Well Caleb Downs plays defense, so not sure where that logic comes from.
Precisely, so why did you bring that approach to this conversation?
Why in the world would mistakes as a kick returner affect their snaps at their actual positions? You could have brought Egbuka in to field punts or kickoffs for the rest of the game. That would be understandable. It would be remarkably foolish to take safety snaps away from Caleb for that mistake, or not use Henderson's feet and creativity in the passing game because he can't return kicks.
You can't have it both ways. You can say Ryan Day blew it with a shitty game plan - oh, but thank goodness our leader was able to carry the ball repeatedly for 2 yards a pop. And also screw up royally on a kickoff return when all you have to do is catch the ball and signal fair catch.
Judkins and Henderson basically had the same number of carries (12 versus 10). That is a total joke. But sure, gotta give to the veteran Buckeye because that's the "nice" coaching thing to do.
Do tell, why can't I have these things both ways?
- Good idea: Using Treveyon as a receiver for a defense daring you to complete 4-9 yd passes to sustain drives and a QB feeling pressure and pressing a bit
- Bad idea: repeatedly running into the teeth of 2 elite DTs with backup IOL and a RB who is a gamebreaker in space but is not as steady in a phone booth
Meanwhile you're over here waxing poetic about 3.8 ypc for some reason. Quinshod is better at grinding out yardage. Neither of them were particularly efficient yesterday, because they tried to slam their talented 2 RBs into an elite wall and never adjusted.
The only quality run from either of them came when Chip remembered he could outflank the defense, and he ran a speed option to Quinshod for the easiest 15 yards of the day. They never tried anything like that again. The other 11 rushes into the phone booth went for 3.1 ypc with Q.
Kind of like the easy screen to Treveyon. That never returned.
Think Meyer would have done that?
Oh look, another random thing that has nothing to do with the conversation.
But let's accept your outlandish claim about TH vs Q for a moment. Do I think Meyer can underutilize a RB in a critical ball game? Is that a serious question?