading his team down the field in clutch time, but if you look just at the raw numbers you won't be all that impressed: 5 completions in 14 attempts (one spike) with an intentional grounding penalty thrown into the mix. Where McCord earned his NIL money was on the plays where the Buckeyes needed him the most, converting first downs on 3rd-and-10, 3rd-and-19, and 4th-and-7 to keep the improbable drive alive.

• Some of our posters claimed that McCord entered The Pantheon after that game-winning drive, joining the likes of Dwayne Haskins, Justin Fields, and CJ Stroud as Buckeye legends. Another poster dubbed him Kyle McKrenzel. Right now, I'm inclined to the hold the latter position – lots of awkwardness and ugliness with moments of sublime beauty delivered right on time. Haskins, Fields, and Stroud were all Heisman finalists and first round draft choices and prototype quarterbacks, but Krenzel won a national championship.

• Much has already been said about Ohio State's final play, the Chip Trayanum 1-yard touchdown run to win the game. Most of that talk has been along the lines of Ryan Day being a lunatic for calling a run with just 7 seconds left on the clock. But it was the right call. Ohio State needed one yard and Ryan Day dialed up the play mostly likely to gain him that one yard. Sure, if that run failed then it was game over, but an incomplete pass might have used up those final 7 seconds anyway. And as mentioned above, Kyle McCord hadn't exactly been surgically shredding Notre Dame's defense during the previous 14 plays, he didn't really have the proverbial hot hand. Maybe Day felt that McCord wasn't quite ready for that moment of crowning glory so he took the ball out of his hands and the pressure off of his back. Maybe Day went into Kevin Stefanski smartest guy in the room mode and called a play against type. Or maybe Day (or McCord) checked into a running play after noticing that Notre Dame had only 10 men on the field and that the missing man was the right defensive end. In any event, it was the right play call because the play worked and the Buckeyes won the game.

• People have already asked whether last night's game was an instant classic. I have two answers: Yes, and maybe. Yes, because it was a matchup of top-10 teams from historic programs that had an epic finish. Maybe, because this game might not seem so special if Ohio State fails to finish the season strongly – if the Buckeyes end up 9-4 with a middling bowl game, then this becomes just another really nice win with a few memorable highlights.

• Now that the final comeback drive has entered Buckeye lore, what do we call it? The Drive is too simple and obvious, and that term has already been appropriated by Cleveland Browns fans. Something with "Miracle" in the name would make sense, especially because it happened in view of Touchdown Jesus, but that route is a bit to clichéd for my tastes. I'm sure that there are names floating around cyberspace as I type – let me know if your see or hear any good ones.

• The rushing numbers for both teams were fairly similar: Ohio State had 27 carries for 126 yards (4.7 average) and 2 touchdowns, while Notre Dame had 38 carries for 177 yards (4.7 average) and 1 touchdown. The difference was in how each team gained its yardage – Ohio State had a 61-yard touchdown run from TreVeyon Henderson (that's why he's special, folks) and not much else; Notre Dame was able to consistently pound the ball behind their outstanding offensive line.

• Like Kyle McCord, JT Tuimoloau came up big when it mattered the most. On Notre Dame's final drive, he had a 5-yard TFL and a batted pass on consecutive plays to force the Irish into 3rd-and-15 and an eventual punt.

• Ryan Day's Ric Flair postgame interview was equal parts inspiring and hilarious – maybe next time he'll be sporting dark shades and flashing a solid gold Rolex. People will undoubtedly bash Day for calling out Lou Holtz, but in this Coach Prime Era of college football playing the disrespect card and delivering it with vigor and style will get you noticed. Nice guys finish last, and quiet guys don't make SportsCenter. And besides, college football is entertainment, so who can complain when a head coach is entertaining?

* My father was born in December of 1936. He has never seen Notre Dame beat Ohio State in football. May he live another 100 years.

The Ten pin
 
Upvote 0
Ryan Day is the ONLY coach

A win is a win is s win. Fuck off.
Ok since my previous explanation for what I saw was ignored, I FIXED it just for you. Again, I am Day fan. Fan of Day. Night can suck it.

THE WAY SOME PEOPLE REACT "Feeds into my fire DAY issue. Who will just idk step in on a moment's notice? OR is this season just a lost cause" BECAUSE IF WE JUST UP AND FIRE HIM, WHO IS GONNA TAKE OVER AND BE BETTER? DO THESE PEOPLE THINK THAT THE SEASON IS A LOST CAUSE BECAUSE DAY IS STILL THE COACH?
 
Upvote 0
LJB, at the 4:13 clock, went to frig to refill my red. Wife said there was still time, but I wasn't so sure, given the fits and starts that was our O last night. She was correct, fortunately. When the cameras panned on tOSU sideline, always saw Day in the middle of the O players, maybe Hartline on the fringes, sometimes not. Wondered how Brian was gonna become a true OC, when it's clear he's not calling the plays. Soooo, seems he has the title in name only. Seems unclear (to me at least), how Day is going to hand the reins over to BH, as we we enter B10 part of the schedule. Can someone clear the fog away for me? Go Bucks! PS, for the idiots that are calling for Day's scalp (and job), who do you possibly believe tOSU could get that is a step up from Day?
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top