• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Should the U. S. national anthem be sung in a language other than English?

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 5.9%
  • No

    Votes: 51 75.0%
  • I really don't care

    Votes: 13 19.1%

  • Total voters
    68
  • Poll closed .
Funny, but I could've swore I read somewhere that our founding fathers had a vote over which language--English or German--would be our official language, and English won by a single vote.

Its not law mandating our "official language" to be English. As of right now, only West Virginia passed a law stating English would be the "official language", but it was a line item in a much bigger article about education. Most of the legislature didn't even read that line and passed the bill. And then went ape shit when they realized they had been duped.
 
Upvote 0
The Latino community love this country and have died for it.
Why would we denie them their language and an expression of love for this country?
I think it sounds wonderful.
But, I'm a commie.............:tongue2:
 
Upvote 0
The Latino community love this country and have died for it.
Why would we denie them their language and an expression of love for this country?
I think it sounds wonderful.
But, I'm a commie.............:tongue2:

No one is trying to deny anyone their right to speak a foreign language. The point is whether or not this country's national anthem should be learned and sung in this country's language.
 
Upvote 0
No one is trying to deny anyone their right to speak a foreign language. The point is whether or not this country's national anthem should be learned and sung in this country's language.

I think we should worry about getting all the people chosen to sing the anthem at sporting events to learn how to sing it properly in English before worrying about how Jose Immigrant is singing it.
 
Upvote 0
Its not law mandating our "official language" to be English. As of right now, only West Virginia passed a law stating English would be the "official language", but it was a line item in a much bigger article about education. Most of the legislature didn't even read that line and passed the bill. And then went ape shit when they realized they had been duped.

offiicial language is set at the state level, not the national. though that conscept does seem a little odd. 27 states "official language" is english. ohio is one of the non decided unfortunately.

(west virginia has also set its official language to english)
Alabama (1990) – constitutional amendment adopted by voter initiative
Alaska (1998) – initiative statute; ruled unconstitutional in state superior court, March 22, 2002; full text of ruling
Arizona (1988) – constitutional amendment adopted by voter initiative; ruled unconstitutional by federal district and appellate courts, decisions vacated on March 3, 1997 by the U.S. Supreme Court; then overturned as unconstitutional by the Arizona Supreme Court on April 28, 1998; U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear English-only proponents' final appeal on January 11, 1999
Arkansas (1987) – statute
California (1986)– constitutional amendment adopted by voter initiative
Colorado (1988)– constitutional amendment adopted by voter initiative
Florida (1988)– constitutional amendment adopted by voter initiative
Georgia (1996)– statute
Hawai`i (1978)– constitutional amendment declaring the state officially bilingual – recognizing English and Native Hawaiian as official languages
Iowa (2002) – statute
Illinois (1969)– statute repealing a 1923 declaration of "American" as the official state language and adopting English
Indiana (1984) – statute
Kentucky (1984)– statute
Mississippi (1987)– statute
Missouri (1998) – statute
Montana (1995)– statute
Nebraska (1923)– constitutional amendment
New Hampshire (1995) – statute
North Carolina (1987)– statute
North Dakota (1987)– statute
South Carolina (1987)– statute
South Dakota (1995)– statute
Tennessee (1984)– statute
Utah (2000) – initiative statute; appeal by ACLU dropped
Virginia (1981)– statute, revised in 1996
Wyoming (1996)– statute
Oklahoma (2003)–

ok people, noone is saying a law should be passed making it illegal for a hispanic to walk down the street signing the national anthem in spanish. im sure someone already has and ya know what? 99.999999% of us couldn't give two shits. what does bother me personally is the idea of changing the wording of the song and having it sung in spanish for an audience. that doesn't mean i find any ethnic group or language lacking in anyway. simply that i feel the national anthem is one of the things you just don't fuck with. it would be like tbdbitl rapping their way through script ohio.

These kids have no parents, cause all of these mean laws ... let's not start a war with all these hard workers, they can't help where they were born"

wow... amazingly powerful those lyrics are.. written by a 3rd grader im guessing. mean laws? yeah, those laws were written specifically to hurt hispanics... yep, thats exactly it. your being persecuted by us "mean" whities because of where your from. its good to know that you hard workers will break our laws anytime you find them inconveniant.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
I think we should worry about getting all the people chosen to sing the anthem at sporting events to learn how to sing it properly in English before worrying about how Jose Immigrant is singing it.

I think a better idea would be get rid of the stupid idea of singing it in the first place at sporting events.
I was worried that the idiotic singing of God Bless America would become standard at 7th inning stretches, but thank God that most cities have stopped it.
I want to get drunk and eat - not waste my time removing my hat to sing a song that has nothing to do with sports.
 
Upvote 0
This has nothing to do with the Star Spangled Banner per se, but I watched a girls' softball game at our neighborhood park yesterday, and I found it fascinating that the coaches were yelling out instructions to the kids in both English and Spanish. It was so cool! It made me think about how much I missed out on by growing up in an all-white community. I would have liked to have gone to school, played sports, etc. with a diverse group of kids.

Scooter, I echo your sentiments regarding the SSB. Great posts.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top