I don't think it's wise to comapare TP to Troy Smith, or Vince Young, or any one else. Terrelle Pryor is not Troy Smith nor is he Vince Young, he's Terrell Pryor.
While I certainly understand that the progression of the two QB's may be compared at their same, relative points in time (sophmore seasons), these are simply two entirely different athletes with differing cirumstances.
Without listing a mirage of statistics btwn the two athletes, I think it's fair to say that while Troy Smith struggled as a sophmore, just as TP is, you could really see the potential in Troy in terms of being a natural QB combined with his athletic ability. Troy's mechanics were rarely questioned, he used is feet very well coming out of his drops, and was able to move up into the pocket. He didn't throw off of his back foot (consistently) and his release was consistent. He had some accuracy issues in 2004, but I beleive he threw a more consistent ball than TP currently does. Troy's biggest flaw was his decision making, trying to decifer when to throw versus when to run versus when to throw the ball away.
I truly believe that TP will improve going forward, he has 2 and a half more years to figure it out. Terrelle just has different issues than Troy had. His decision making abilities (or lack thereof) have been criticized (ad nauseum), and that is clearly his biggest hurdle. I think TP still has a long way to go in terms of his mechanics, which means the difference between hitting his receivers between the numbers or throwing an interception. His foot work is poor, he throws off of his back foot the majority of the time he's in the pocket, hence his accuracy is inconsistent.
I'm not convinced that this current offensive design is the right way to move forward with TP as the QB. I don't understand why we continue to line up 4 and 5 wide and ask TP to make a first, second, and possibly third read, when the kid is struggling mentally, especially this past Saturday. Everyone has a bad game, and TP had a bad game vs Purdue. He's allowed to make mistakes, just not 5 times over. He's clearly shaken at this point.
I know these points have been made over and over by now, but there is a reason for that. The bottom line is, what we're doing offensively is not working. In fact, it's progressively getting worse. It's nearly impossible for a team to make major adjustments to their scheme/philosophy in the middle of the season, so, don't expect much to change schematically. That leaves the players, it's up to them to figure it out. They have to do the work on the field. But when it's 1st and 2 at the goaline, and you can't punch the ball in the end zone after 3 downs, there is a big, big problem there.
I'm anxious to see how we respond this week.