• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

QB Tavien St. Clair (Official Thread)

I think what we are seeing is that the big dual threat QB takes too long to develop to Day's standard to be playable in time. Like Keinholz transferred before he was ready for Ohio State. TSC probably transfers too. Then the small QBs who are ready to step in have a limited ceiling.

LK was on schedule. He was a project coming out of Dakota HS football and is starting and playing well in his 4th year.

Have I missed something with TSC? Is he actually a dual threat? From what I’ve seen, he runs like CJ.
 
Upvote 0
LK was on schedule. He was a project coming out of Dakota HS football and is starting and playing well in his 4th year.

Have I missed something with TSC? Is he actually a dual threat? From what I’ve seen, he runs like CJ.
TSC isn’treally a Dual threat IMo. He’s a big kid who can move the pocket and run some guys over. But he’s more in the vein of Cardale. Cannon arm and big bodied QB who can lay the wood on a defender. When I think of Dual threat, I think of Braxton,Fields and even Troy
 
Upvote 0
And tOSU claims both of them, much like Joe Burrows....

OSU fans only claim Burrow because the legacy of OSU QBs in the NFL is so poor, you take what you can get.

Look at Jameson Williams of the Lions. He did more at OSU than Burrow ever did and nobody talks about him being from OSU - because we have enough WRs that spent their entire career and are tearing up the NFL.
 
Upvote 0
LK was on schedule. He was a project coming out of Dakota HS football and is starting and playing well in his 4th year.

Have I missed something with TSC? Is he actually a dual threat? From what I’ve seen, he runs like CJ.

LK might have been on schedule for who he was but for the program and how the Day has built the QB room, the projects and the 5 stars aren't lining up to give us proper depth.

LK might have been ready to play last season but he was never needed. Someone needed to be ready to step in this season to be a ready backup. It's not the first time this happen, Devin Brown wasn't ready to backup McCord. Now Fahey and TSC aren't ready.

I truly don't know the solution for this era of college football but how Day has built the QB room, it's not working. Maybe they are picking guys that need too much development to step in or they have the timing of which recruiting classes they are coming are wrong or they need to figure out portal QBs that can bridge the gap. I think they just need to reevaluate how they are building the QB room so the playable depth is better.
 
Upvote 0
LK might have been on schedule for who he was but for the program and how the Day has built the QB room, the projects and the 5 stars aren't lining up to give us proper depth.

LK might have been ready to play last season but he was never needed. Someone needed to be ready to step in this season to be a ready backup. It's not the first time this happen, Devin Brown wasn't ready to backup McCord. Now Fahey and TSC aren't ready.

I truly don't know the solution for this era of college football but how Day has built the QB room, it's not working. Maybe they are picking guys that need too much development to step in or they have the timing of which recruiting classes they are coming are wrong or they need to figure out portal QBs that can bridge the gap. I think they just need to reevaluate how they are building the QB room so the playable depth is better.
With the Portal and NiL I think every program is going to be like this. At almost all top teams, the backup is either an older kid who had modest success somewhere and is there to be a placeholder for a year or 2, or it’s a former high rated true frosh or 2nd year player that’s barely ever played. I don’t think anyone can name a backup for any top 5 team in the country. heck, most OSU fans didn’t know who Fahey was, most didn’t even know who Sayin was when Howard was starting.

Also, with the Portal, your next best offensive weapon may not arrive until January so he only has 8mos to build a rapport with the offense, OC and Day. No one cares about the backup QB until he’s needed, yet he’s never given starter reps and plays with the starters because so much time is needed to mesh. Sayin had to focus this off season on getting JJ the ball in every way possible, but then learning how to incorporate McCuin who he just met, and then learning a new playbook from Smith. I think to see success going forward in this new era with constantly changing rosters, is to hire OCs with simplified playbooks that focus on getting the ball to your playmakers fast. Almost like the old Urban system but with less reliance on running the QB. There should be a system like how he used Leak and Tebow together for Fahey and TSC. If all TSC can do is one read, then give him that read and if it’s closed then pull it and run. The NFL type OC just isn’t working, when they want to play a chess match, and these guys don’t play together long enough like in the NFL where guys have multi year contracts
 
Upvote 0
With the Portal and NiL I think every program is going to be like this. At almost all top teams, the backup is either an older kid who had modest success somewhere and is there to be a placeholder for a year or 2, or it’s a former high rated true frosh or 2nd year player that’s barely ever played. I don’t think anyone can name a backup for any top 5 team in the country. heck, most OSU fans didn’t know who Fahey was, most didn’t even know who Sayin was when Howard was starting.

Also, with the Portal, your next best offensive weapon may not arrive until January so he only has 8mos to build a rapport with the offense, OC and Day. No one cares about the backup QB until he’s needed, yet he’s never given starter reps and plays with the starters because so much time is needed to mesh. Sayin had to focus this off season on getting JJ the ball in every way possible, but then learning how to incorporate McCuin who he just met, and then learning a new playbook from Smith. I think to see success going forward in this new era with constantly changing rosters, is to hire OCs with simplified playbooks that focus on getting the ball to your playmakers fast. Almost like the old Urban system but with less reliance on running the QB. There should be a system like how he used Leak and Tebow together for Fahey and TSC. If all TSC can do is one read, then give him that read and if it’s closed then pull it and run. The NFL type OC just isn’t working, when they want to play a chess match, and these guys don’t play together long enough like in the NFL where guys have multi year contracts
It’s the only logical way.

Having a more simple system that allows you to have more optionally with the talent you plug in gives more way to win. More options = more durable, robust.

Day has run the NFL prep school approach and the talent has been breathtakingly successful BUT it’s more breakable when things change quick at the most important position on the field which is still QB.

You could continue that IF you can build a better QB bench. I don’t see how you do that with NIL and a 5 year clock.

No one with experience is going to come sit unless they are not starter quality. You can get the elite HS talent stacked for a year or two but then it’s going to want to play. Here or somewhere else.

I don’t see any issue continuing to have a top tier starter but the back up is either going to be inexperienced and talented or experienced and limited on talent.

I really don’t see how you get around that so the only mitigation is fill the room with the same kind of guy. This year fell apart because the primary backup can’t run the same offense as the starter and not just because of inexperience. He can’t physically do it.
 
Upvote 0
Recruiting college quarterbacks, even if 'all world' is still a gamble. Building them up for a year or two is essential, and they'll separate themselves eventually. The big guess is deciding which ones to nurture, and which ones to 'have the talk' with. LK was always going to be a backup in tOSU plans, given the talent at QB with him. He joined up anyway, got some good training, and voila, is making waves at his new place. Great for him. For whatever reason, and not certain anyone outside the Woody really knows, TSC has not risen to the challenge. That leaves a void (as we're seeing), in case of injury to QB1. Stuff happens. But some writers above are correct. Cannot recruit two 'all worlds' and expend the resources needed to secure, and forego other positions/needs etc. Believe that Day will go to the portal in December, but that's after this season has expired. Not Fahety's fault. If he's the pick to play, what's going on with the coaching and/or the other QB backups? Usually, a 'project' gets some minutes in a game, to showcase him, or just finalize a decision whether he's gonna be the guy here or elsewhere. That's not remotely happening. Maybe someone can make sense of this mess, and as I reread this post, it isn't me. Go Bucks!
 
Upvote 0
It’s the only logical way.

Having a more simple system that allows you to have more optionally with the talent you plug in gives more way to win. More options = more durable, robust.

The main concern I have with this is that defenses have been getting better and more complex recently. I imagine there are some simple answers to that, but simplifying makes me think of something parallel to Meyer’s system that eventually can’t compete with very good defense.

Not sure how feasible this is, but they could try and teach young guys a proto-offense that can be upgraded as they learn, but would be much easier to play if they had to start.

I don’t think there is one good answer, and it’ll change on a year-by-year basis.
 
Upvote 0
The main concern I have with this is that defenses have been getting better and more complex recently. I imagine there are some simple answers to that, but simplifying makes me think of something parallel to Meyer’s system that eventually can’t compete with very good defense.

Not sure how feasible this is, but they could try and teach young guys a proto-offense that can be upgraded as they learn, but would be much easier to play if they had to start.

I don’t think there is one good answer, and it’ll change on a year-by-year basis.
But in college, defense really haven't gotten more complex. They are in the NFL, but with the Portal there isn't many complex schemes anymore. If you watch say UGA or Miam, they just have freaks on the DL who consistently rush the passer. OSU is one of the few schools trying to do complex things with their DL. IU is just using twists and stunts, but thats not exactly a complex technique to learn. Many defenses sit in zone now as opposed to mixing it up with zone and man. Its hard to implement a complex scheme when you can only teach it for about 6-8mos before the season starts
 
Upvote 0
But in college, defense really haven't gotten more complex. They are in the NFL, but with the Portal there isn't many complex schemes anymore. If you watch say UGA or Miam, they just have freaks on the DL who consistently rush the passer. OSU is one of the few schools trying to do complex things with their DL. IU is just using twists and stunts, but thats not exactly a complex technique to learn. Many defenses sit in zone now as opposed to mixing it up with zone and man. Its hard to implement a complex scheme when you can only teach it for about 6-8mos before the season starts
Can you explain this to Patricia…..asking for a friend
 
Upvote 0
Recruiting college quarterbacks, even if 'all world' is still a gamble. Building them up for a year or two is essential, and they'll separate themselves eventually. The big guess is deciding which ones to nurture, and which ones to 'have the talk' with. LK was always going to be a backup in tOSU plans, given the talent at QB with him. He joined up anyway, got some good training, and voila, is making waves at his new place. Great for him. For whatever reason, and not certain anyone outside the Woody really knows, TSC has not risen to the challenge. That leaves a void (as we're seeing), in case of injury to QB1. Stuff happens. But some writers above are correct. Cannot recruit two 'all worlds' and expend the resources needed to secure, and forego other positions/needs etc. Believe that Day will go to the portal in December, but that's after this season has expired. Not Fahety's fault. If he's the pick to play, what's going on with the coaching and/or the other QB backups? Usually, a 'project' gets some minutes in a game, to showcase him, or just finalize a decision whether he's gonna be the guy here or elsewhere. That's not remotely happening. Maybe someone can make sense of this mess, and as I reread this post, it isn't me. Go Bucks!
I'm definitely not in the Woody, but I posted what Mark Porter said, and he's very known in the recruiting sphere in OH. TSC was a 5star based on his ceiling and physical tools, not on what he currently was. TSC was throwing to 5-7 160lbs TE and had a 5-8 150lbs RB, so you can tell the type of talent he had and was playing against. He more than likely had a 1 read offense, and then could take off. At 230lbs in the country he's bigger and faster than most of the conference, and he's playing kids that will probably be working on farms or at the local Walmart. So coming to a program the size of OSU, he had the uphill learning curve to adapt to defenders now being 6-5 270lbs and as fast as him, as opposed to a 5-10 170lbs DE who was dirt slow
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top