Value City Arena will be rocking this afternoon during pregame introductions. Based on experience, the place will go bonkers when most of the Ohio State players are introduced, particularly crowd favorites Deshaun Thomas and Aaron Craft, then the noise will be cut in half when coach Thad Matta is called, a “din” just above “polite applause.”
This isn’t new and definitely isn’t the creation of a 19-7 season that seems “down” compared with three 30-victory seasons in the previous six. There are no boos for Matta, but there doesn’t seem to be much love, either. It has been this way for a while now, maybe from the beginning, and it seems, well, odd.
Of Matta’s eight previous Ohio State teams, five have won at least a share of the Big Ten title, including the last three. They have won three conference tournament titles and have gone to two Final Fours. His teams have won 20 games every season except this one, a mark that can be reached today with a victory over No. 4 Michigan State.Yet, he is generally treated by a lot of fans as more of a caretaker than a facilitator, as if all of the terrific players he has recruited would have somehow found their way to the Schottenstein Center anyway.
Like most coaches, Matta becomes a focal point of his critics during “down” seasons, even one that almost certainly will result in an NCAA bid that has seemed almost automatic since he arrived from Xavier in 2004.
As the critics wonder why he can’t get an offense that is missing first-team All-American Jared Sullinger and sharpshooter William Buford from last season to play better, it seems almost mandatory to ask whether Matta gets enough credit.
“Honestly, I would say no,” junior guard Lenzelle Smith Jr. said. “This season has been really tough for us and whenever we have a tough season like this, I think a lot of the fans or critics point to him. In reality, it has nothing to do with him. “He’s constantly asking us this year what does he need to do for us to play better for us to win, but at the end of the day, it’s on us. We’re the ones out there. We’ve got to put the ball in the bucket. He can’t do it for us.