Basically, as long as we don't ask for a set price, and it is reinforced that it is a free gift for registering with buckeyeplanet (as a temporary deal at the spring game) I think we could probably be ok if we're only making like $5 from the stingy donations I doubt anyone would complain. A high-quality color 8x11" print, dvd case and dvd is very reasonable for $5. And that is if you are valuing the dvd media with nothing on it.
Couple of ideas, maybe we should get someone to get a downloaded, local version of buckeyeplanet so that people could browse and see what the forum is like.
Obviously if we showed some key threads like the Gwaltney thread, the ESPiN category, the daily tOSU news articles (3yards'), some of our multimedia stuff (wallpaper, dvd case), and such we could probably make some people realize what a great website it is and would feel better about making a donation to a website they've never seen (fi the dvd wasn't enough). Just another idea if we don't go with the color laser printer idea (which would allow us to print an absurd number of prints for a lot less than other efforts, like my personal bubblejet printer).