• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Rich Rodriguez (official thread of last laughs)

Read HTM's post above its the same thing really.

They are just so saturated with this stuff they don't even want to discuss it or acknowledge it anymore. We eventually got this way with MoC, yep he's a fuckwad and an embarrassment lets move on type of thing.

Doesn't make it less real to the outside world, they are just past the point of feeling pain in regards to RR...that is untill the season starts. :biggrin:
I don't recall anybody just dismissing MoC stuff as "you guys already think he's the devil, so I'm ignoring you". That's a pretty lame spin.
 
Upvote 0
BuckeyeNation27;1142801; said:
I don't recall anybody just dismissing MoC stuff as "you guys already think he's the devil, so I'm ignoring you". That's a pretty lame spin.

Agree 100% thats its about as lame a response as one can come up with.
 
Upvote 0
HailToMichigan;1143008; said:
You asked for one. What would you like me to say? Did the affidavit change your opinion of RR at all?
Perhaps give your opinion? Who cares what we think? You obviously don't form your opinions based on what opposite-colored fans think... so why suddenly make that a central focus when you chime in?
 
Upvote 0
HailToMichigan;1143008; said:
You asked for one. What would you like me to say? Did the affidavit change your opinion of RR at all?


I would like somewhat objective people to start even possibly entertaining the idea that maybe, just maybe, all this smoke is actually from a fire.

I'd like to see the point where self respecting UM fans stop comparing RR in any way shape or form to Bo other than the fact they were both coaches at the same school. I hated Bo and Carr as coaches of the enemy but I had almost no doubt, less than no doubt in Bo's case, that both were honorable men. I don't see any way in hell anyone with a shred of objectivity can honestly say the same about RR.

What I really can't wait to hear I will probably never actually hear a scUM fan say. The day when scUM nation has to fess up and admit they replayed the IU/Kelvin Sampson saga in attempt to win again and that they don't sit on nearly as high a horse as they once thought they did.
 
Upvote 0
jwinslow;1143014; said:
Perhaps give your opinion? Who cares what we think? You obviously don't form your opinions based on what opposite-colored fans think... so why suddenly make that a central focus when you chime in?
Does this not count as an opinion? I rather thought it did.

And I'm pretty sure I've said on multiple occasions: I'm tired of the lawsuit because "RR is not handling it particularly well" (a direct quote from the link above) and none of it makes our coach look any good. The affidavit is lawsuit business and another example of RR not handling it well, so I see nothing very new, only more of the same. So my opinion doesn't change either.
 
Upvote 0
Does this not count as an opinion? I rather thought it did.
I wasn't clear*, I was answering 'what we want you to say' so to speak. What I meant was that shifting the discussion to what we think is a bit of a diversion. I did appreciate that response, and Roger and I think alike at times :wink:

* - I should've said 'just give your opinion, not ours' or something like that.
 
Upvote 0
Jaxbuck;1143024; said:
I would like somewhat objective people to start even possibly entertaining the idea that maybe, just maybe, all this smoke is actually from a fire.

I'd like to see the point where self respecting UM fans stop comparing RR in any way shape or form to Bo other than the fact they were both coaches at the same school. I hated Bo and Carr as coaches of the enemy but I had almost no doubt, less than no doubt in Bo's case, that both were honorable men. I don't see any way in hell anyone with a shred of objectivity can honestly say the same about RR.

What I really can't wait to hear I will probably never actually hear a scUM fan say. The day when scUM nation has to fess up and admit they replayed the IU/Kelvin Sampson saga in attempt to win again and that they don't sit on nearly as high a horse as they once thought they did.
You cannot compare Kelvin Sampson to Rich Rodriguez until Rodriguez actually commits a violation. You might have solid ground to criticize his character based on his handling of the buyout but you have no leg to stand on at all if you try to accuse RR of violating any laws or NCAA rules. Indiana hired a coach under sanction. RR's slate is clean.

Edit for addition: I can sit here and admit "where there's smoke there's fire" all you like. If it makes you happy, I can pretend to agree with you 100%. It doesn't change the fact that I'm gonna root for the greatest success for him and his football team. Where's the principles and the high horse if I condemn the guy as a scumbag out of one side of my mouth and cheer his successes on the field out of the other? My concern here is Michigan football. (And basketball, hockey, etc.) Insofar as he has not yet dirtied the name of Michigan football with academic cheating scandals as with Florida State, recruiting violations, flouting sanctions as with Sampson at Indiana, pretending felonies never happened as with Neuheisel at UW, or such other things as would drag the program through the mud, I see no reason yet to throw the man to the wolves. When - not if - he is successful, I believe he will have done so without cheating to bring in recruits or keep them eligible. I like that Michigan football has been as successful as they have almost entirely without such shenanigans, unlike, say, Florida State or Texas A&M and given RR's clean track record, I believe it will stay that way.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
HailToMichigan;1143032; said:
You cannot compare Kelvin Sampson to Rich Rodriguez until Rodriguez actually commits a violation. You might have solid ground to criticize his character based on his handling of the buyout but you have no leg to stand on at all if you try to accuse RR of violating any laws or NCAA rules. Indiana hired a coach under sanction. RR's slate is clean.


Reputable people at this site who would know have posted that they have seen RR violate recruiting rules with their own two eyes. That well respected members opinion at the time was that things he got away with at WVU will not go unnoticed at UM.

RR is a man of low moral charachter as is Sampson. RR will no more change who he is because he changed jobs than Sampson did.

There is no doubt in my mind RR will not only bring shame to your program off the field he will not bring the level of success on the field that many scUM fans are praying for.

These are the reasons in my opinion you can put one of these ( = ) between the names Rodriguez and Sampson.
 
Upvote 0
Jaxbuck;1143039; said:
Reputable people at this site who would know have posted that they have seen RR violate recruiting rules with their own two eyes. That well respected members opinion at the time was that things he got away with at WVU will not go unnoticed at UM.
Wait a moment! You mean current, future, and former players, as well as their parents, families, and high school coaches post on this site?

Who knew?! :wink2:
 
Upvote 0
Frankly HTM I'm calling BS on your whole stance that the lawsuit is the only thing about RR with which you take issue - characterizing RR's handling of the same as poor.

HailToMichigan;1142610; said:
{HTM Filters Out Buckeyes Saying Bad things About RR Unless ..} Lawsuit .... RR is not handling it particularly well, {snip}
Thus (to answer buckiprof) it got wearisome a while ago, but being tired of the lawsuit business and being tired of the coach are two different things.

You bundle the affidavit together with the contract buy-out lawsuit. That is a mistake, they are completely different matters. The affidavit was taken as part of the investigation by WVU into Magee's racism claim - not in pursuit of evidence pro or con the buy-out suit.

What about this, instead of responding to something that wasn't really asked (when are you tired of RR) instead talk to what is really at issue?
When - aside from the lawsuit - did you hear of, or see reported actions, words, statements about RR that would cause you to question his values or character?

You would have us believe that it didn't happen with this affidavit - barely credible in my view, certainly the statements made are a clear cause for concern.

You would have us believe that you have forgotten or have dismissed the manner in which he exited WVU, about which there was substantial reporting and blogging - why, because I'm so tired of it :tibor:.

You would have us believe that RR phoning Pryor before his meeting with the WVU administration - truth of which is demonstrated by the original times given in the Scout article about the same - that this means nothing to you, it isn't a red flag. Why? Perhaps that falls under you dismissing out of hand any criticism of RR that emanates from either Columbus or from WVU territory. If so, then it means you are blinkering your view of the new guy in town - it becomes then only about winning at any cost.

The above would be reason enough to call BS. But then there is the little matter of common sense - the matter of contrast old and new - the matter of TSUN holding their standards and head high in the past, and their inability to really do so now. At least not without ignoring all the contrary evidence.

One case in point from a Buckeye perspective. Let us call it the grudging acceptance of Cooper.

After Bruce was fired Cooper was hired, in large part I remember, because of his win as HC at Az. State against TSUN in the Rose Bowl.

Bruce was widely admired, despite the travails of the football team on the field. Same I believe can be said about Carr. Cooper had some shoes to fill in terms of winning (Buckeyes wanted those championships, wanted those Rose Bowl appearances and certainly wanted to beat TSUN). Buckeye fans also wanted to be sure about their new leader's ability to step up as a representative of The Ohio State University. There was suspicion about Cooper's winning credentials amongst some Buckeye fans, one Rose Bowl win doth not a dynasty make. But, what raised eyebrows first around Columbus was an apparently minor deviation for Cooper from past behavior, but it was a major sign to fans that things were very, very different in terms of the coaches character.

Hot Tubs, Giant Eagle - commercialization and shilling to fatten his purse.


All of it perfectly legal, much of it happening elsewhere in the country at that time (read SEC, read PAC-10 country). But, still enough of a deviation from the community oriented and modest approach embodied by Bruce, and Hayes before him, that it put Cooper on thin ice, with me and with many others I know of.

Yet you would have us believe that the far worse things surrounding RR are not a cause for you to question his character?
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Another thing I find hilarious about many scUM fans (not the visitors here necessarily) is how they hammered JT and tOSU for recruiting Pat Lazear two years ago (even when no actual offer was on the table from tOSU), yet dismiss the fact DickRod actually took him on out of hand. Not to mention the questionable recruitment and acceptance of Noel Devine. They hide behind statements like "he won't be able to do that at UM". Really? The fact that he did go after these type of recruits should say something to them, but it doesn't. There was also the questionable handling of Chris Henry and his on field antics at WVU. This guy has red flags all around him, yet Bill martin still hired him after a whirlwind courtship after Les Miles made it clear he wasn't going to be heading to aa. Did Martin do the necessary homework in those few short days? Is he NOT so desperate to change the on-field product that he will tie DickRod's hands, preventing him from the style of recruiting that made him successful at WVU?

If all of this doesn't make you at least somewhat skeptical of your new coach as a man, I don't know what to say.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top