• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

The Buckeyes' Most Agonizing Loss

What is the Buckeyes' most agonizing loss?

  • 11-22-69: Michigan 24, Ohio State 12 (To ruin a perfect season and possible National Championship)

    Votes: 17 5.7%
  • 01-01-71: Stanford 27, Ohio State 17 (This Rose Bowl loss cost the Bucks a National Championship)

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 11-24-73: Michigan 10, Ohio State 10 (This "loss" cost the Bucks a National Championship)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 11-09-74: Michigan State 16, Ohio State 13 (Big 10 Commissioner Wayne Duke gives the game to the Spa

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 01-01-76: UCLA 23, Ohio State 10 (Another Rose Bowl loss which cost the Bucks a National Championshi

    Votes: 9 3.0%
  • 12-29-78: Clemson 17, Ohio State 15 (Woody's Waterloo in the Gator Bowl)

    Votes: 2 0.7%
  • 01-01-80: Southern Cal 17, Ohio State 16 (Yet another Rose Bowl loss which cost the Bucks a National

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 12-27-90: Air Force 23, Ohio State 11 (A fiasco in the Liberty Bowl)

    Votes: 2 0.7%
  • 11-20-93: Michigan 28, Ohio State 0 (The undefeated Bucks lay an egg in the Big House)

    Votes: 7 2.4%
  • 10-29-94: Penn State 63, Ohio State 14 (The Bucks get annihilated in Happy Valley)

    Votes: 3 1.0%
  • 11-25-95: Michigan 31, Ohio State 23 (Tim Biakabutuka's 313 yards rushing ruins the Bucks' perfect s

    Votes: 16 5.4%
  • 11-23-96: Michigan 13, Ohio State 9 (Another perfect season "slips" away....)

    Votes: 36 12.1%
  • 11-22-97: Michigan 20, Ohio State 14 (Michigan's victory caps a perfect regular season for the Wolve

    Votes: 3 1.0%
  • 11-07-98: Michigan State 28, Ohio State 24 (A 28-point underdog costs the Buckeyes a perfect season)

    Votes: 176 59.3%
  • 01-01-01: South Carolina 24, Ohio State 7 (A bad start to the new millenium, and Cooper's last stand

    Votes: 1 0.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 7 2.4%

  • Total voters
    297
Oh my !!!!

I was at the 95 Michigan game in Ann Arbor great road trip ruined by a horrible defeat. I went with a buddy of mine. We had big plans to cross the border and celebrate after the game, instead we just got in the car and made the sad trip home and got plowed all night. I was in shock!!! I scalped a ticket for 80.00. I have to admit the Michigan fans treated us prettty well until the game ended!!! When the game ended the walk out to the car was little ugly but I had expected worse. I can also say the Michigan fans had no confidence before the game kept asking us about our players and saying things like we just hope we can keep it close. They then started to really go nuts around the 3rd quater and I kept saying there is time but really was no time. OSU did make a late rally but too little too late.

I also went to the Michigan State game in 1998. I have never heard the stadium so quiet. I went to this game with my Dad and was the last one we have gone to together. I had a bad feeling about this game from the kickoff even after we had gained the lead. We kept having freaky bad luck the whole
game just everything that could go wrong did. I remember the student in front of me burned his student ticket which still had the Michigan ticket on it!!! I tried to stop him but he was so distraught. I do remember this kid who was visiting Columbus from the University of Alabama. I think he was a frat brother
of a OSU frat kinda like a exchange thing if I remember correct. He was really trying to get the crowd fired up in the 4th...He kept saying come on you guys this is your team get off your A$$!!! It was embarrassing how the crowd was so quiet until Joe almost brought us back!!!!! then it got loud again. I taped the game but have not brought myself to watch it all the way through. I can't believe I have been to 2 of the worst OSU losses. The Michigan State game was like a funeral. I also remember sitting there watching the MSU players celebrating on our field taunting our fans. I have hated Plaxico ever since!!!!! He got me again this year in my Fantasy Football championship. I remember walking to the car and students had already started pulling a sofa off a porch on one of the side streets. My Dad kept saying it was going to get ugly..BAD MEMORIES but yet I have some really great moments as well. Go Bucks!!!!!
 
Upvote 0
I just noticed this thread and I agree with the outcome.

The 1998 Bucks were the best fucking team in the country - spare me undefeated Tee Martin and Tennessee. The second half John Cooper play-not-to-lose brain fart and total team collapse against MSU really hurt, especially when the pollsters did their usual reward the team who lost in September schtick, and sent an undermanned Seminoles squad to play UT while we stomped the shit out of Texas A&M in New Orleans.

Not only were the Bucks better than FSU, I would've bet my paycheck on 'em versus the "national champions" from Tennessee. The only saving grace was I got to attend the Penn State and Michigan ass-kickings, live and in person, in the Shoe.
 
Upvote 0
Misanthrope said:
I just noticed this thread and I agree with the outcome.

The 1998 Bucks were the best fucking team in the country - spare me undefeated Tee Martin and Tennessee. The second half John Cooper play-not-to-lose brain fart and total team collapse against MSU really hurt, especially when the pollsters did their usual reward the team who lost in September schtick, and sent an undermanned Seminoles squad to play UT while we stomped the shit out of Texas A&M in New Orleans.

Not only were the Bucks better than FSU, I would've bet my paycheck on 'em versus the "national champions" from Tennessee. The only saving grace was I got to attend the Penn State and Michigan ass-kickings, live and in person, in the Shoe.
We all know in 1998 OSU had the best team. Yet I think the main problem was turnovers, not the play calling. I can still see those last two passes falling incomplete near the goal line (I think that's how it ended, I drank alot in those days). That did suck. I pointed to that year ever since their killer recruiting class. Although the Shawn Springs slip really blew also. Man, that was a sunny November day and we drank from 9PM the night before right up until game time. No sleep! Kegs and Eggs! Partying until the Bucks beat Michigan!. Talk about downer. Completely hung over on top of a horrible loss.
 
Upvote 0
scott91575 said:
Although the Shawn Springs slip really blew also.
I've never once thought the defense (or the Tai Streets touchdown) had anything to do with that loss. When you were mowing down people with that line like we were that year and you post 3 field goals in The Game (sound familiar Michigan fans?), you deserve to lose. I voted for 1996.

Only one Earle Bruce-coached game on the list. Guess there's something to say about modest expectations.
 
Upvote 0
11-20-93: Michigan 28, Ohio State 0 (The undefeated Bucks lay an egg in the Big House)
11-25-95: Michigan 31, Ohio State 23 (Tim Biakabutuka's 313 yards rushing ruins the Bucks' perfect season)11-23-96: Michigan 13, Ohio State 9 (Another perfect season "slips" away....)
11-22-97: Michigan 20, Ohio State 14 (Michigan's victory caps a perfect regular season for the Wolverines)
11-07-98: Michigan State 28, Ohio State 24 (A 28-point underdog costs the Buckeyes a perfect season)

wow thats hard to pick but IMO it's in Bold
 
Upvote 0
Sorry fellas....

I was at the 1996 game in Cols. I always thought I jinxed us. My first game. Then I went to the Fiesta Bowl, the '03 SDSU game, that Will Allen interception, was right in front of me. Then the 05' Game. I was right there for all the action. I realized that '96 game wasn't my fault. Now I'm good luck.
 
Upvote 0
Any and all of them hurt....I still wonder what coulda and woulda been... Another loss I didn't see in the poll was the game against Oklahoma in Ohio Stadium where we lost on a last second field goal. I don't remember the year perhaps 1977? Anybody know?
 
Upvote 0
Personally for me, it was last year's loss to Northwestern. Never has a game woke me up all night with nightmares.

Maybe it was due to my emotional state before the game having buried my grandmother earlier in the day and arguing with my brother over proper dress for a funeral. He was on the road back to Florida during the night and that was weighing on my mind too.

Absolutely horrible night. Second worst of my life.
 
Upvote 0
I definately feel that the most agonizing loss had to be the 1998 Michigan State game. We were 28 point favorites. We win that game, we don't have to worry about the pollsters taking FSU ahead of us (even though we were better). Oh so many mistakes cost us a national title that year. Ughhh the Cooper era hurt.
 
Upvote 0
CharlotteBuckeye62 said:
Having graduated from tOSU in 1962, I remember and suffered through them all but I voted for the loss to the Air Force in 1990.
We lost to a putz team in a putz bowl.
This proud football program couldn't have sunk any lower.
Wow, Charlotte I'm very surprised at your choice. I would have thought that anybody who witnessed them would have to select either the 1969 scUm game, or the 1976 Rose Bowl. Those 2 were the most painful for me. Certain NC's lost in the last game of the season. (1969 team would not have gone to a Bowl).

I guess it depends whether someone looks at the question as to whether it's the 'most painful' or 'most embarrassing' loss. Your choice was a very embarrassing game, but personally I've always felt the lost glory of a sure NC, when you know you're the bettter team, was rougher to take.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Back
Top